Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by gothamalleyviper

What does Sunday hold in store?

Shopping and anal

Nikki woke up alone in bed. A part of him wondered if the last week had been a dream. A part of him felt alone without Mamma Harley in bed with him. A part of him realized how normal this was before he had Mamma Harley and Cinderella in his life and how he had been miserable. Nikki got up and made his way to his bathroom.

“Are you up sweety?” Harley’s voice called from the kitchen, “We have breakfast ready.”

“I made a special for you, my love!” Cinderella called.

Nikki finished up and washed his hands before heading to the kitchen. Nikki was surprised at the ladies. He was expecting them to be wearing something sexy, but while they were dressed hot, their outfits were kind of mundane. Harley was wearing a red pair of leggings with an oversized Metz jersey. Cinderella was wearing black leather look leggings with an oversized softball jersey shirt, and a grey handkerchief in her hair.

“I made Croque Madame,” Cinderella smiled.

“What?” Nikki asked.

“Ham and fried egg on French Toast,” Harley snickered.

“No, Pan Perdu Harley!” Cinderella snapped, “Just because I am French and made toast does not make it French Toast!”

“You are cute when you’re angry,” Harley kissed Cinderella on the lips.

“Of course, Harley is going to goad the other ladies,” Nikki pinched the bridge of his nose, “I am hungry, so let’s see what you made.”

The three sat at the table and began to eat. Nikki had to admit, it was delicious! Nikki could feel the pair of women looking at him like as he ate. They would look at each other and exchange brief knowing smiles before going back to eating. As Cinderella finished she picked up a paper napkin and wiped her mouth.

“Nous have planned out your day off,” Cinderella started.

“You have?” Nikki asked.

“Yes, I am going to hit the grocery store,” Harley smiled, “And meet up with you two later.”

“Nous are going to mall. I need a wardrobe of my own,” Cinderella looked Nikki in the eyes, “And it is only fair to get some interesting outfits for you to wear for us.”

“Ok…” Nikki said slightly confused.

“More than just one rubber catsuit Sweety,” Harley added.

“And I think we need some accessories,” Cinderella hand a naughty smile, “That is about when we will meet up with Harley and from there dinner and a night in together…”

“You know, to test out the new… accessories,” Harley giggled.

“Now finish up your breakfast and shower,” Cinderella smiled, “I will lay out your clothes my love.”

Cinderella got up and cleared her plate.

Harley kept looking at Nikki while she ate.

*

Nikki was not use to riding in the passenger seat of his own car, but he didn’t argue with Cinderella when she got in the driver’s seat and insisted he buckle up. He was not surprised that as they were making their way to the mall, Cinderella grabbed his hand and put it on her thigh.

“Now we are alone,” Cinderella said not looking away from the road, “You want to try anal play but are too afraid to ask.”

“I ahhh… uhm,” Nikki stammered.

“My Love,” Cinderella said in a soothing but firm voice, “I am a perfect lover for you, I know everything about you and you made sure to make sure I was into Anal Sex and fucking a boyfriend in his ass…”

“Oh, yeah,” Nikki looked down.

He felt Cinderella grab his hand resting on her thigh and squeeze.

“There is no need to feel ashamed my love,” Cinderella smiled, “After all I am getting all hot and wet thinking about your wonderful cock pounding me ass.”

“You don’t think less of me… for… you know…” Nikki asked.

“No! I can’t wait to play with your adorable butt,” Cinderella beamed, “It is so cute and sexy! And is perfectly framed in that leather jockstrap Harley bought for you!”

“I think I made a mistake,” Nikki murmured.

“Oh no my love,” Cinderella said, “You have to at least try before you decide. I promise, you will love it as much as I do.”

Nikki blushed.

“We are here,” Cinderella let go of Nikki’s hand and turned the wheel.

*

Cinderella or Cendrillon Ellenor Voclain-Allard as her ID and credit cards called her, walked just in front of Nikki making sure to sway her hips in her new brown leather miniskirt. They carried a few bags of clothing for Cinderella with a few additions for Nikki and were working their way back to the car to drop off this load. They had gotten a few outfits for Cinderella, two weeks-worth of bras and panties, as well as jackets, skirt, pants and purses from a leather shop. The shop girl didn’t even blink when Cinderella picked out leather pants and skirts for Nikki as well.

“Hay girl, why don’t you hook up with a real man?” a guy called.

Nikki and Cinderella turned and looked at the source of the comment. It was a twenty something year old man in a tight t-shirt and black jeans, he was leaning against a wall with a girl about the same age looking up at him from her phone. It was clear she wasn’t impressed with what he had said. Cinderella stopped, turned and handed the bag in her right hand over to Nikki.

“I have a real man, but…” Cinderella looked from the man to the woman.

Cinderella started to whisper a song as she stepped closer to the young woman. She had a naughty smile. Nikki didn’t understand what she was saying but he did recognize the crescendo.

“… Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Boo,” Cinderella flicked her fore and middle finger from her fist and like magic a card appeared in between her fingers, “When you tired of pretending to be straight and ready to have a real orgasm with a real woman, give me a call, I can hook you up with my girlfriends.”

The girl blushed and took the card. The man gasped. Cinderella turned and went back to Nikki and kissed him while taking back the bag. Nikki noted that the nameless brunette turned and watched Cinderella’s butt as she walked away. Nikki kept up with her confident gait. Once they exited the mall for the parking lot, Nikki spoke up.

“What happened?” Nikki asked.

“He wanted to embarrass you my love, so I did more than embarrass him,” Cinderella smiled.

“And how did you do that?” Nikki asked.

“I called out how he never could satisfy his lover and how she had no real interest in him,” Cinderella snickered.

“And the bibbidi stuff?” Nikki asked.

“I have the Fairy Godmother’s magic,” Cinderella said, “It is how she cast her spells. So that is how I must cast my spells.”

“So you used magic to turn that girl into a dyke?” Nikki asked.

“No,” Cinderella laughed, “She was already one, I just erased her ability to pretend she was anything but one.”

“So she has always been a lesbian?” Nikki asked as they came to his car.

“Oi,” Cinderella said opening the trunk.

“And now you just made her unable to pretend to be straight?” Nikki asked.

“Oi,” Cinderella put the bags in the trunk before turning back to Nikki to take the bags he was holding, “Her disgust with the Manly form is now an ozne.”

“So next time he tries to take her to bed…” Nikki muttered.

“She might vomit on him, she might just leave,” Cinderella shrugged.

“You can be a mean girl,” Nikki noted.

“You knew that when you picked me,” Cinderella smiled and kissed Nikki on the nose, “But also wanted me to be your loving gentle dominatrix mommy.”

Nikki thought about it as Cinderella took the bags and put them in the trunk. She was right. Nikki wanted a cruel mistress that would be his soft and loving mommy dommy but more than capable of inflicting torments to others. He had to admit, between that thought and Cinderella leaning over in her brown leather miniskirt, it gave her a boner.

*

Cinderella treated Nikki to lunch at the Mall food court before hitting a few more shops. She picked out a few more outfits for herself, Harley and Nikki. Once they were done, they left the mall and went to a specialist shop. They were in one of the smaller sex shops on Harley’s list. They stood together in front of a black leather dildo harness on the lap of a mannequin for women’s panties. Cinderella was looking at the box in her hand. Nikki was looking at the two sets of pictures. On one side was a pair of blonds using the harness to have sex while the other side had one of the blondes wearing the harness while fucking a muscular man while he bent over a table.

“Looking to try a little bend over boyfriend?” A woman asked as she walked up.

Nikki blushed as Cinderella turned to look at the woman. Maybe thirty, black with short curly hair.

“Looking to experiment,” Cinderella smiled.

“Awesome,” the woman smiled, “My boy-toy loves it when I use my feel-do on him!”

“Do you have them?” Cinderella asked.

Cinderella’s firm grip on Nikki’s hand meant that he was **** to follow over to the other display with the specialized “V” shaped dildos.

“And if you want to try something to stimulate you without taking a full cock while having sex,” the woman said pointing at another display, “We have ass locks that will allow you to feel things as well while you give it to her.”

Nikki and Cinderella looked at the black rubber device she was pointing at. It was an elastic ring with a tail that connected to a rubber thumblike end.

“How does that work?” Cinderella asked.

“The ring is a cock ring and goes around his cock and balls,” the woman said, “The ribbing on the connecter stimulates the taint while the plug stimulates his rear while he pumps you.”

Cinderella looked at Nikki. He knew he was blushing.

“And of course, if you want to keep him locked up but still tickle his booty,” the woman pointed at a different model.

It was black but instead of a cock ring it had a small compartment shaped like a shriveled cock.

“Cock cage on one end to control his releases and then a vibrator in his booty to drive him wild,” The woman smiled.

“Oh no,” Cinderella looked at Nikki and licked her lips for a second, “I very much enjoy his… releases. What do you have for his and her’s training plug sets?”

*

“There’s my Sweetie!” Harley shouted and rushed over to hug and kiss Nikki.

Harley **** her tongue into Nikki’s mouth, and held him close against her body. He couldn’t help but get excited by her attention.

“And he was a very good boy!” Cinderella said as she walked in.

“You’re back and brought a new friend,” Carol said as she came up, “You must be Cindy.”

“Oi,” Cinderella smiled at the Latina owner of the fetish shop.

“Let me quick show you what Harley picked out for you before we have Nikki try on his new suit,” Carol smiled.

Nikki felt a bit embarrassed, but this was not his first time at this high end fetish shop and it seemed Harley had gotten herself some leeway with this place. Harley eventually broke the kiss and let go of Nikki. She grabbed him by the wrist and dragged him back to the table where Cinderella and Carol were talking.

“I can’t wait,” Cinderella said holding up a black rubber opera glove, “Do you like?”

Cinderella waved her hand so the palm of the glove rubbed over Nikki’s face and he got and sniff of the rubber.

‘Yes,” Nikki said automatically.

“I hear you really enjoyed your last suit from us,” Carol smiled, “You pajamas are ready for you.”

“Pajamas?” Nikki asked.

“Right this way,” Carol smiled.

*

Carol and Harley stood on either side of Nikki in front of the mirror. Unlike the last suit, which had been tight all over, this one was loose. Loose except for the hands, ankles and neck. Everything below his next was covered by the thick and loose pink rubber. Nikki’s hands were held in tight mittens that prevented him from using them and his feet were covered by loose socks pinched tight at the ankles.

“Why the hands?” Nikki asked.

“This design is originally for adult babies,” Carol said running her hands over his arm, “Renders the wearer helpless and totally at his mommy’s mercy.”

“You trust that Mommy Harley and Mommy Cindy are going to take care of you, right?” Harley asked.

“Yes,” Nikki said unsure.

“Well then wearing this, puts you entirely in our care, and we will take very good care of you,” Harley kissed Nikki.

The thought of Harley unzipping his crotch and using his cock popped in Nikki’s head. Cinderella had exited her changing booth and was walking back over in her leather skirt and blue shirt combo and wrapped her arms around Nikki’s waist.

“You look lovely,” Cinderella whispered in Nikki’s ear from behind.

Nikki couldn’t hid it, being held and admired by three attractive women was a massive turn-on for him. Cinderella’s hands slid down and pulled the crotch area tight against his boner.

“And he feels lovely too,” Cinderella smiled into the mirror.

“Doesn’t take much to figure out what you three are doing when you get home,” Carol chuckled.

“Nope,” Harley said reaching for the silver zipper that ran between Nikki’s belly button and the small of his back.

*

Nikki snapped too, he remembered the fetish shop, coming home and sitting down to talk with Harley.

“So sweety,” Harley prompted, “Feel better?”

“Yeah,” Nikki responded.

“Do you remember what I told you?” Harley asked.

“I am straight, but kinky, and that is ok,” Nikki started to remember the conversation before drifting off.

“You sure you aren’t attracted to men?” Harley asked.

Nikki thought about her question, he felt no attraction to me.

“Yeah, nothing…” Nikki said.

“What about this?” Harley held up the box of the strapon dildo harness Cinderella had bought.

Nikki looked at the picture of the two women having sex with the dildo.

“They are sexy,” Nikki blurted.

“Good, so if you don’t find men attractive, but you want to have sex with women,” Harley said before prompting, “That makes you…”

“Straight,” Nikki chimed in.

“And if you want to have sex with women,” Harley prompted, “But want to try different things, you are…”

“Straight but kinky.”

Nikki now completely remembered the conversation before. Harley had sat him down and asked if he was embarrassed about wanting to have his butt plaid with. She then asked him if he thought guys were pretty, attractive, or sexy. Nikki couldn’t think of any that he found attractive. Harley asked if he wanted to have sex with women. Nikki wanted that a lot. Harley then pronounced Nikki straight. She then asked if he wanted Harley to just lay in bed naked and wait while he humped her, of if he wanted to try stuff like strip-teases, bondage, femdom and other kinky games. Nikki just looked at Harley. She then informed him that he was straight but kinky. Which was fine because even Nikki thought vanilla was boring. She than told him she wanted to hypnotize him to re-enforce this thought process.

“Here, I filmed it on your phone, like I said I would,” Harley handed him his phone, “We still need to get you a better phone sweety. Dinner will be ready shortly and after the orgy!”

“Oi!” Cinderella shouted from the kitchen.

Harley got up and went to help Cinderella. Nikki watched her walk away in her tight leggings and felt a bit of a boner return. He then went and started the ten-minute recording, it was pretty boring, it was Harley going over with the entranced Nikki that if he wasn’t attracted to men and found women sexually attractive, he was straight. If he wanted to play kinky games, that meant he was straight but kinky, not gay.

“So like Harley said, she hypnotized me to help me accept that wanting her and Cinderella to play with my ass is kinky, not gay,” Nikki said before he stopped the video.

Nikki opened Harem app and brought up Harley’s profile. He thought for a second and then modified her profile so she would crave his dick in her ass, and she would be into pegging like Cinderella was.

“Dinner’s ready!” Cinderella called.

Nikki hit the confirm and save changes before getting up and joining his blonde lovers for dinner.

*

Over dinner, it was decided. Tonight, they would all finger fuck each other’s asses. Nikki would play with Cinderella’s and Harley’s and they would get to play with his. Nikki found himself at ease with the idea and even excited. Cinderella pointed out that if he didn’t like it, this would be his chance to say he was done with the idea and delete it from the agenda. So after dinner, the Mommy Mistresses had Nikki wait out in the living room while they got ready. He stripped and then waited in nothing but the black leather jockstrap that Cinderella picked out for him.

“Come on in Sweety!” Harley called.

Nikki walked into the bed room and his cock shot straight up. Cinderella and Harley were posing and showing off their outfits. They wore spike heeled ankle boots, thigh high stockings, garter belts, open cup corsets, opera gloves and chockers. Harley’s was in red rubber and Cinderella’s in black rubber. They turned and bent over Nikki’s wardrobe and made a show of their exposed butts.

“Come over here My Boy,” Cinderella beckoned.

Nikki walked towards his loving Mistresses. The pair turned around grabbed something and turned back to Nikki. They grabbed his hands, held them up and then pulled heavy yellow rubber dishwashing gloves on. Cinderella reached back and grabbed a bottle of clear sexual lube. Once his rubberized hand were lubed, Cinderella went back to bending over the desk.

“Now, mon amour,” Cinderella said, “Start with your little fingers.”

“Put your pinker in our stinkers sweety!” Harley cooed.

“Rub around our holes to start, the slowly push in with your fingertips,” Cinderella instructed.

The pair of blondes reached back with their gloved hands and pulled their butt cheeks wide giving Nikki unfettered access. Nikki put the tips of his pinky fingers on the women’s anuses. The pair purred.

“That is it,” Harley said, “Smear the hole with some lube, small circles.”

Nikki did as instructed and noticed it was making both women’s pussies very wet.

“Now push in with the very tip of your finger,” Cinderella moaned.

Nikki pressed his finger tips against their holes and felt the automatic resistance giving way as the women moaned their approval. Nikki found that pumping his fingers deeper, then back and then deeper again seemed to be the best approach. Soon Nikki was in as far as he could go and the women were loving it.

“Add your ring finger,” Cinderella panted.

Nikki slide his ring fingers down his pinkies and pushed them into the blonde’s anuses. Cinderella and Harley started to kiss each other as well. He got the extra finger in and started to rotate his hands a bit to add some more motion and that made the women even more excited.

“Another finger,” Harley gasped.

Nikki moved his hands around and pushed his middle fingers in. Cinderella and Harley’s pussies were dripping on the floor now from the stimulation. Nikki wondered what it would be like to feel that as well.

“Pick one,” Harley gasped, “Pick a mommy to fuck. But remember… while you are doing that, the other is going to be fingering… ahhh… your cute little patoot!”

“Mommy Harley, please let me fuck your ass,” Nikki said, “Mommy Mistress Cinderella please finger your boy’s bottom.”

Harley and Cinderella looked at each other, grinned and kissed.

“Withdraw boy,” Cinderella ordered.

Nikki took his fingers from her ass. Cinderella stood up and turned. She grabbed a condom and the lube from the desk and went behind Nikki. With an expert hand, she had pulled the jockstrap down, the condom out of the wrapper, on his cock and was rubbing it with lube before Nikki realized what was happening. Cinderella guided Nikki to be right behind Harley and then used her hands to get Nikki’s away from Harley and stripped the gloves off turning them inside out as she did. Cinderella put Nikki’s hands on Harley’s hips and then pumped his cock a few times and guided him into Harley’s hungry ass hole. His cock slid right in and Cinderella hip thrust against his butt **** him to plunge all the way into Harley setting her off in the convulsions of an orgasm.

“Don’t stop Sweety!” Harley gasped and moaned.

Nikki pumped his cock into Harley as ordered and heard the snapping of latex gloves behind him. Soon he felt the feminine hands grasping his butt cheeks and spread them. Soon he felt the cold slickness of lube against his ass. He almost heard Cinderella singing behind him as he felt her stick her pointer finger against and into his anus.

“More, deeper, harder Baby,” Harley moaned.

Nikki thrust harder and swooned himself as Cinderella wormed her finger deeper into his sphincter. As she did, it felt better and better. Nikki was slapping his balls against Harley’s thighs as he thrust to the deepest. Cinderella moved her hooked finger and started to poke a particular point inside Nikki’s colon. And then suddenly it made Nikki’s cock explode and that caused Harley’s pussy to squirt out as another orgasm rocked the red clad blonde’s body.

“Holy shit,” Nikki gasped.

*

Nikki slept between the rubber clad lovers. He dreamed of a being in the middle of a double doggy style sex sandwich between Cinderella and Emma Frost. In his dream Harley was under Cinderella in a sixty nine as Nikki fucked his mistress’ ass. All the while the imaginary Emma Frost fucked his ass with a strap-on Dildo harness.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)