She answers for him

Jeff is freaked out by the whole situation. Lucy was always a little unhinged, but this was a whole new level. As much as he wanted to not be in a relationship with her anymore he still had feelings for her. he didn't want to see her hurt herself. Hopping off the barstool he marches over to Lucy and picks her coat up and off the floor. "You're being ridiculous. Now get dressed and sit at the bar to talk like a rational human."

Lucy allows Jeff to put the coat over her shoulders, but she sighs and starts walking away from him. "I get it, you're embarrassed that I'm about to make all of your perverted fantasies come true." She leans against the bar leaving Jeff standing in the middle of the room. "Do you remember that night I sucked you off in the bathroom?" She doesn't give him a chance to answer. of course, he remembers. Like most of their kinkiest sexual escapades, it was simply a tease of a whole world Lucy hinted at but never fully opened the door so he could pass through. "Do you remember what you told me when I was kneeling in front of the toilet with your cock in my mouth? You said, through happy moans, that you wanted to strip me, put me on a leash, and walk me out into the bar."

"Lucy, please stop this."

Everyone in the bar is listening. Lucy slips off her coat again and hands it over the bar to Max. "Hang this up for me? Thanks." Turning back to Jeff who can't believe she handed her coat to Max. He does as he says and hangs the coat behind the bar. "You said you wanted to watch everyone circle around me and feed me their cocks. It was a quiet night. Like this one. Do you remember who was here that night?"

He really didn't. Probably Will and maybe their other friend Ralph. Some random patrons. "I don't know, Lucy, but it doesn't matter. We need to go."

She lowers herself to her knees and starts crawling back to Jeff. "I remember because I've thought about it quite a bit. What if I was braver? What if I let you do the things you always asked me? What if I was a better girlfriend? I failed you Jeff, but that all changes now. I'm going to prove it by giving you exactly what you wanted that night. Will was here. Max was bartending. There were some guys playing darts in the back. Ralph and Rachel were here. So were Shelly and Melissa." She stops at his feet. Looking up. "Can you imagine how ruined I would have been that night? How humiliated if you made me suck off all of the men in the bar in front of Shelly and Melissa?"

Shelly and Melissa were Lucy's closest friends. Shelly was a nice Christian woman who grew up with Lucy. She was close to Lucy's parents and would have very likely been the bridesmaid if Lucy and Jeff were to ever marry. Melissa was a friend she made in college. She was also Lucy's occasional lifeline whenever Lucy lost a job. Melissa could often find contract copyediting work for her.

Jeff is absolutely speechless. He gazes down at his girlfriend - EX-GIRLFRIEND - it's clear she isn't going to listen to reason. Was she really going to take this all the way? Staring up at Jeff she loudly says "Max, Will, random guy at the table if your lady will let you, come over here and get your cocks ready."

"Lucy," Jeff starts but realizes begging her to stop isn't going to work. He looks up at Will and Max by the bar. "Guys..."