Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by Ninj8 Ninj8

What Happens Next?

Ryan & Chase have Round 2. Chase and Leah have Round 3

After a moment, Leah rolled over and looked at him, her eyes sparkling.

"I had no idea you were so good in bed," she giggled.

Ryan blushed, his cheeks burning, "I uh... I try my best."

Leah smiled, leaning in and placing a soft kiss on his lips.

"You were amazing," she whispered, her voice husky.

"T-thanks," Ryan stammered, his cheeks red.

Leah looked down and gently poked Chase, who was resting between their legs, her tip pointing right up at her.

"And you were amazing, too," she purred, giving Chase a quick rub, who wiggled and let out a happy little squirm.

Ryan gulped, his face bright red. Leah looked up at him and chuckled,

"What? Embarrassed about a girl complimenting your dick?"

"No, it's just... I'm not used to hearing a girl say things like that," he replied, his cheeks burning.

"Well, you'll have to get used to it. I plan on spending a lot of time with both of you," Leah purred, giving Chase a few pumps.

"A-are you serious?" Ryan stuttered, his eyes wide.

"Mhm. Now, do you mind if I have a shower? You've got me all sticky," Leah replied, sitting up and swinging her legs off the bed.

Ryan nodded, his heart pounding.

Leah got to her feet and sauntered over to the bathroom, her hips swaying. Reaching the bedroom door, she turned and gave Ryan a wink, and blew chase a kiss, before closing the door behind her and disappearing into the bathroom.

Ryan lay on his bed, his mind racing but no words forming. He couldn't believe what had just happened. Nor couldn't believe how amazing Leah had made him feel. But best of all, he couldn't believe that she actually wanted to spend more time with him and Chase. It was all so overwhelming, yet so incredible.

Ryan heard the water begin to run in the bathroom, and as if on queue he heard a voice who had been quiet all night.

“Alright… I already know the answer, but… ass or tits?” Chase smirked, twitching and pulsating happily.

Ryan sighed with a smile, rubbing his eyes.

“Yeahhhhh… you’re totally a slut for those boobs of hers, aintcha? Those girls were two holy grails! I’m totally titfucking them in the future~” Chase bit her lip, drooling as some leftover cum dripped out of her mouth.

Ryan looked down at Chase, using a finger to wipe away her ‘drool’ before saying, “Yes, her boobs were gorgeous. And yes, I prefer them over ass.”

Chase giggled, before sighing contently, her expression changing to a thoughtful one.

"She's pretty great, isn't she?" Chase asked. But then her tone got serious.

“Just don’t forget the one you truly love…” Chase stroked herself and shot Ryan a smirk. He grunted, feeling Chase tense up as she jiggled their balls.

"I won't," he assured her, his hand drifting down to wrap around her shaft.

"Good, cause I get incredibly jealous," she replied, her tone dead serious as she continued,

“Sex with Leah is one thing… but you and me going one-on-one? Nothing tops that. You’re mine, Ryan… and don't you forget it," Chase growled as she heaved Ryan’s balls up and firmly pressed them against his thighs, forcing them to squeeze around her, causing Ryan to grunt and shudder.

Ryan couldn’t help but moan as Chase began to massage his balls, her voice low, "And if you ever find yourself forgetting, I'll be happy to remind you."

Ryan nodded, Chase throbbing in his grip.

"Good boy," she purred.

Ryan shivered as he kept his eyes locked on Chase as she gently pulled against his hips. The pressure causing a little bit of pain, but it only fed into Ryan’s lust.

"Now, why don't you show me just how much you love me, huh?" Chase demanded, her tone leaving no room for argument.

Ryan nodded, his hand stroking her shaft.

"Mmmm, yeah. That's a good boy," she moaned, her breathing ragged.

"F-fuck," Ryan stammered, his Chase drooling precum onto his hand.

Chase groaned, her whole shaft vibrating,

"O-oh my gosh... you're making me so fucking hard! Our balls are just aching for release…”

Ryan bit his lip, his hand pumping her faster.

"You like that, baby?" she purred.

"Oh yeah," Ryan moaned, his eyes closed, his fingers squeezing her tip.

"Mmmm, then keep going. Don't stop. I'm so fucking close," Chase panted, bucking Ryan’s hips.

"Fuck! Chase... I'm gonna cum!" Ryan grunted, nearing climax.

"Oh my god, yessss!" Chase moaned, her voice husky.

Ryan felt his balls tighten, and Chase's entire body pulsated with pleasure.

"Ooooh fuck! Yes!" Chase cried out, her voice hoarse.

Ryan let out a strangled cry as Chase jerked, shooting thick ropes of cum onto his stomach. Chase's tip swelled up and exploded, her tip spurting out a massive load that painted the underside of his chin.

Ryan let out a low groan, his balls emptying themselves as Chase continued to shoot cum.

"Holy shit…" he mumbled, his chest rising and falling as he caught his breath. He laid his head down, breaths becoming soft.

“Mmmh, that’s the good stuff… hey, give us a hand dude,” Chase sighed contently.

Ryan didn’t respond.

“Uh, dude?” Chase slapped herself against Ryan’s stomach, but was still met with no response.

“Hey! Wake up man!” Chase said sternly, trying to get Ryan to wake up, but she again failed to get a response.

Chase heard the shower water stop running and sighed, “Ah, fuck…”

As if on queue, Leah walked back into the room with a towel wrapped around her body, hair still slightly damp. From her perspective, she simply saw Ryan **** with his dick still rock hard and twitching slightly.

“Aww, you had round two without me?!” Leah joked, walking over to Ryan and nudging his arm. Not getting any response, she furrowed her brow as she turned and faced Chase who was twitching and throbbing silently.

“But you’re still awake…” Leah muttered to herself as she walked over and crouched at the end of the bed. She then grabbed Ryan’s legs and dragged him so Chase was on the very edge of the bed, before resting herself a few inches away from Chase. Leah watched Chase twitch, still completely unaware of her sentience, and said,

“Welp, I guess it’s just you and me now…”

Chase twitched, letting out a soft whimper that Leah failed to hear.

"That's right, I'm gonna make sure you're all taken care of," Leah cooed, reaching out and running her hand along Chase's shaft. She then propped her breasts on top of Ryan’s legs, gently sandwiching Chase between each breast.

"Doesn't that feel nice, sweetie?" she purred, her fingers lightly massaging the base of his cock.

Chase trembled, her entire length vibrating against Leah's breasts.

"Mmm, I'll take that as a yes," Leah giggled, her hands pushing her breasts together as she continued to talk to Chase.

"You're just so cute," she cooed, her eyes sparkling as she turned down and stuck her tongue into Chase’s tip while starting to rub her breasts up and down. She removed her hands, displaying her pectoral control as her breasts still had a firm grip on Chase, and took Chase completely into her mouth.

"Mmmmh..." Chase groaned, her tip throbbing inside Leah's warm, wet mouth. She was struggling to stay quiet and not blow her cover, but Leah was making it excruciatingly difficult.

Leah hummed, her cheeks hollowing as she sucked Chase, her tongue swirling around her tip. Without warning, Chase seized and shot ropes of cum down Leah’s throat, catching her by surprise.

"Mmmph!" Leah exclaimed, her eyes wide as Chase filled her mouth with hot cum. She quickly swallowed it, not wanting to waste a single drop. She then pulled Chase out of her mouth and out from between her tits.

"My god... you must've really needed this, huh?" Leah teased, her hands gently stroking Chase’s shaft.

Chase's head slumped, her body twitching as she gently wiggled her head up and down in a nod, much to Leah’s surprise.

"Wait... did you just nod?!" Leah asked, her voice a mix of shock and excitement.

Chase froze, unsure how to proceed, but before she could even come up with something, she heard Ryan's phone ping from receiving a message.

Ryan stirred, his eyes slowly opening. He felt a tingling sensation in his crotch, and his eyes immediately darted to Chase. He was met with the sight of Leah's tits on either side of his dick, and a pool of cum covering his lower body.

"What the-?" he gasped, sitting up and looking at the phone. He was so distracted by Leah and his own state that he almost entirely forgot about his phone as he said,

“Did you just titfuck me?!”

Did She?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)