Test Them.

"Hmm... which of you wants it more?"

Ashley snorts. "Please, how transparent can you get? We're not going to get competitive."

"Yeah, not happening," Tibby confirms. "Even if I didn't think she earned first place with that lap dance, I want to watch her get fucked."

"Plus we already made an agreement. I get you first."

"And if I disagree? What kind of pets team up against their owner like that?"

Tibby sticks her tongue out and twists around to sit on the edge of the table, her legs spread provocatively. "If you don't like it, you can always punish us."

"No I can't," you say with your best serious face. "I'm too horny to punish anyone right now."

You have to wait for their laughter to die down before you can continue. "Well since Ashley's the only one in position, she might as well go first."

"Go ahead then." Tibby sits back next to Ashley, her hands at her sides.

"Don't rush me," you grumble as you undress. With one finger you probe between Ashley's legs. Her lips are swollen and wet, and you slide in easily. Her performance must have aroused her as much as it did you. Never the less, you tease at her clit for a bit before grabbing your dick and getting into position.

Bracing for your first penetration, the bunny reaches out for Tibby's hand, who looks on in awe as you enter your friend from behind. You push halfway in, then pause to let her adjust. When she's ready, you start feeding the rest in with slow thruts, each penetrating slightly deeper than the one it follows.

Through her moans, you hear a second, softer set of mews and notice that Tibby is fingering herself with her free hand. Stabilizing yourself with your right hand on Ashley's hip, you reach the other over to stroke Tibby's leg.

Taking her eyes off the action for the first time, she raises it to rub her foot against your bare chest. Looking down, you see her toenails are painted in three colors. Jet black, bright purple, and pale green. Lifting her foot up for a closer look, you bring it to your mouth and kiss its ball and the underside of her toes, marveling at how soft her skin is even here. It smells clean too, with only a hint of fresh sweat getting past the fading floral scent of her soap.

Unable to keep her balance, Tibby lets herself fall onto her back. Releasing Ashley's hand, she reaches over to fondle her boobs, transforming her moans into little sqeaks. You give Tibby a few more kisses, then lower her leg onto your shoulder and feel your way down its length. Rubbing Tibby's inner thigh, you approach her pussy only to find Ashley has beaten you there.

"Too slow!" she declares through her moans, but her fingers move up to give you access. You slide two fingers into your kitty, curling your fingers inside her to reach the most sensitive spots while Ashley stimulates her stiff clit.

After a while you let Ashley take over again, preferring to move your hand down to press a finger against Tibby's rear entrance. She groans when it slips inside her, and Ashley tries to lift up so she can see what's happening. But Tibby pulls her into a kiss, and snakes her own hand down to join your cock between her legs.

She doesn't let up until Ashley's body shakes, her ecstatic sounds muffled by Tibby's mouth. You give her a few more thrusts while her orgasm winds down. Pulling out, you reposition yourself and lift Tibby's other leg onto your shoulder.

Still breathing hard, Ashley straightens up and looks at you curiously. "Are you sticking it in her butt?"

"No," you tell her. "It would probably hurt with this little prep. I'd need to use at least two fingers on her first, or have her wear her other tail for a while."

Standing next to you, Ashley watches as you enter Tibby's pussy. Knowing you must be close to cumming as well, her hand returns to Tibby's clit and she bends over to suck a nipple into her mouth. Tibby latches on, holding Ashley's head to her chest and peeking between her long white ears to make eye contact with you.

Knowing what she needs, you slam into her roughly, shaking both girls' bodies and making Tibby squeal with delight. You won't last long like this, but you intend to use the time you have to give your pet as much pleasure as possible. Angling your dick in an attempt to reach the same spots as before, you saw in and out of her with abandon. Her pussy clenches around you, made tighter by the way her legs are pressed together. You cum before her, but your spasms send her over the edge and she wraps her arms around Ashley's head, unintentionally protecting her ears as she shouts out her orgasm.

Pulling out and tapping on Ashley's butt to let her know she can take her mouth off Tibby, you help the bunny up and pull Tibby back into a seated position.

"You really do know how to work together. I must be the luckiest man in the world."

"Aww, that's so sweet." Ashley leans in to kiss you on the cheek. Tibby wants to give you the same from the other side, but finds that she can't get up with you standing in the way and settles for your jaw line. To make up for it she adds a lick to your chin, after which you bend down to kiss her on the lips.

Ashley smirks. "Now if we're done being sappy, I have to go wash your cum out of these ears before it ruins them."