Take her virginity

There really isn't much of a decision. While the thought of getting to stretch her tight little ass out is hard to pass up, getting to be the one to take her virginity is a no brainer. You had only had sex with one virgin, and that was when both of you were too young and dumb to even know what was going on. It was awkward and painful, and although she had asked for it, she dumped you afterwards.

"I want to make you a woman," you whisper to Kelsi, who bites her lip and nods.

You slide on top of her, pinning her hands to the bed over her head as you kiss her. Your cock is penned between your bodies, so you use it to gently dry hump her clit as you make out. You love who she moans into your mouth with each thrust.

"Oh...fuck it hurts," Lisa said from the vent. "At least use some lube."

"It should hurt, as punishment for parading around in front of our company with that gown on," Derek said.

"It's not like he hasn't licked my ass before," Lisa said, followed by a moan of pain.

"For that comment, you don't get any lube," he said.

"Oh daddy, you know how I like it," she moaned. "Raw fuck my tight little ass, baby. You know I live to serve that cock."

Then there were just grunts and moans from both of them as Derek apparently raw dogged her unlubricated asshole.

With that picture in your head, you lined up your cock with Kelsi's nubile little pussy and pressed gently into her until you felt resistance. She moaned and squirmed beneath you, but you didn't break this kiss. Your tongues wrestled as you slowly added pressure, trying your hardest to be gentle because you knew this was a moment she would remember for the rest of her life.

Almost to slowly to be real, you felt her hymen give way and your cock slid slowly into her virgin hole. Kelsi screamed into your mouth, but you kept your lips pressed together to muffle the sound. By the time your cock was all the way in, she was already cumming. She was also crying.

"I'll lay her for a minute and not move," you whispered to her. "The pain will pass, I promise. And the next time it won't hurt at all."

She bit her lip and nodded. You kissed her gently on the forehead and held her as you listened to her parents have rough anal sex next door.

"I think I'm ready," she said after a little time had passed. She was still cumming around your cock.

"Are you sure?" you asked and she just nodded.

And so you fucked her. There were no more thoughts of your poor faithful wife at home alone with the kids, just the nubile young pussy at the end of your cock. It was the most amazing sex ever, with her continually cumming around your cock as you pounded her. You continued to kiss as she moaned, now mostly in pleasure.

Your intention has been to pull out and cum on her tits or face, but you had no control over your own body. You just fucked her until there was no turning back, then exploded inside of her. The sensation of your seed filling her insides was all she could take, and Kelsi's pussy clamped down on your cock like a vise as she had what Kelly called "the big one." You were both trying not to moan aloud as you have her her first creampie.

When your were spent you gently pulled your cock out of her and kissed her on the cheek.

"I love you, Uncle Jason," she said with a weak smile.

"I love you too, sweety," you whispered back to her.

Through the vents, you hear the sound of Derek and Lisa climaxing as you wrap your arms around her and hold her. She smiled and melted into you.

It was in that moment that the full weight of what you had just done desended on you. Not only had you cheated on your wife, you had cheated on your wife by having unprotected sex with your best friend's barely legal virgin daughter who was also like a niece to you. Yeah, you were probably going to hell for that, of hell was real. You promised yourself this was never going to happen again.

But as you lay there holding her, she turned and looked at you with those same eyes and you felt it all melt away. There was something in the submissive, backwards and slightly innocent way that she looked at you that was like a ****. You knew in that moment that this would in fact happen again and again because you couldn't resist that look. It was like a ****.