Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by FrostyBooty69 FrostyBooty69

What's next?

She wakes up in another stranger's bed

Caitlin’s head was throbbing. The dim light coming through the window was only making it worse. Her stomach churned and she thought she was going to be sick. All her muscles were aching and it hurt to move. This could only mean one thing. Caitlin had a hangover. Killer Frost must have been drinking last night, again.

Once her eyes finally focused, Caitlin looked around the room, hoping to be greeted by the familiar look of her bedroom. She was not. Instead she was in yet another stranger’s bed with no idea where she was. Killer Frost had started to do this more frequently lately, but did she have to do this night after night. Caitlin already had enough trouble getting out of the house yesterday, with the perverted son and sex crazed mom, and now she had to do it again, this time with a hangover.

Caitlin scanned the room. This time, there was no one in the bed with her. She didn’t know whether to be relieved or worried. Since he was awake, Caitlin might run in to him, which she was sure would involve several questions about her changed appearance. The room looked like a typical bedroom, a TV facing the bed, a nightstand next to the bed, and an open door that led to a small closet. Caitlin took the covers off of her and was not surprised to see that she was once again naked. She saw her dress laying on the floor just next to the door leading out of the bedroom. So far, today seemed to be going much more smoothly than yesterday.

As she started to get up and move towards her dress, the door to the room opened. Dammit, Caitlin thought, I had to jinx it. A short, but very wide, man entered the room holding a tray of food. On the tray sat two plates stacked with pancakes with syrup dripping off them, two glasses of orange juice, and a plate full of strips of bacon. Oh yeah, and he was also naked.

“Good morning, beautiful. Hope you slept well. I hope you like pancakes and bacon. I thought I could make you some breakfast in bed. I hope it tastes good,” the man said as he sat down on the bed next to Caitlin and layed the tray down.

“Thanks but I’m not feeling the greatest and I don’t think eating quite yet would be a wise idea,” Caitlin politely said.

“Are you sure? I made this just for you.”

“And that’s sweet and all, but I’m really not feeling very good. I should probably get home.

“Please don’t go yet,” he pleaded as he put a hand on Caitlin’s thigh. “Last night was amazing and if you leave now, then it’s all over.”

“Hey, I’m sorry but I can’t stay. What we did last night was a mistake,” Caitlin said.

“Please don’t say that. It was not a mistake, it was the best night of my life. I’ve never done anything like that in my life. You’re the most beautiful woman I’ve ever seen, and just the thought that you would come home with me,” the man said as he started to cry.

Caitlin moved back down and sat next to the sobbing man. He then wrapped his arms around Caitlin and rested his head on her shoulder. Caitlin hugged him back, trying to comfort him, even though it was still awkward as they were both still naked.

“It’s okay. I’m sure you’ll find another woman that is perfect for you. You just have to give it time. She’s out there for you, waiting for her knight in shining armor to save her,” Caitlin said comfortingly.

“Look at me. I’m no knight in shining armor, I’m just a troll,” he said.

“No you’re not.”

“Really?! I’m short and my fat has fat. As my self esteem gets lower, I turn to food to provide comfort, which only makes me heavier, leading to even lower self esteem. It’s a vicious cycle, but you saw through that and you spent the night with me of all people. No one has ever done that before. No woman I’ve ever met has slept with me until you did. I love you,” the man sobbed.

Caitlin’s couldn’t help but feel sympathy for the man. While he was not wrong about his looks, Caitlin could tell he had a good heart. People today don’t look past the outside and only look for the man with the biggest muscles and massive dick, neither of which this man had.

“It’s not how you look that matters, it’s your heart. I’ve only known you a short while, but I can already tell you are incredibly kind. Any woman would be lucky to have someone as nice as you are.”

“I don’t want to have any woman, I want you. You’re perfect.”

“Believe me, I’m not perfect,” Caitlin said.

“Have you seen yourself? You’ve got a perfect body. Not only that, but you’re also the nicest woman I have ever met.”

“I’ve got my own problems that you shouldn’t have to deal with,”

“It doesn’t matter. Whatever problems you’re going through, we can do it together.”

“I don’t think it’s a good idea.”

“Please, I just want to be with you. I love you,” the man pleaded.

“Okay, I’ve got an idea. How about we give each other our phone numbers and we can keep in touch, but as friends only. We can get to know each other and maybe I can help you find the right woman for you. How does that sound?” Caitlin said with a smile.

“Okay. We can do that, but please don’t just say that. I really want to know you, and maybe then you’ll realize that the perfect girl is already right next to me,” the man agreed.

“You’ve got to stop doing that.”

“Why, you’re not married are you?”

“Well, no I’m not. But…”

“Then why can’t you give this a chance?”

“Alright, fine. I’ll give this a chance, but don’t get your hopes up.”

“You’re the best,” the man said as he moved closer and kissed Caitlin. Caitlin was shocked by the man’s forwardness, but it was also impressive. Caitlin could learn a thing or two about following her heart. Maybe this friendship would be beneficial for them both.

“Now that that’s all settled, why don’t we get dressed?” Caitlin suggested.

Caitlin put on her dress from the previous night while her new friend got some clothes out of the closet. Afterwards, the two exchanged their numbers and Caitlin found out that his name was Kyle.

“I really should be leaving now,” Caitlin said.

“Wait! You still haven’t eaten the breakfast I made,” Kyle said.

“I’m really not very hungry. Maybe next time we meet you can cook me a meal,” Caitlin responded.

“Couldn’t you at least eat a little?”

“Alright, I’ll stay for a few minutes, but I’m after that it’s time for me to go,” Caitlin agreed. The two of them sat down and began to eat the breakfast that Kyle prepared for them. Caitlin was amazed by the taste. They were the best pancakes that Caitlin had ever tasted. Before long, Caitlin had eaten the entire plateful and had more than enough bacon to last a lifetime. While they were eating, Kyle told Caitlin more about his childhood and his limited experience in a relationship. After they talked for an hour or two, Caitlin decided to leave. She got up and Kyle walked her to the door. Before she left, Kyle leaned in and gave Caitlin another kiss. This time, her response was much less pleasant than the last kiss, she vomited all over herself and Kyle. Maybe eating all that food with a hangover wasn’t a good idea.

“I’m so sorry!” Caitlin said.

“It’s fine. I don’t know what I expected after I gave you all that food after how much you drank last night,” Kyle said. “Well you can’t go home wearing that now,” he said gesturing to Caitlin’s now ruined dress. “You can borrow some things from my closet until you get home,”

“Thank you so much,” Caitlin said as she followed Kyle back into the bedroom and stripped off her dress.

“I bet you didn’t think you’d be naked in this room so soon did you?” Kyle smirked.

“Very funny,” Caitlin said as Kyle handed her a change of clothes. She put on the plain shirt and pants she was given, but they weren’t exactly a perfect fit. The pants especially were much wider than Caitlin’s hips and kept sliding down if she wasn’t careful, and the shirt was too short to provide any cover if the pants fell down, but it was better than either walking home in a puke covered dress or completely naked. The two of them walked back to the door, but there was no kiss this time. Instead, Kyle just gave Caitlin a hug, which she gladly returned. While they were hugging, gravity did its job and Caitlin’s pants fell around her ankles once again, leaving her pussy and ass completely exposed since Killer Frost decided not to wear underwear again and she didn’t really want to borrow Kyle’s.

“You might want to be careful about that on your way home,” Kyle said as Caitlin picked up her pants. “Although I don’t think any of the men will complain if it happens again.”

The two of them said their goodbyes and Caitlin exited Kyle’s apartment and went on her way home. Since Killer Frost had never driven a car before, Caitlin had to walk to the nearest bus stop and get a ride home. She had a real challenge keeping her pants from falling down again, but she managed to get home without any more mishaps.

Caitlin entered her apartment and got a clean outfit that actually fit her. Once again, she noticed that Killer Frost had left another note for her. This one read, I decided that if you aren’t going to fuck Barry, or at least tell him your feelings, then I would make sure to give you as much practice as possible until you finally do what you should. Looks like I’m going to be having a lot of fun in the upcoming nights, I hope you enjoy your mornings. P.S. You might want to check out this video, I think you’ll love it. There was a link written at the end of the note. Caitlin’s curiosity got the better of her and she decided to check out the link, even though she was sure she wouldn’t like what she saw.

The link led her to a porn site. Of course this is what Killer Frost did in her spare time. If she wasn’t having sex, she was watching people have sex. The video that Killer Frost recommended was very familiar to Caitlin. It was the video of her giving a blowjob to the kid she had met the previous morning.

“That bitch said he wouldn’t show this to anyone,” Caitlin said to herself. She really hoped no one saw this video, but the view counter said otherwise. She just had to hope no one she knows sees this.

What happens next for Caitlin?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)