It’s Olivia’s turn.

“Right.” Olivia swallows. “It’s my turn.”

You pull out of Jessica, who scoops the cum dripping from her pussy with her finger and licks it off with a blissful hum. On your knees, you turn to Olivia, who seems to be mentally preparing herself with a few deep breaths.

Now you can finally focus on her. What can you do to help? You know her first time was bad. She said the guy was too big and it hurt her. And as much as it pisses you off thinking about it, you can come up with a couple of reasons for it. One is that that’s just how Olivia naturally is. Her pussy might be too small to fit a big penis. However, while you still can’t rule that out, you’ve had sex with 10 women now, and none of them have complained that you’re too big. Perhaps the other guy was even bigger. The other reason, and the most probable, is that, since Olivia didn’t want to do it in the first place, she was probably not wet enough. The guy not only blackmailed her into sex, but didn’t even care how she felt about it.

“D-David? What’s wrong?” Olivia asks, looking nervous.

“W-What? Nothing’s wrong. Why do you ask?” You say.

“You were making a scary face.” Lilian points out.

“W-Was I? Sorry.” You say, smiling sheepishly. “Really, I shouldn’t be thinking of something unrelated now. That’s rude.” You lie.

“Is that so?” Olivia looks at you with narrowed eyes, not believing you for a second. “Fine. I’ll just make sure you can’t think of anything else.”

Again, she crawls on the bed and gets in all fours in front of your crotch. She opens her mouth and takes your cock inside it, rolling her tongue around it. She licks you clean and seems to be enjoying it thoroughly.

“Fuck, Olivia. You’re really good.” You groan in pleasure.

“…” She smiles wryly at you. “I like doing it for you.”

You mentally click your tongue. There must be something there, too, but better to leave it for another time. You remember Mia also had some issues with her history with blowjobs.

“Alright, that’s enough.” You tell her, gently putting a hand on her cheek. “Lay on your back.”

She swallows nervously, but does as told. But instead of going directly to the main act, you spread her legs, move her panties to the side and dive for her pussy.

“Wha- oooh!” She moans loudly, throwing her head back when she feels your tongue along her slit. “Fuck!”

She grabs onto the bed sheets and her body squirms. She bites her lip and moans sweetly. You eat her out as best you can, licking her clit and pushing your tongue inside while you caress her smooth thighs.

“David! Yeah! That’s… oh fuck, that’s great!”

“Maybe we rushed a bit too much?” Jessica asks Lilian. “That seems fun, too.”

“You heard what the others said.” Lilian shrugs. “He won’t get tired after three shots. We have all the time in the world.”

You can taste in your mouth just how wet Olivia is now. You wonder if you should continue until she comes or if you should try for penetration now. But Olivia herself gives you the answer to your unspoken question.

She throws away her bra, letting free her marvelous tits. They’re big, around the same as Sophia’s, and look very, very soft. She also takes off her panties and throws them to the side.

“I don’t care. I can’t resist anymore! Fuck me, babe. Let me make good on all the teasing since we met.” She says, grinning excitedly at you and spreading her legs.

You start kissing up her slender, curvy body. From her thighs, to her pussy, to her belly, to sucking on her nipples and massaging her incredibly supple breasts, to licking her neck until you’re face to face with her. The tip of your cock pushes against her labia, making her shudder.

“…Go slowly.” She asks, wrapping her arms around you.

“Tell me if anything’s uncomfortable for you.” You nod.

The head of your cock goes in, and you can tell she’s incredibly tight. Her pussy grips you, and you feel Olivia getting tense below you. She doesn’t say anything, and nods for you to continue.

But instead of pushing further, you pull out and push again only to the tip of your dick. And again and again, settling into a slow, but steady rhythm.

“Ah…!” Olivia moans with eyes closed. Bit by bit, you’re able to fit more of your length inside her, deciding to stop pushing for more when you’re halfway inside her.

You plant a soft kiss on the left corner of Olivia’s mouth, right where her sexy little mole is. She kisses you back, moaning into your mouth as she feels you going in and out of her.

“That’s not all, right?” She asks with a nervous smile.

“No.”

“I think you can go a little deeper.” She says, swallowing.

“Okay. But let’s not rush anything.” You tell her. “Just being like this with you is amazing already.”

“Yeah.” She sighs, relieved. “You feel so good inside me, babe.”

You chuckle at the nickname and kiss her again. Your hands knead her soft breasts as you keep thrusting inside her. And as you continue, more and more of you fits inside her.

“Yeah…! Yeah…! David! Deeper! It’s fine! Give it to me deeper!”

Though she says that, you’re still worried, so you keep the steady rhythm, slowly pushing more of you inside her after every thrust. Olivia kisses your neck, sending shivers down your back.

She moans and hold onto you tightly. “Fuck! Fuck! I love you so much! Come inside me and make me yours, too!”

“Yeah.” You grunt from the pleasure. Slowly and as she relaxes, Olivia has been loosening up a bit, yet still remaining so tight that it’s like she’s squeezing the life out of you. She feels incredible, and since you’ve been taking your time making love to her, you feel ready to burst.

You thrust inside her and finally your hips make contact with hers. All of your cock is inside her, making Olivia bite her lips and groan in delight.

“Holy shit! It’s so good!” She grins. “Kiss me again, babe! Come inside me!”

You grind your hips against her, locking your lips with hers as she moans uncontrollably.

Her pussy squeezes you wonderfully, her skin feels smooth in your hands, kissing her makes you feel lightheaded, and most of all, knowing you’re fucking the woman who used to torment you makes you feel like you’re at the top of the world.

You release your still powerful third shot inside Olivia. Her body shakes violently, her hips raising to meet yours, her pussy coils around your cock. Her mouth hangs opened in a silent scream and her body squirms below you as she rides a long and powerful orgasm.

“Fuck yes…” She breathes deeply and looks into your eyes with a red face. “Oh my GOD! Just marry me, please.”

Your heart skips a beat. She might just be saying that due to the high of her orgasm, but god damn does it have an effect on you. But you swallow it. Now’s not the time to be talking about that.

You plant a kiss on her forehead and caress her cheek. “Let’s talk about that after you’ve calmed down, okay?” You smile.

“Sure.” She smiles back, looking stunningly beautiful.

“I’m gonna assume you had no issues, then.” Lilian says, grinning teasingly.

“Zero.” Olivia says, laying on her back as you pull out. “Fuck, why couldn’t you be my first time? You two are so damn lucky.” She tells her friends.

“I guess we are.” Jessica giggles and hugs you from behind. “I still can’t believe you did it with all three of us.”

“Yeah!” Lilian nods several times. “Are you some kind of stamina monster?”

“Well, sorry to break the illusion, but there’s a bit of magical enhancement helping me out.” You admit sheepishly.

“Three fucking hurrahs for magic, then.” Olivia grins, sitting up. “Because we’re still not done here, are we?”

“Of course not.” You grin. “This is just the beginning. You girls do know I’ve wanted to do this since I first saw you, right?”

“I can imagine.” Jessica says, kissing your neck and rubbing her chest against your back. “Fuck us again, amor.”

“You’ve been calling him that.” Lilian points out. “What does it mean?”

“Love in Portuguese.” Jessica answers. “And Spanish too, I guess.”

“And you.” Lilian looks at Olivia with narrowed eyes. “You suddenly started calling him ‘babe’. What’s with the nicknames?”

“I don’t know? I just felt like it.” Olivia shrugs.

“Do I need to call you by a nickname too?” Lilian asks you.

“Please don’t **** it.” You chuckle. “If it doesn’t come naturally, I’d much rather you just call me by name.”

“Okay, good.” Lilian sighs. “Because I can’t really think of anything.”

Her eyes then travel down your body to your crotch. She looks at Olivia, who’s still a little lightheaded, and takes her chance. She gets on all fours and crawls to you, facing your dick.

“Can I?” She asks you with a quick lick to her lips.

“Sure.” You nod eagerly.

“Remember to avoid using your teeth.” Olivia tells her.

Lilian nods and starts to gently lick your cock, trying its taste and cleaning it up. Meanwhile, Jessica turns your head a bit and captures your lips. Her tongue playfully rolls around yours.

It’s about 6:30 pm right now. There’s still a lot of time for you to spend with your three new girlfriends.