Scavenger Hunt

I walked up to Emily’s apartment, and knocked. The door opened, Emily beaming at me.

“Cole! Hi!” she threw her arms around me and I was a little bit shocked, but pulled her body close to me. We stood like that for a minute before she stepped back, smiling shyly.

“Have you meet Peggy?” she asked, and I shook my head.

“Oh, you should. She’s great.” Emily smiled. She put her hand on my shoulder and leaned close to me to whisper in my ear.

“She’s also a stripper. But she’ll never mention it unless prompted.” Emily informed me, and I wrapped an arm around the blond, and she gave me a big smile.

“I missed you.” I whispered, and she nodded, eyes shining as I leaned in, about to kiss her.

“You guys coming?” a voice called. I startled out of nearly kissing Emily. The moment broken, we sprung apart and went inside.

“Hi, I’m Peggy Conners.” the beautiful girl inside smiled at me.

“Hey. Cole Campbell.” I grinned at her, imagining her stripping. She averted her eyes bashfully at the heat in my eyes, but she gave me a coy smile as the intercom crackled.

“Hello, Apartment Wars teams! Please report to the lobby in thirty minutes!” Natalie announced.

“So, are you guys together?” Peggy asked, licking her lips.

“No!” Emily cried way too quickly.

“Mhm. So you won’t mind if I do this?” Peggy said innocently, and she crossed the room, slamming her body against mine, and she kissed me feverishly. My hands cupped her amazing ass, as she mewled softly against my lips.

“You’re SO good.” Peggy groaned. She leaned back from the kiss but kept her arms wrapped around me. I spared a glance at Emily, who looked flushed and upset.

“That’s what I thought.” Peggy said triumphantly, and kissed me again, sweeter this time. She put her hands on me, all over me. Peggy thrust her hips aggressively into mine as we kissed, and soon it looked like we were fucking with clothes on. Emily was close to tears but was trying hard not to cry in front of Peggy. The sexy redhead girl gave me a final quick kiss and then stepped back from me, looking more than a little flushed and turned on.

“Why are you so hot?” she giggled. Emily sniffled.

“Stop whining, darling. I asked if you were together with him, and you said no. Congratulations, Cole, Emily’s in love with you.” Peggy winked. Emily blushed hard as Peggy made kissy face.

“I... I am in love with you.” Emily confessed. I smiled warmly.

“I love you, too Emily Willis. I’ve never stopped, really.” I promised, and her eyes shone with joyful tears. I crossed the room and Emily put her hands on me, and stood on her toes to kiss me softly. I kissed her back passionately, wrapping my arms tightly around the blond and lifting her up. Her legs wrapped around me, and her amazing tits pressed into my chest as I kissed Emily. It has been so long since I kissed Emily.

“I love you.” she whispered. I nodded.

“Peggy, could we have a minute alone?” I asked. Peggy nodded and left. Emily dropped to the floor, averting her gaze.

“I know what you want to talk about. You having other women.” Emily sighed.

“Yes. I have a lot of women who really like me. I don’t want to leave them high and dry, you know. I love you, so much, Emily, but you’re just not the only girl in my heart. You’re the one I want to spend my whole life with, but you’re not the only girl for me, right now.” I said. Emily nodded.

“As long as it’s just sex, I guess it’s no harm done. And I’ll even toss in five dates. I love you, too Cole. And I don’t want to lose you.” Emily whispered, and I kissed her fondly. Then I winced.

“I’ll have to break things off with Cassidy, I guess.” I sighed. Emily looked up at me with wide eyes.

“What if you... didn’t?” Emily whispered shyly.

“Huh?” I asked, confused.

“I’m just saying, the whole you being with another girl? I’ve had a lot of dreams about that. And I’m totally OK with you continuing to date Cassidy. I’d just prefer you don’t tell her about us.” Emily said quickly, ashamed.

“Em. You don’t have to be ashamed of what you want in life.” I told her, and she giggled.