Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by DenomZero DenomZero

Who are you going to try it with?

[Ritual] Frank the gentleman

After thinking about it for a minute you decide to go with the guy with the tattoo on his chest - he seemed like a pretty nice guy, you like nice guys. "We'll go with you Frank, right..Helena?" You feel embarrased to confirm it with her, because she seemed to be more interested in the guys who promised to actually have sex with us - that was the whole point after all.

"Uhh, sure?" Helena says unsure and you go to Frank. He's handsome and his middle section is less prominent than the others and so are his arms. You don't really like muscular guys anyways, because they'll never be good huggers. "Hey, look at that. If you don't hear from me I'll say that I'm just hanging with my new girlfriends, no, just kidding. Let's go girls." He says cheerfully and the other people roll their eyes and shrug.

"Hey you two. Why did you come talk to us really? I mean, you could've gone to the party with that car of yours, what are you planning? Oh, forgive my nosiness, I'm just really curious." He asks you two as he walks you two toward his house. "We…uh, well I guess… I guess we wanted to meet new people." you answer haphazardly and Frank chuckles.

You get to his small rent home, not too different from yours, and go in. "I'm sorry, it's like a tornado came through here, but ugh, make yourselves at home." Frank suggests and starts picking up sportswear and school stuff from the tables and floor. You blush as you realize that you are in his home now - his hair and face are really cute in your opinion and he is almost like your dream boyfriend or something, that big tattoo being the only turn-off.

Helena sits on the sofa and removes her hat, she looks up at you with something in her eyes, you know what that is. "Oh, do you girls drink coke, beer, water?" Frank shouts from the kitchen and you shout back nervously: "Water is fine!" He comes back with three glasses of water and squats before you and looks at you two with an amused expression. "You girls really want to have sex huh? You should inform me beforehand, shouldn't you." He sighs and rounds the small glass table he put the drinks on and sits next to Helena who instantly looks up at him.

"We, ugh… Yeah, right March?" Helena looks back at you blushing and you feel like dying. "Well girls, I feel pretty conflicted here. If you want sex then, well do something about it. I can't all the work myself or soon I'll be charged of sexual ****. Oh, you girls are 18 or older, right?" Frank asks leaning on his thighs and looking at you two with his grey eyes.

"We are, really… Do you want us to strip for you?" You ask and blush. He shrugs and says: "That's the classic way this happens." Helena gets up and starts pulling her beautiful dress down. You do the same on your blouse, but then remember your penis - oh shit.

"Don't worry girls, we can do this any way you want. I won't be doing anything you don't like, and I hope you don't do anything nasty to me either." He says and removes his mask and starts pulling down his jeans. "D..do you mind…th...that I, ugh." You **** on your words as you try to make a casual question about your penis.

"I'm ok with pretty much anything. Want me to lick you anywhere, ok. Want to do anal, I'm game. Hell, ask one of the other guys here to have a foursome and I'm just fine. I don't care as long as we have fun, you know." He speaks so fluently about embarrassing subjects like that - you feel your panties starting to moisten up.

"Uhh, are you bi? I mean, the thing you said about the other guy…" You ask and cover your boobs for now - Helena is all naked and doing the same, but with her obviously smaller B-cup breasts. You think that Helena's slim body is very beautiful although it's kinda weirdly poportunate like her face. Her stomach is long if that makes sense and her posture is very backwards tilted. Her waist is hardly slimmer than yours and her butt is small and cute.

"Oh, well does it matter? Were you thinking of inviting someone here?" He blushes a little and you start getting more confident. "Uhh, well I have something that…" You end the sentence and just pull your skirt and panties down revealing your engorged penis and balls. You look at him holding your breath, while he looks dumbfounded and Helena backs away and sits on the couch mouth open.

"Uhh, it's a penis. So, I'm sorry, but you are a guy right? I…I..I don't judge, it's just that you could've fooled anyone, I think." He stammers and looks at you confused. Helena is blushing and looking awfully horny and bothered. "I'm a g..girl. H..here, I have a pussy too." You lift up your balls and give them an embarrassing look at your wet pussy. "I've pfff, ok, so you still wanna do it, I'm just fine with it, but what about you?" Frank asks Helena and she looks around with a little smile: "I'm her friend, I already knew…" That's not true, but it eased up the tension quite a bit.

You strip all the way down and sit on Frank's leg, your testicles rest on his thigh, but neither of you really care. You lean in and start softly playing with his manly body. His abs and chest are both super fit and you can't help but giggle as you run your fingers on them - so hot. "Oh, crap. You don't mind if I get a little feel of your breast, right?" He asks and you smile at him. He takes your boob and starts playing with it very softly. You get very wet and leak on his thigh.

You pull closer and kiss him. He has a bit of a beard and cute mustache which tickle a bit, but you just enjoy his touch and tongue. Helena snuggles on him and starts rubbing his boxers. You are really hard and horny and you start playing with his neck and ear as Helena kisses him. You grab his hard shaft through his boxers and realize that it's not much bigger than yours, you hoped it was, but regress.

Frank pulls his boxers down and without thinking much you take the shaft in your mouth. It tastes like a sweaty skin, nothing too disgusting but not anything like a candy cane. The head feels funny and it's fun to play with it with your tongue. He groans and you start pumping it while playing with his testicles with your hand. Helena leans next to you and as you raise your gaze she starts licking really close to your mouth on the penis. You try to take care of your side as Helena licks her side. You don't kiss or anything, but it still feels fun and hot.

"I'm going to cum soon, don't you w…want to have an orgasm too?" He pants blushing and you smile at him and Helena gets on the couch and puts her bended back to work as she pushes her little butt up at Frank. Her little pussy is just as soaked as yours and you start feeling really horny.

"M…March, was it? Uh, if I do her, will you do me? Shit, I shouldn't have asked…" Frank asks coyly and gets behind Helena slowly pushing his penis in the witch girl's pussy - she moans and starts panting cutely. You give it a thought, but decide to just do it. Frank has a pretty good butt for a guy and you feel around nervously until you find his little butthole. You gulp and push your penis in there. Frank groans and grabs his ass to make the hole open up a bit more.

You manage to slam it in and moan as it feels really good on your penis. Frank is panting intensely as he fucks Helena who is absolutely moaning in the cutest way. You fuck his ass and feel like passing out as you thrust your cock in and hold his strong body a bit of like a buttress, oh wait.

You go for a few minutes until Frank moans almost like a girl and says with a high-pitched voice: "I'm going to c…cum...oh crap…" Helena pulls her shaking self off and starts blowing him while you continue your steady thrusts. His moans are really girly now and you love it. You bend down pressing your breasts on his back and rapidly thrust in him making your penis go over the edge and absolutely fill his rectum with your seed. He screams and apparently cums in Helena's throat as she coughs and breathes deeply. You slide your penis out and collapse on the sofa exhausted and red.

He stays up for a bit, cum leaking out of his ass and penis. He sighs and drops on the floor eyes blank and tongue out. Helena almost looks like she's about to cry, but just giggles and plays with the cum on her chest and face. You feel your penis softening, but suddenly a coldness encaptures you. Your mind starts spiraling and your existence turns trivial as your mass turns into nothingness.

*You have completed the ritual and acquired access into a distant universe where every girl of the party is a futa.*

...

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)