Katie’s big birthday surprise

The rest of the night went slowly. All he could think about was the impending surprise for Katie that he was now about to play a big part in.

Over the course of the evening, Mark seemed to find himself alone quite frequently. He was only staying late because of what he had promised to be apart of it.

Every time that Katie passed him that night, she gave him a bit of a dirty look, clearly not happy that he was here.

Jesus Christ she looked hot. Those bouncing big breasts, her dark hair tied back in a ponytail and her smoking ass in those leather black pants. It was starting to sink in that he in less than a couple of hours, he would be standing naked in front of her where she would have the chance to explore his body.

When the time came, most people were started to head off to bed, especially considering it was a Wednesday night and most students had classes the next day.

Tayla had indicated to Mark from across the room to meet her out in the hallway again. Leaving his drink on a nearby table, he followed her out to the hallway where Taylor and two senior boys were standing.

Both guys were much bigger in terms of muscle size. One had a massive height advantage too. Mark started to really doubt his chances of winning this thing.

T1 and T2 led the three boys to Katie’s room. Once inside, the saw that the beds had been pushed to one side of the room.

“Okay boys, chop chop, start stripping” demanded Tayla.

Mark was a little hesitant but as the other guys began to remove their clothes quickly, he had no other choice.

The two girls stood in front of them, hands on hips enjoying the view of three very naked men in front of them. They got them to line up side by side, some space in between each of them. He didn’t want to look to either side of him so he focused on front of him.

“Stay there, I’ll be right back with the birthday girl,” Taylor said as she went outside to find Katie.

A minute later, in walked in the birthday girl still in the same clothes, her dark hair tied back in a ponytail, her eyes now covered with a black bandana that was wrapped around their head.

“Is this some sort of joke, how do I even know there’s guys in here,” she said blindfolded.

Katie had already been informed on what was happening but there was a part of her that didn’t believe it.

“Why don’t you come forward and feel for yourself,” said Tayla from the side.

Mark watched the sexy busty dark haired girl move forward slowly with her arms out stretched. Katie kept moving forward until she felt some skin. She had her left hand on the tall guy that stood on Mark’s right side.

He watched as she used her right hand to feel Mark’s shoulder. She was using both hands to explore the two bodies. The soft feel of her hand sent shivers down Mark’s spine.

She moved her hands across, shuffling to her right, to find the third body. As she did, her hands moved across Mark’s chest to get there.

“It’s just the three yeah?” Katie called out behind her.

“Correct.”

“Why don’t you explore them one by one and then make your decision on who you’re keeping in here.”

Katie agreed, and moved both hands to the senior boy on Mark’s left. He watched on with a bit of envy and the excitement of knowing he would probably be next.

She felt his face, the short hair he had and slowly moved her hands down. Katie brought herself closer to his body, so much that her tits were now brushing against his skin.

Katie moved her hands down to his butt, giving it a nice squeeze. That squeeze led to a different squeeze to his penis. The big titted senior girl was now using both hands to play with the guy’s cock, trying to get it to stiffen in her hands.

It didn’t take long at all, she now had his dick completely hard as she softly jerked it.

The guy’s body may have been built like a soldier but he’s little soldier downstairs didn’t live up to the girls expectations.

To put it bluntly, it was small. The size of it really didn’t change that much as it stiffen in her hands. You could tell Katie wasn’t too overly impressed, she flicked it around in her hand, not really enjoying it much.

After a minute or two, she moved over to Mark in the middle. Katie got a better feel of his chest this time, she moved her soft hands around, feeling him up.

Mark began to panic, he was worried that she would be turned off immediately since he wasn’t built like the two guys next to him.

“Hmm, not into the gym that much are we?” She said, moving her hands downwards.

Her little shot at him hurt but he couldn’t help feel himself stiffen as her fake nails scrapped along the front of his body downwards to his member.

Before exploring it, Katie did the same thing she did to the guy on his left. She grabbed his clenching butt, squeezing it in her hands.

Mark and a very nice soft ass that girls quite enjoyed feeling up.

Her hands then crept back to the front of his body as she felt his now hard and stiff dick. Katie clenched it in one hand and very slowly jerked it up and down, kneeling in front of him.

“Mmm this is a bit better,” she whispered as she worked her hand up and down his shaft.

Mark didn’t exactly have a big dick but compared to guy to his left, it made him look a long bigger than he was.

She started wanking him off a bit quicker, Mark began to breathe heavier as the hot senior worked on his cock. Katie looked so hot underneath her blindfold, she sped it up before surprising him with sticking her tongue out and giving it a nice long lick up the shaft.

Mark desperately tried to stop himself for moaning out loud.

She teased him more by sticking her tongue out and licking the head of his penis, making it twitch. With one last slow jerk, she let it go, standing back up and moving to the final guy.

As Katie explored the tall senior boy on his right, Mark felt his own dick his hands, he could feel where she had licked it right up the shaft. Just the feel of where he tongue was making his horniness strengthen.

He’s chances of being the last guy left was beginning to lessen though as Katie was loving the feel of the tall guy’s body. On her knees, she played with his dick, giving him a nice slow handjob.

Taking it one step further than she did with Mark, Katie took the guy’s dick right into her mouth as she sucked on his knob.

Releasing him with a pop, she went to give him a bit more of a wank, now that it was wet from the inside of her mouth.

It didn’t last long though as he unexpectedly began unloading himself, releasing spurts of cum towards the shocked girl.

“What the fuck!” She yelled out as she clenched up her shoulders feeling drops of cum splash her in the face and neck.

She wiped it off quickly, rubbing on the guy’s leg.

“I had you in my mouth for literally like five seconds,” she said, annoyed by his premature ejaculation.

“Just don’t take off your blindfold yet, you need to pick which guy you’re keeping,” said Taylor, worried she was going to whip it off right there and then.

“Ehh not exactly the best choices you could give me but just give me a second to think,” she said getting to her feet and thinking about the three boys.

Mark knew she was 100% going for the guy on his right until he prematurely cummed on her face. Clearly he was still her preferred choice but now that he blew it like that, Mark was a chance.