Knocking Up Lilith ♡♤

Finn began rocking his hips slow, and with the position they were in, he didn’t have to put much effort, just make sure he held Lilith’s body in place, so he could fuck her good, but gently. He continued trying to be careful, and not hurt the catgirl, but as he began pushing his dick deeper inside her tight pussy, Finn quickly got carried away, and accidentally picked up a pretty good pace. But as he was already fucking Lilith like he would do to any other girl in the room, Finn noticed that Lilith didn’t mind, in fact, it sounded like she was loving it, or at least that’s what he understood from the cute, soft moans she did every time he thrusted, which he found hot as hell, just like the rest of his friends.

“YES!! That’s it Finn!! Keep fucking Lilith like that!! Look at how cute she looks when you are breeding her tiny pussy!! - Zoey cheered, and encouraged Finn, who actually forgot he was having sex with Lilith surrounded by all of his friends. This only made it hotter for him, but he tried only to focus on making the catgirl feel good, instead of listening to whatever dirty things his friends told him. He knew they were enjoying it, and he was giving them a great show, but Finn really didn’t want to get distracted, and it was a good thing he kept his focus.

As Finn got a bit more cocky, and started thrusting faster, Lilith could feel how his thick cock stretched her inner walls, shaping her tiny hole to the exact shape of his perfect member, which also caused her lips to tightly grip Finn’s dick, making it easier for him to enjoy this moment, and maybe even make him cum faster. But while Finn just wanted to have fun with Lilith, and show her the pleasures of sex, just to make love to her, it seems like the catgirl did want to have babies with him, since she locked her legs around Finn’s waist, and held on to his body tightly, to help him fuck her deeper.

Her body was doing it entirely on it’s own, Lilith thought Finn was just making her feel good with his impressive dick, without even realizing that her body was begging, and trying to help Finn to get her pregnant. And even though he also wasn’t focusing on impregnating the catgirl, it seemed like that’s what he truly wanted as well, since he wasn’t afraid to hug Lilith back, and push his cock deeper inside her wet, tight hole. And while they were too lost in their intense, erotic moment, their friends who were watch were so aroused by this sight, they couldn’t help but make more dirty comments about the two of them (which did make sense, because they were just making babies right in front of them).

“I’m so jealous right now… I wish I was her at this moment… She must feel very lucky to receive Finn’s babies tonight…” - Zoey jokingly told Faranne, but that only made her more horny than she was. All of the girls were pretty much pleasuring themselves, while watching the most erotic scene ever, a handsome boy like Finn breeding a cute catgirl like Lilith. Just the position they were fucking in was insanenly erotic for all of them, and it was making it hard for them to think straight. But as they all were aroused by Finn’s and Lilith’s babymaking, they were also starting to lust over the idea of being in the position of the catgirl. Faranne was the one that desired it the most, and she actually felt a bit jealous of her own little sister, but both Sayuri and Katsumi wanted to get pregnant with Finn’s babies, after seeing how hot the process of making them was.

“And maybe you are next… but I think you already have his baby growing inside of you… Let’s just help Finn knock up Lilith and then we could all take our turn to get his babies, what do you think??” - Faranne replied in heat, trying to joke around with Zoey a little, but being too horny to think, because Finn just began pounding Lilith’s pussy faster, and she was starting to moan louder than ever. Faranne actually felt proud of both of them, because her little sister would become a mother, which weant she would be an aunt, and because Finn was so great at making babies, and seemed very confident with this position.

But as everyone could only watch Finn try his hardest to get Lilith pregnant, his friends felt like they could encourage him to breed her soon, to remind him about the goal of his dare, but also because they hoped they could have their turn of babymaking with him as well. So with Finn increasing the pace of his thrusts, and the catgirl making more cute, but sexy moans, everyone was down to cheer for them, and hoped they could actually conceive a baby together tonight, since it would probably be the craziest ending to a game in their entire lives.

“Yeah!! Knock her up Finn!! You can do it!!” - Sayuri, out of all people, exclaimed with excitement, as she was also very aroused to see Finn have sex with the catgirl. She was desiring to be in Lilith’s spot, and get knocked up like Finn was doing to the catgirl, but she could wait, because this was definitely hot, even though trying to make babies with him would be hotter. And since it seemed like Finn was seemingly losing energy rapidly, from all the other naughty things he did tonight, it seemed like he couldn’t last too long. But right as Finn lost his pace for a moment, Lilith finally told him what she wanted, and gave him permission to impregnate her.

“Finn... I want to be the mother of your child… Please knock me up… just be gentle, you are going to fast…” - Lilith whispered to Finn, and it was almost impossible to hear her, from how soft she was talking, and how her moans were louder than her actual words. But as Finn was close to her, he got to hear her, and accepted her request, by slowing down with his thrusts, but making sure he reached deeper inside Lilith’s tight pussy. They all found her words very cute, or at least the way she said it was adorable, but since she was asking Finn to get her pregnant, it was impossible not to be turned on to hear the catgirl say those dirty things.

And while Finn didn’t pay much attention to Lilith’s words, he was trying to fulfill her other request, of making her the mother of his child, and knocking her up in front of everyone, who were more than eager to see it happen, and just wanted to see Finn cum inside the catgirl, fill her womb up, and give her a couple of babies. This was the case for literally all of them, even Itzel, who felt a bit left out, but was still enjoying the show. And while Finn was struggling to keep his focus, and was starting to lose control of himself, he couldn’t resist anymore, not because he couldn’t handle the pleasure, but because his girlfriend was now whispering erotic things to him.

“You heard her, slow down a little, but fuck her deep… Get ready to knock her up, I know you are about to cum soon…” - Zoey whispered in Finn’s ear, with the most provocative voice she could come up with, which was more than enough to make him lose control. All the other girls started saying similar naughty things to him, but nothing got him more than that, it was just the way Zoey talked to him, like she knew exactly what he was feeling, and she was right, he was about to cum soon. So while Faranne, and the fox sisters tried to encourage Finn with some erotic words, he wasn’t hearing any of it anymore, he could only try to last a bit longer, and hope to be able to impregnate Lilith in the first try. But even when he tried containing it, Lilith’s moans were too intense for Finn, and it was even worse for him when she also started saying some pretty erotic things.

“Fuck me!! Cum inside of me Finn!! I want to be a mommy!! I want to have your baby!! Please give it to me!!!” - Lilith moaned, with an intentionally sexy voice, which actually sounded very natural, and even had that cute tone she always has, which only made it hotter for Finn. He found the catgirl’s begs irresistible, and as he felt his cock throb deep inside her, Finn knew he couldn’t last any longer, and he just had to release it all. He was hoping Lilith had already orgasmed at this point, but he didn’t realize that Lilith had already came on his cock multiple times, and she was constantly moaning in ecstasy, so she was more than ready to receive her fertile sperm, and let him knock her up.

“YES!! I’m going to… Lilith... get ready to have my child!! I want to knock you up!! - Finn exclaimed, with some very intense groans, as he was right about to bust inside the catgirl’s pussy, but he tried to talk dirty back to her, which didn’t really work out, because it made him lose control, although it did sound very hot to his girlfriend, as well as Faranne, who couldn’t wait to see her little sister get pregnant. They were all just wanting to see Finn breed Lilith, and while they got to see them both orgasm at the same time, they couldn’t actually see how they were exchanging fluids, or how Finn’s sperm was currently making its way to Lilith’s fertile womb.

Right as Finn felt his cock begin to burst inside Lilith, he knew he had to make sure he got to pump everything into her womb, to knock her up in the safest way, since he wasn’t sure if he had much left to give. After everything he did tonight, he already came in Katsumi’s mouth, he already creampied, and maybe even conceived with Zoey as well, but he now was trying to impregnate Lilith, and he thought that would be very hard to do. So to make sure he was successful in his first try, Finn held the catgirl’s body as close as he could, and pushed his cock deeper than ever, to the point it was brushing against her tiny cervix, waiting to receive his hot load of babies.

Perhaps Finn put too much effort into the positioning, but it still worked, and it looked very hot from the different views his friends had of the scene. Finn got cum deep inside Lilith, and even when he already orgasmed twice tonight, he still had a lot to give, so he ended up filling up the catgirl’s womb with his thick, fertile semen, which actually overflowed, from how potent the streams of cum were. His babies mixed with Lilith’s fluids as well, so it was difficult to tell how much she came inside of her, but even when no one could see it, Finn got to coat Lilith’s womb with a nice layer of his seed, which actually stood inside her, and quickly found the perfect egg to fertilize.

Reproduction between a human and a catgirl was fairly common, back in the day, so no one had seen something like this happen in a while. But as Faranne, Zoey, Sayuri, Katsumi, and Itzel witness how Finn filled up their cute catgirl friend with his cum, they had just watched the beautiful creation of life, and even when it didn’t seem like it, they were right next to them when Lilith became a mother. They had watched how Finn got to breed the catgirl, and they couldn’t even know it, but they all were very excited to find out if Lilith was now pregnant.

But after their fantastic climax, Finn and Lilith took some time to recover, and think about the baby they just made. She was already thinking about what she would do as a new mother, and he was still questioning if he had pumped enough sperm inside her to impregnate her. They were both doubting a lot about that, but they were lucky to have their friends supporting them, as they continued cheering for them, and congratulating them for conceiving a child. They all really believed they just watched how Finn impregnated Lilith, but they were sure about it, after he got off of her, and when he pulled out, a river of his thick sperm dripped out of the catgirl’s fertilized pussy (there was no doubt that he did knock her up).

“Ohh, that was amazing!!... Lilith, you are going to be a mother!! Look at that, I wonder how many babies you will have…” - Faranne exclaimed, both excitement, and disbelief, as she was still very horny to watch her little sister get knocked up by Finn, but she also couldn’t believe she just watched that happen, and she was now going to be an aunt. She couldn’t hide her emotions for this erotically beautiful moment, and the other girls made sure to show their support as well, while also showing a lot of interest in the idea of making babies with Finn. He didn’t pay attention to any of the girls except Lilith, since they just made a baby, and he wanted to enjoy this moment with only her, even when he appreciated all of the cheering from his friends.

“Thank you for making me a mommy Finn... I love you, but I hope you help me raise our children” - Lilith said shyly, as Finn helped her stand up, causing some of his sperm to drip down her sex, which Katsumi immediately tried to catch with her tongue, and even succeeded, but looked very silly while doing it. And even though Finn was mostly still horny, because he just got to breed his catgirl friend from childhood, he knew this was a serious moment, and he felt like he needed to say something to Lilith, because he was willing to be on her side at all times, and raise their babies together.

“I will, no matter how many kids we have… I’ll always take care of you Lilith...” - Finn replied, with a sincere, heartwarming smile, before giving the catgirl a kiss in front of everyone, which made Lilith blush so much, to the point she had to hide her face again, and look away, to then distance herself from him. Finn laughed at her cute reaction, but he didn’t understand why she suddenly got so shy, until he remembered he had all of his friends around him, and they looked very happy for both of them, although he noticed how the girls seemed hornier than ever.

Finn felt proud of himself, as he believed he just impregnated Lilith, and he had completed his dare. Even though he didn’t care about the game anymore, he felt like he completed his dare in the best of ways, and got the greatest results out of them all. But after he turned his attention back to his friends, he noticed that they seemed to be eager to play a bit more, which was a bit concerning, but also made him curious. He was tired now, since he just finished making babies with the catgirl, but as he took a seat on the bed, Finn realized this might not be over, since all the girls quickly sat next to him in bed, and started acting very flirty with him all of a sudden.

“Aww, that’s so cute… But enough talking… You already knocked up Lilith, so Finn, you better give us some babies too… We are all waiting to become mothers… Want to have kids with us too?” - Zoey whispered seductively to her boyfriend, as she teased him a bit, by brushing her finger on his flaccid cock, trying to get him hard again. But while he thought it was only Zoey trying to flirt with her, and get some more action, Finn quickly noticed that both fox sisters, and Faranne were doing something similar to her. He didn’t expect to find himself surrounded by all these girls, all trying to tease him, as they caressed his naked body in all sorts of suggestive ways, which pretty much told him everything he needed to know.

And while he was too tired to say anything, question their intentions, or even move, Finn already knew what this was about. Every single girl was giving him the same lustful stare, all of them, lusting over him, desiring to end up like Lilith tonight. Finn found it hard to believe, but it seemed to be the case, and it really felt like it was pulled from one of his most erotic dreams. Every girl wanted to get pregnant with him, they wanted him to knock all of them up, have his babies, just like Lilith.

He thought that maybe this was all part of Zoey’s plan now, but he really didn’t want to think much about it, so Finn thought there were not many options in this hot situation. It seemed irrational to resist it, and argue with each one of them, so he didn’t even try. And with all these naked girls around him, begging him to make them all mothers, Finn found it funny, because it seemed like everyone got jealous of Lilith, and now they all wanted what she got. But since the offer was also extremely hot to resist, Finn was too tempted by the unbelievable idea his girlfriend teased him about, so he decided to accept it, just to see if he would actually proceed to have sex with all girls in this room, and get them all pregnant. But as unreal as it seemed, and as confident as Finn was on this only being a fantasy, he was pleasantly surprised to see that Zoey was being very serious about this.

“Then I dare you to get every single one of us pregnant tonight…” - Zoey giggled, with the naughtiest smile Finn had ever seen, and without hesitation, he responded with a similar sexy expression. And while it still seemed like she was only joking, Finn was impressed to see how eager all these girls were to have his babies, and since he now had accepted the dare, he couldn’t turn it down now. So immediately after he smirked, Zoey didn’t waste time to get some babies out of him, and so did Faranne, Sayuri, and Katsumi, with even Lilith trying to help them make babies all night.

So that’s how the day ended. The seemingly most underwhelming Spirit Day in the history of this island ended up becoming the best day in Finn’s life. After he he got Lilith pregnant, he would spend several hours having sex with all the girls, trying to knock all of them up one by one. It took some time, and a lot of energy, but after that fantastic night of sex, and babymaking, they all definitely had something to celebrate for.

It seemed like there was nothing else to do, Finn could just stay on the island, at home, with his new huge family, as he had to raise a dozen children with his new lovers. He ended up having a similar night later on, but with every single girl at the island, the monster girls, and Milky included. But as he now had found his purpose of breeding every girl in his life, Finn realized this was all he was meant to do all along, and he really didn’t want anything else but to have this big family, date, have sex, and make babies with all of these sexy girls every single year… that was ñFinn}’s dream, and he was so glad to have reached it in such a simple night.

But of course, he then didn’t actually have a future, because this didn’t actually happen, it is non-canon, it is not part of the story dummy, don’t you get it?? Come on, you have to go back to the actual story, you can’t stay here forever. I know you want to see Finn fuck every girl and have a happy life with all of these girls, but you won’t get that, not yet. There is a big adventure awaiting for our protagonist, and it sure is long, so I hope you enjoyed these extra scenes, because you won’t see more of them in a very long time :D