Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 28 by 0Faceinthecrowd0 0Faceinthecrowd0

What's next?

Suspended Love, Day 1: Part 3

Zack was a bit stunned at what Amber had just confessed to him. He surely hadn’t been able to stop himself when in similar situations with Ashley and Scarlett. To him this felt a bit different because unlike those two girls, Amber just admitted that she was a virgin and surely that meant a lot more.

“Your first?” Zack could only repeat with shallow breath. Amber nodded assertively as she bit her lower lip and stared into his eyes with her mesmerized brown eyes. Zack was still a bit hesitant, but the word “no” never did come out of his mouth. Amber decided to make it a bit more tempting as she wrapped her soft, bare leg around his and snaked her dainty hand down to his shorts covered dick. Her hand found its target and squeezed his prick as she began to move her hand up and down while still begging for an answer with her eyes. The split guy could only let out a hard exhale as he lowered his forehead onto hers and never once broke the gaze.

“You’re sure you want this?”

“Uh huh! I really want this, Zack.”

“How do you know you won’t regret it?”

“Because I trust you.” Amber continued just as confidently as when she first told him she wanted to have sex. Her hand is now picking up more speed and rubbing up and down the full length of his shaft. She now began to lift her hips upward into him, **** to convince him of her desire. Even through Zack’s shorts, he could feel the warmth and wetness of Amber’s bare and trimmed vagina gyrating against his leg. She squeezed her leg tighter against his and brought his body down flush against hers. “Do you need me to suck it first to get you in the mood? I will if that’ll make you turned on but it certainly feels ready.” Amber let out a faint moan as her hand could barely fit around the outline of his dick.

Zack was sure that if his dick was any harder at this point, it would probably shatter. It also slightly hurt him that this sweet girl still thinks she’d have to service him for him to be into her. In his mind, Amber is a beautiful girl who any guy at school would be lucky to have and slightly scolded himself for taking this long to notice. He cleared his mind of any thoughts of how this could impact them moving forward and convinced himself that he wanted to prove to her just how desirable she is. Zack gently reached down and lifted her chin until bringing his face down to hers and giving her a soft kiss. His other hand slipped underneath the girl’s back and unhooked her bra, the only remaining piece of clothing that she had on. Amber’s chest heaved and she smiled widely at his silent acceptance as he made his next move. The slower and sensual speed was unique to her as other high school guys had attacked her body like a wild animal. Zack on the other hand, seemed in full control and lightly trailed his fingers around as if he was taking the time to truly explore her. The focused guy smoothly slid the bra off the front of her body and tossed it onto the ground. He danced his fingers across her chest and lightly circled around her bare nipple as his lips had sunk to her neck, both leaving light kisses and nibbles down to her collarbone. Amber panted harder and at this rate felt like she might cum again simply from his foreplay. As much as she was enjoying his touch, her patience ran out and she needed him now.

“Zack, I really want you inside me. I need it!” Zack released her and sat up as he turned towards his wallet. He was pretty sure he still had a condom in there that his uncle Malcolm had given to him for times just like this.

“Ok let me grab a condom.” Zack said trying to calm the insatiable girl, only for Amber to firmly grab his hand and pull him right back on top of her.

“Oh, we don’t need that. My mom got me the pill just in case. She doesn’t always trust my decision making.” Amber said with a slight giggle. “Tanya said once at cheer practice, that it’s so much better without one. I really want to feel you.” Zack’s lust had fully taken over and that was satisfying enough to him. He unbuckled and removed his shorts as his boxers now remained the only thing between their two bodies. Amber sat up and helped push his boxers down, unable to take it any longer. Her eyes sprung open as his cock bounced out from behind the cloth and waved just above her belly button. ‘Holy shit! How’s that going to fit?’

As Amber was mesmerized and slightly afraid at his size, Zack removed the boxers all together and gently laid himself on top of her body at an angle. He took his dick in his hand and it gave it two light strokes before rubbing the head of his dick on her tight opening. Her juices quickly covered the tip and even this slight contact felt heavenly to them both. Zack was now questioning himself, how this was going to fit as he didn’t want to hurt the girl. He looked up at her and pushed her silky blonde hair away from her eyes that was matted to her forehead from the sweat. Amber never lost focus of the guy and was shaking with anticipation. Before he was able to ask her one last time, Amber cut him off. “I really want this, Zack. Please!”

With a deep breath Zack began to push into her tight fold. The resistance from her virgin pussy put up a fight and slightly strained him as tried to make it work. Suddenly the head pushed through just as Amber let out a pained shriek. Her one hand gripped a tight handful of his hair as she was **** to latch on to something and to keep him from pulling away. She used the fingertips of her other hand to lightly press against his thigh and keep him from pushing in further. For what felt like the entire thing to Amber was only actually the tip of his dick. Amber tried to catch a breath and let out a guttural moan, “Don’t stop. Just go slow.” Zack gave her a nod and adjusted before lightly rolling his hips back and forth until the motion became slightly easier. The slow anticipation was killing the guy, but he wanted desperately for her first time to be as enjoyable as it can. Amber fought to catch her breath as she felt herself being stretch. While Zack may not have been the best choice for her first time, she couldn’t imagine it being with anyone else at this point. She did her best to relax and spread her legs wider to help him penetrate deeper. Zack cautiously pressed slightly further and gauged the whimpering he heard from Amber to find a suitable rhythm. As he found a steady pace, Amber’s winces lightened to pleasure and her sharp breaths were not starting to shift to loud moans. The pain she was feeling is now almost blissful, though she doesn’t dare and press things further yet.

“Oh.. fuck! Oh Fuck! Right there Zack, mhm right there!” Zack was lost in the stars himself as he hadn’t imagined how tight her body would be gripping his dick. The feeling was sensational, Him being cautious to control the speed and level of penetration, was the only thing that kept him from busting. He slipped his head down until his tongue found a hard nipple to latch on and lick. Amber all but lost it at that point. Her nails dug deeply into his back and her hips pumped upwards as she was actually the one to take Zack’s cock in deeper. They both moaned as the feeling overtook them and Amber’s pants turned to loud shouts. Zack grunted as her body met his and reached under her to squeeze her firm ass cheeks and pull her into him. As Amber’s petite body began to shake and her head was filled with lust she began begging for more. “Fu.. Fuck go deeper Zack. Please! I want it all.” At that he plunged his dick deep inside her and she fully lost control at the new sensation. Amber’s juices began to flow and covered both of their bodies as well as his sheets. Zack continued to pump as he felt her pussy get impossibly tight around his shaft and was pretty sure that her nails were drawing blood at this point.

“Amber I think I’m going to cum..”

“Yes! Yes! Do it with me. I want to feel everything!” At that Zack lost it and pushed with a final thrust as he lifted himself onto his toes and buried his pumping cock inside of her. After several long spurts, he collapsed and started giggling on the ecstatic girl’s shoulder. She tried to open up one of her rolled back eyes to see what he was laughing at but had no energy to move. “Don’t laugh at me.” Amber whined and finally released her arms on his back as they both landed flat on the mattress. Her chest was heaving as she took long winded breaths and could still feel her leg twitching from the orgasm or possible multiple orgasms, she wasn’t quite sure. Zack finally unsheathed his softening dick, much to Amber’s disappointment. Zack chuckled a bit more and she only let out a pout as her body stayed completely still.

“I’m sorry. I’m not laughing at you at all. That was amazing Amber. I’m just kind of in shock.” Amber tried to respond but only mumbled a few indistinguishable sounds before she used her final energy to turn over and cuddle into him with her ass nuzzled against him. Her breathing turned to cute snoring as he realized that she had dozed off. Zack knew that he would have to get her up soon to avoid being caught but couldn’t help and enjoy it for a moment as he wrapped his arms around her and gave her a soft kiss on the cheek. He took a moment to take in the sights and cherish the moment. He wasn’t aware that he wasn’t the only one taking in the view.

___

Chloe panicked and made her way to Zack’s bedroom door and sloppily searched through her bag as she dug around for her key. Chloe was frantic at the thought of how bad she screwed up and couldn’t even blame Kevin as she was the aggressor. ‘Dammit Chloe. You sure know how to fuck up everything.’ She cursed. After she eventually pulled the key out and aimed towards the lock, a strange noise behind the door drew her attention. She instantly ducked as she heard loud voices, possibly shouting and figured that barging right through the door would make things worse for Zack if he was arguing with Monica. She stayed completely still as she wanted to avoid being caught and couldn’t help herself from listening in. It took only a couple of seconds to realize that the screams she was hearing weren’t out of anger but seemed to be something else entirely. She stayed squatted and tip toed over to his window where the blinds were slightly out of place. She gasped and shot her hand over her mouth at the unexpected site. The unexpected site was her best friend’s bare ass pumping into a petite squealing blonde headed girl. Chloe couldn’t peel her eyes away as she tried to figure out just who this screaming blonde was. Her suspicions were answered as she heard Zack call out Amber’s name between grunts. She was a little disappointed at the reveal but quickly realized that who the girl he was with was no longer of importance to her. She continued watching with even more intensity and couldn’t believe that she was seeing her best friend sawing into the blonde repeatedly. If Amber’s responses were anything to judge by, he was doing quite well. His movements may not look as refined as the guys showcased in her favorite adult films but as he slid his cock out of Amber and plunged it back in, Chloe let out a slight moan of her own. ‘He’s certainly packing like the guys I watch.’ Chloe couldn’t help admitting to herself as her mind betrayed her. She didn’t even notice her hand that was now squeezing her thigh and inching closer to the waistband of her shorts. Chloe involuntarily began to rub her legs together as her panties began to collect the heat and wetness she was putting off. It wasn’t until her other hand squeezed her large shirt covered breast and drew a louder squeal from her. She instantly dropped down to her ass and turned her back to the wall of Zack’s house. Zack and Amber were way too lost in themselves to hear anything else around them. Chloe peaked once more as she could hear the pleasure in Amber’s shrieking voice. Was it annoyance she was feeling or maybe envy? Chloe used all of her strength and pulled herself from the window just as she heard the couple announce that they were coming. She couldn’t risk being caught and sprinted across the backyard to her own home while she still barely could.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)