Yahtzee!! (All 6's)

Amy rolled the dice 6. Bianca drew a check mark on the white board next to "Nothing" on the top list. Amy started to sweat nervously. Maybe she'd roll the bikini top for underwear, that wouldn't be so bad, she thought. Next she rolled for bottoms, another 6. "Shit," she said involuntarily. She rolled again for shoes, and for the third time in a row, she rolled another 6. Not so bad to be barefoot, considering. But nevertheless, she inspected the dice; it had all the numbers and seemed to be a normal dice. By this point, Bianca was starting to laugh uncontrollably.

"Wow, you have such shitty luck, Boychest."

Amy looked at the underwear options, but were no good options to hope for. Figuring that no matter what, she'd be re-rolling anyway, Amy tossed the die a fourth and final time. 6 again.

"Well, I can't go to class naked," she said, so I guess I'll just have to take a forfeit and re-roll."

"Okay, if you're going to be a wimp about it. Which item would you like to re-roll?"

"What!?! You mean I can only re-roll one? But, there's no way I'd be remotely decent, they won't even let me go to class, I'll be stopped my campus police before I even got across the quad!"

"Come on, now, I'm not that unreasonable. You can re-roll as many as you want, you just need to roll a separate forfeit for each item. And no repeats, if you roll the same item twice, I'll pick a different forfeit from the list for you.

"Although, now that I think about it, I'll offer you the following half-off deal: instead of rolling a separate forfeit for each item, I'll let you roll just two forfeits for all four items. However, you only get to roll once for all your clothing--whatever you roll, that's your number for every item. If you roll a six on that one, we'll just have to come up with some reason for you to attend class naked. Like you're protesting fur or something.

"So which is it, reroll each item seperately with a separate forfeit, or reroll everything at once for only two forfeits?"