She chooses to roll separately.

Amy thinks for a moment. She decides that since she's fine with going barefoot, she'll only have to roll 3 different forfeits, and if she gets lucky with the tops and bottoms, maybe she can get by without underwear too, in which case she'd only have to do 2 forfeits anyway.

"I'll roll separately," she says.

"Suit yourself, which item will you roll for first?"

"Top."

"Okay, first roll on the forfeit table, then we'll roll for your replacement top."