Katie picks Mark

Katie stood back giving her a decision a bit of thought.

“Even though I was loving the big boy on the end here, You’ve blown your chance tonight so I’m going to have go with.... the one in the middle ” she said pointing to Mark.

The girls were surprised with the result, it was in expected, considering the chiselled body of the boy on his right. His tall height and large penis were talking points of all girls to see him in the nude. Even if he didn’t have much stamina at all for a big guy, it seemed as if he was going to have to be the winning choice.

“Alright then Katie,” said Tayla, clapping her hands together, “Just keep the blindfold on a little longer as we get the other boys out of here.”

Tayla motioned for the two other guys not chosen to collect their clothes and get out of the room with them. Mark couldn’t help but smile as he watched the two dejected lads leave Katie’s room.

The girls followed them out, Tayla gave him a wink before shutting the door.

As soon as the sound of the door shut, Katie peeled off her blindfold to see her birthday present.

Unfortunately it wasn’t what she wanted to see and it wasn’t the reaction that Mark wanted to see himself.

“You?!? Are you fucking kidding me?” she exclaimed, poking his chest with a finger, “I had my fucking tongue on you.”

Mark stood petrified, the senior girl with melon shaped tits stood in front of him angry as hell. Her incredible figure and snarky attitude may have been super hot but it was also super scary for Mark.

“What? Got nothing to say?” She said, crossing her arms in front of her, just below her boobs. The arm cross just made those beauties bludge even more.

“I umm I... I’m sorry? Tayla asked if I could do it.”

She just remained crossed, shaking her head at him.

“Why is it such a big deal. You seemed to be more than happy when you had your hands all over my dick but as soon as you found out it was me, you freak out, why?? What’s wrong with me? You were fine with making out with me in public,” he said, finally standing up for himself against her.

She looked a bit surprised that he went after her like that, giving him so many questions to answer.

“You’re a freshman,” she started explaining, “I just made out with you that day to make something jealous. That’s all. Like I said, if you really want to do me that much, you should get with my sister.”

Mark was very much considering just leaving, he’d had enough of her complaining and he figured she wasn’t going to want to do anything with him. However, he decided to give it one shot, one attempt to at least make her birthday some what worth wild.

“I get you don’t want anything to do with me, you don’t want to touch my dick again, but maybe I can at least please you, it’s your birthday after all, you should be treated like a Queen, if you let me have the opportunity to go down on you, I won’t let you down. I’ll stay here and worship you for hours if that’s what you want, just please, let me make your birthday end on a good note.”

Katie’s face didn’t move much, she thought about his request. Making up her mind, she moved up to him again, “I’ll give you 2 minutes, 2 minutes to impress me, if you can’t, you’re out of here, if you can, then I’ll let you stay to finish me off.”

Mark’s dick twitched at her whispering words. To get the opportunity to worship a goddess like body such as Katie’s was honestly an absolute blessing.

As she hopped on top of the bed to lay down, Mark moved over to her, still naked from the birthday surprise. He went over to help unzip her pants but received a smack to the wrist, “I’ll handle this, thanks.”

Boy, that feisty attitude, he was in for a treat.