2 vs 2

"Why not? So, what will it be, Captain Bell?" you ask. You put your weapon in your left hand and hold out your right, ready to shake hers as you anticipate her decision.

This only renews her resolve. "Never!"

She lunges at you, but before she reaches you the cardboard blunderbuss is aimed at her chest. "Bang!" you exclaim, and the enemy captain staggers back.

You then take aim at the mutineer, Fang. "Surrender or die."

"I'd rather die!" Tibby yells and charges at you.

This time you fail to swing the blunderbuss around fast enough to keep up with her nimble attack, and only barely fend off her jabs. Additionally, Captain Bell is still in the game despite her simulated wound. Clutching her side with one hand, she brandishes a cutlass with the other.

Fortunately, Daggertooth is still in the game too. Just as Annabelle joins the fight, Ashley takes Tibby out of it with a surprise tackle. Your pets tumble onto the bed and you're left to face off against Annabelle.

The Pirate Queen gets a few good strikes in, but in the end you manage to knock the blade out of her hand and **** her to retreat until she's standing with her back against the bed. Blunderbuss aimed at her head, you stand proudly before her.

"You should have accepted a truce, Bell!" You sneer. "I'm going to sink your ship as punishment, but first it's time to plunder... starting with the treasure chest you carry with you."

Annabelle is confused until your hand springs forward, feeling her bosom up through her shirt. You squeeze the soft shape concealed by the thin fabric with delight, then grin at her. "It feels like you've got some valuable loot in here. Let me see it!"

"No, it's mine!" she says, but you won't be denied again. Pushing your defeated foe onto the bed, you drop your weapon and pounce on her, unbuttoning her shirt despite her feeble attempts at resistance.

One button after another gives way, and Annabelle's impressive bust is revealed. For a moment you just stare at her breasts, admiring how they move with every breath. Then she snaps you out of it. "Is my treasure not what you were hoping for, Captain Barefoot? I thought you couldn't wait to get your hands on my loot."

"I have to check if it's real first, like how you bite coins to see if they're made of gold," you tell her. Your hands still on her blouse, you lower your head and catch a nipple between your lips. After sucking vigorously, you let it pop back out. "This one's real," you declare before diving onto the second.

You intend to give it the same treatment as the first, but Annabelle holds you down. "That was hardly a thorough inspection. You need to be sure it's real."

You've got no intention of doing otherwise. Sucking more of Annabelle's tit into your mouth, you grab the other with your hand and squeeze gently. But suddenly, you feel Ashley's hand on yours. "Are we dividing the loot, Captain?"

Instead of answering, you simply grab her head and pull her in, letting her have that boob. She starts sucking greedily, and then Tibby crawls over as well. It's clear she wants in, but there are only two nipples to go around.