Finn's Last Dare ♡♤

“What do I have to do??” - Finn asked back, with all the determination, confidence, and wit in the world, as he was now willing, and committed to do anything with Lilith, although he couldn’t think of many things he could do with her. He thought there wasn’t much left to do, and he already tried everything with pretty much every girl in this house, but he was still surprised to hear what Faranne wanted him to do. In reality, Faranne was going wild with her dare, because she really wanted her little sister to pay for what she did tonight, and she thought the best way to end this game was some good impregnation in front of everyone.

“That’s the spirit… It’s very simple actually… I dare you to get my sister pregnant…” - Faranne replied casually, and so nonchalantly, that she got everyone to gasp in shock, even Zoey, who already had an idea of what could happen, but couldn’t believe it until she heard it. Faranne immediately made her own sister faint, only for a brief moment, but her dare was enough to make everyone question if they had actually done anything naughty tonight, because all the things leading up to this definitely couldn’t compare to the finale.

“WHAT????” - Finn exclaimed, pretty much like everyone else, after being dared to get Lilith pregnant. He wasn’t shocked by being dared to have sex with the catgirl in front of everyone, not even the fact that it was Faranne who was daring her, but the way that she sounded so calm when asking her to impregnate Lilith. Finn tried to stay as long as possible in denial, as it wasn’t even too unbelievable to think that Faranne was being serious right now. But after everyone got time to understand the weight of Faranne’s dare, she felt the need to explain herself a bit more, and entice everyone to get her little catgirl sister pregnant.

“Yea, it is that simple… Come on, we’ll help you do it… We just need to use that gorgeous cock of yours, you are the only one that can get a girl pregnant on this island after all… no offense Itzel...” - Faranne replied, with a more erotic voice, to seduce Finn into accepting his dare. And while her attitude was still very casual, she was being very provocative with her simple request, and she actually got everyone to desire the same thing as her, seeing Finn impregnate Lilith right in front of them. Zoey, Sayuri, Katsumi, and Faranne were ready for it, and even in position, but it took a bit more time to convince Finn, because he knew this was a big deal. But while he started hesitating, and questioning the morality of this decision, it seemed like Lilith also didn’t want to do this, and she was even more scared than before.

“WAIT!! I’m not ready to become a mother!... I can’t get pregnant!! Finn is going to destroy me with that thing!! Please don’t let him put it in…” - Lilith cried, clearly terrified of having Finn inside her, let alone have a baby with him. It was not that she didn’t want to have a child with him, she just believed the process would be extremely painful, so she wanted to avoid it at all cost. But as she was being restrained from any movement, Lilith felt like she was going to be forced to be used by Finn, and conceive a baby she didn’t really want.

Although, Faranne knew her little sister often lied, and tried to hide some information, mostly to play innocent, and make everyone think she is just a cute catgirl, but also to hide her true feelings. And at this moment, Faranne thought Lilith was hiding her true desires, and she secretly really wanted Finn to breed her, so she only needed some encouragement, or some reassuring words to make that happen. So while Finn continued thinking about his choice, Faranne tried to calm her sister down, in hopes to help her embrace the desire of becoming the mother of Finn’s children, and think about how beautiful being pregnant would be.

“Yes, I know… and you will love it… Trust me, having babies is the best thing in the world… And having babies with Finn is even better, right Zoey??” - Faranne whispered to her sister, with a soothing, but beguiling voice, as she really believed Lilith was just too shy to admit that she wanted Finn to impregnate her, and it didn’t seem like that was the case, but her comforting words made the catgirl feel a bit safer. Lilith still felt threatened, since she was being held in place, and it didn’t seem like it was her choice, but she was glad to see that Finn still hadn’t made a decision. But because Faranne was getting frustrated at her own sister, it was time to convince Finn to get Lilith pregnant, even if she didn’t want to, which she hoped would not be the case.

“Exactly… see Finn, we told you it was worth it to wait… Now help us impregnate Lilith!” - Zoey replied to Faranne’s question, and immediately addressed her boyfriend, to help seduce him into making babies with the catgirl, since clearly Lilith didn’t want to, or she was trying not to admit it. Finn needed to hear what Lilith had to say though, or else he would feel bad for forcing himself inside her, and giving her a baby she didn’t want. But since he was already imagining how their children would be, he was arousing himself, with the simple, yet very hot idea of impregnating his catgirl friend, who could now become the mother of her children.

Everyone eagerly waited for either of them to respond, say something, or show some type of reaction. But while Finn didn’t say a word, and didn’t show any sort of emotion, not even a smile, it seemed like he was convinced to do this, because his eyes were focused solely on Lilith’s small pussy, waiting to be bred by him. He still wasn’t sure if this was a good idea, he couldn’t tell if Lilith wanted this, or if he was about to rape her, so he tried to find out. But even though he tried not to scare the catgirl so much, when Finn approached her, Lilith immediately started to panic, while her friends started to laugh, and got turned on to see her so scared to have babies with Finn.

“Oh no… Finn... Don’t do this… I love you, but please don’t put it in…” - Lilith begged Finn, and while she wasn’t being too clear with her request, it was enough to make Finn stop. He didn’t proceed, and took a moment to think some more, but as he stared at Lilith’s desperate eyes, he thought he found an answer, and it seemed like he found what he was looking for. He couldn’t make sure until it was too late, but he could see in Lilith’s eyes that she was actually begging him to love her gently, and not be rough with her, just because she was scared of his size, and how painful making babies could be. But before Finn could come to a reasonable, and reassuring conclusion, which would let him have sex, and impregnate Lilith, without feeling too bad about it, he was interrupted by her horny girlfriend.

“Wow, did you hear that?? It seems like Lilith is also in love with Finn! Who isn’t at this point??...” - Zoey asked the foxgirls, and Faranne sarcastically, to try to entice Finn to give Lilith a baby, even when they both weren’t sure about it. She was too horny to think, and she could only focus on her boyfriend breeding the catgirl in front of everyone, but that lt Finn know that no one was considering Lilith’s feelings at this moment. Finn started to feel like his friends were being cruel, and he couldn’t do anything to his cute catgirl friend, even when he was being pressured to do so. So as hot as it would be to knock Lilith up, Finn tried to contain his urges, until Faranne decided to soothe Lilith’s worries even more, just to see if that could get them both to relax, and in the mood to reproduce.

“Come on now, you just confessed your love for Finn, that would only give him more reason to make love to you… Don’t worry, he is going to be careful… he is an expert at this point, you just have to feel how good his cock stretches you out and you will fall in love with him… trust me…” - Faranne whispered to Lilith with a playful, but heartfelt, and oddly comforting voice, which actually worked on calming her down. She was clearly joking around with Finn, and her experience with him, but Faranne really did mean to calm down her sister, and it seemed to be working fine.

But as Lilith was still very nervous, she at least wasn’t crying, or resisting at all, so that actually was all that Finn had to see to make his decision. He really believed Lilith was just scared of her first time with him, so he just had to be careful with her, and promise her that she was in good hands, and the baby making process was going to be painless, and maybe even enjoyable. Finn was still hesitating, and he didn’t know how to tell a girl he was going to knock her up, without making it sound too awkward, but he tried it anyways, and hoped it would really work (because it would probably be rape if it didn’t)

“Lilith, if you actually mean that… then I think I love you too… But just to make sure, we need to show our love for each other… So I’m sorry, but I have to do this… I promise to be gentle with you… Let me give you a baby…” - Finn said to Lilith, with a soft, nervous, but accidentally charming tone, which actually got Lilith to smile, and feel good to have Finn as the man to get her pregnant. Everyone remained quiet, since they knew they could ruin the moment with their horny comments, so they just let Finn share an intimate moment with Lilith, as they both stared into each other’s eyes, and felt safe to be together. They were still very nervous to make babies, specially with an audience, but Finn only tried to focus on the catgirl, and she seemed to be doing the same, that way they could forget about their worries, and express their love for each other, with the purest act of love.

So with Finn’s reassuring words calming down Lilith, and seemingly convincing her to let him impregnate her, Faranne, and pretty much everyone else just watched, as the moment turned from cute, to slightly awkward, to insanely hot in a few moments. After Finn got to promise Lilith everything was going to be fine, he got on top of her, and while trying not to scare her, he leaned in for a short kiss, only giving her a small peck on the lips, before pressing his already hard cock on her sex. Lilith didn’t even react, she was so comfortable to be with Finn, she just allowed him to do anything with her.

Lilith had now embraced the idea of having Finn's children, and even though she wasn’t completely ready to make babies with him, she fully trusted him, and after that sweet kiss, she couldn’t do anything but smile, as Finn got the courage to complete his dare. Everyone was trying their hardest not to say anything, since they feared they could ruin the moment, so they waited for Finn to make the first move, before encouraging him with all sorts of sexy words. And that seemed to work, as Finn felt relaxed, and as he kept staring at Lilith’s dreamy eyes, they both smiled at each other, before he firmly placed his hands on her narrow hips, and while being as gentle as possible, Finn pulled Lilith’s body toward him, to naturally let the penetration happen.

With Lilith being so small, and Finn being so big, it seemed like he was casually grabbing the catgirl by the hips, and using her as a cock sleeve, since he got to smoothly push his cock inside her small pussy, trying not to cause any pain, so being very slow, and delicate with Lilith‘s body. She didn’t even feel the initial penetration so much, and Itzel liked to believe it was because he had already stretched her a bit, so he was useful in some way, or that’s what he believed. But now, the halfling could only watch, as her crush was getting penetrated by Finn’s thick cock, which was not only superiorly bigger than his, but also seemed to be perfect to make babies.

Itzel didn’t care much at this point, he even found it hot, as well as all the girls that were watching. But all of them aside, Finn got to comfortable slide his lengthy dick inside Lilith, and while he did stretch her out quite a lot, it was slow enough for her not to feel it much, and he just inserted the tip inside, so the initial penetration felt nice, natural, and like they both were complete, now that their bodies were connected to one another. But after Finn noticed how Lilith was perfectly fine, and even smiling eagerly for him to start breeding her, he felt more confident to start the action.

He knew he was teasing their audience with his slow movements, but he genuinely wanted to be careful with the catgirl, and tried to be very gentle with the penetration. But now that it was done, and Lilith seemed happier, and even hornier than ever, Finn knew what he had to do next, and he didn’t waste time to start doing it. He knew what Faranne, Zoey, Sayuri, Katsumi, and even Itzel wanted to see, and he was planning to give them exactly that. And since even Lilith seemed to be wanting to get pregnant with his baby, Finn felt like it was about time to actually knock her up, so he started thrusting, and it quickly turned into the hottest scene all of his friends have ever seen (and even the hottest thing he had ever done with a girl to this point).