Pussy patrol

"Well, you were getting close there, James," Lizz replied. "It seems we're tied at one vote each. So I guess it's time for you to decide whose pussy you like best." She grinned mischievously. "Come on, Ash." She took Ash's hand and let her over to the plush sofa where she had been masturbating when we came down. They sat down side by side, scooted their asses up to the edge and opened their legs wide exposing two beautiful pussies. I couldn't believe this was happening. "Go ahead, little brother, start your inspection," Lizz laughed.

I didn't have to be asked twice. I got down on my knees between them and looked at first one then the other. Lizz's mound was shaved clean leaving her pussy bare. Ash had trimmed hers down to a kind of landing strip but still as exposed as Lizz's. I reached out with both hands and started feeling both of them at the same time. While they obviously weren't exactly the same, there really wasn't a lot of difference either. They both had soft folds that parted easily with slick wet lips inside. I ran my hands back and forth on their slits, then found their little nub clits. It seemed that Lizz's was a little more swollen but not by much. As I rubbed their clits, I slid one finger then two into the tight cunts. They both moaned simultaneously. I worked my fingers in and out for a couple minutes while playing with their clits with my thumbs. I looked up and they both had their eyes closed, obviously enjoying my "inspection."

"Um, I don't know. This one's really hard," I said. Lizz opened her eyes and looked at me. "I know what's hard she said, looking straight down at my stiff erection. "But you haven't tasted them yet, how could you possibly make your decision already." She gave me another one of her wicked grins. Ash looked over at her and chuckled.

"I don't know if he knows how to eat pussy," she informed Lizz. "He's never tried mine, I know that."

"Well then, better late than never," Lizz grinned. "Go on, James. Taste your girlfriend's pussy. I want to see you eat her out. Then I want you to eat me."

So I wasn't an expert at cunnilingus but I wasn't exactly a novice either. Ash had never been my girlfriend, we had just been platonic friends until tonight, so that's why I hadn't done her already. But I had done other girls who were my girlfriends at the time.

I moved in between Ash's legs and buried my head between her thighs. I kissed her pussy lips, then stuck out my tongue and licked back and forth along her slit. Ash started to moan when my tongue found her clit and started licking it. She tasted a little musky but a little sweet too. I explored her pussy with my tongue for a few minutes pushing it as far up her canal as I could. I decided to use my fingers on her clit while I massaged her opening with my mouth. She was moaning and groaning more now and I could feel her cunt getting hotter and wetter. I lifted my head and looked at her then over at Lizz. I then realized that Lizz had been fingering her own pussy while my attentions were directed to Ash.

"Mmm, you have a pretty tasty pussy, Ash," I grinned. "I think that might be hard to beat."

"Well, you better get over here and find out," Lizz huffed.

I moved over between Lizz's legs and tasted her pussy too, which was already wetter than Ash's was. "Looks like somebody had a head start," I grinned before diving in. Lizz's cunt tasted a little muskier than Ash's, not quite as sweet. But still pretty damn good. I couldn't believe I was eating my own sister's pussy. I gave her much the same treatment as I had Ash, licking her slit with my tongue, rubbing her clit with my fingers, pushing my tongue and fingers in and out of her warm tunnel as far as I could. She was moaning too and I thought she might be about getting ready to cum. I lifted my head again and looked up at both of them, their eyes sort of half-glazed over.

"Damn, it's so hard to decide," I said. "You both taste fantastic. I could eat either one of your pussies all day and all night!" I rested a hand on each one of their thighs up close to their honey holes.

"Are you sure you're done with the comparison," Lizz asked again. "Have you fucked Ashley's pussy? I know you haven't fucked mine.... yet." She grinned again.

"Uh, no," I stuttered. "We're just friends, remember?"

"What? You don't want to fuck your best friend? You don't want to fuck your big sister?"

"Well, no, it's not that," I stammered. I couldn't believe what was happening. Sure, I had had fantasies about Ash, but we were just friends. And what boy hasn't had fantasies about his sister? Especially one as hot as Lizz. "It's just a little surreal," I added.

"Well, it's time to make it real, little brother. So who's it going to be? You gonna fuck Ashley first or fuck me first?"