Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 50 by BeckyS BeckyS

What's next?

Subplot: Somebody for Lucy to Fuck

Lucy squirmed uncomfortably is her seat. She did not like sitting naked next to Jonathan, nor the way he kept "accidentally" leaning into her whenever the car turned a corner. She couldn't help but feel Laura would feel less phased by being the one stuck in the back seat with the unattractive guys but of course Laura was Liv's bum chum now and had to ride next to her.

It was Laura who would be picking for her. She would honestly have preferred it to be Liv. Laura could be kind of a wild card. She always liked to talk about people leaving their comfort zones and doing things that push their boundaries. She dreaded to think who her free spirited friend would decide to pair her with. It wouldn't take long for her to find out.

"Him!" Laura pointed excitedly "That's my pick for Lucy!"

Lucy looked to see a very overweight man who was eating fast food on a bench, alone. He had messy hair ,glasses and a T-shirt with some anime character or other on it that didn't quite stretch all the way over his belly. He also had a touch of acne, a hairy neck and a badly kept beard. This guy was so far from Lucy's type it was untrue. Jonathan would have been a better option without a doubt.

"I'm not being mean but is there even room in the car?" Lucy asked.

"You can all squeeze in together and get nice and cozy. It will be fine!" Laura teased.

"I'm fine with that" Jonathan chimed in.

"Look, he's your age and probably a really nice guy. He probably got bullied and belittled every day and now he gets to fuck the hottest girl in school, albeit a decade later and probably a different school." Laura argued "Won't that make you feel at least a tiny bit happy for him?"

"Just think of your score, Lucy!" Olivia encouraged her friend.

"Fine" Lucy nodded. Olivia pulled up close to the park bench and beeped her horn. This time it was Lucy who rolled down her window.

"Hey, come over here!" she smiled. The young man literally dropped his food. He then shuffled over nervously. On realising Lucy was not only talking to him but doing so naked he started to breathe rather heavily and his face flushed red.

"What's your name?"

"David"

"Are you single dated"

"Yes"

Lucy was hardly surprised. It seemed more than likely David was a virgin.

"I'm Lucy. Do you want to hang out with me and my friends. You can fuck me if you want?"

David somehow managed to look even more flustered now. But he also looked kind of upset.

"You're making fun of me! That isn't very nice!"

"I promise I'm not, I like bigger guys. And guys who are smart and into anime" Lucy continued, hoping he didn't ask her which show his t-shirt referenced "Get in! It is a little tight so you are going to have to let me sit on your lap!"

At this point David clearly decided that even if this was a joke he was going to go along with it. Lucy had to briefly climb out of the car to let him in and David truly savoured the moment. There he was being ushered into a car by a naked hottie. And anyone walking by could see it. Lucy then followed and could already feel Dave's hard on digging into her butt crack through his jeans. Whatever other shortcomings he may have as a lover, dick size certainly wasn't one of them.

"Okay then Liv" Laura smiled "Let's see who you want me to be with!"

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)