A promised date and an unannounced visit.

On Friday, as promised before, you take Emily and Megan on a date. It was them that suggested dinner and a movie. You go right after school, too, since they have another match tomorrow.

You don’t know what to make of it, but something about this date feels… off. Like it doesn’t feel… special. That’s not to say it’s isn’t, or that it’s not fun, because it is! It’s just that you and the girls are so used to each other by this point that it feels like you’re just hanging out rather than a date.

You suppose that’s its own kind of special.

At dinner, Emily laughs at how you won Megan’s dad over. None of you expected him to be into old shows like those, but hey, the man has good taste. You watch your blonde girlfriend while suppressing a grimace. You’ve yet to tell her about her mother having the app, too. You just don’t want to tell her in the middle of the date and completely ruin the good mood.

You watch the movie, and while it’s good, it’s not really your cup of tea. The girls are both really into it though. There’s an unexpected, but very well directed sex scene that takes you three by surprise.

As it happens, both girls lean on your shoulders at each side of you and subtly grope your crotch with big grins on their faces. You don’t know if the boner is because of them or the scene, but the movie is to blame for your growing arousal.

Over the course of the movie, the girls get touchier with you. You feel bad telling them to stop, because they seem to be enjoying themselves by groping you in their favorite places, but you can’t help but feel uncomfortable about it. Mainly, it’s because some people notice and look awkward that you feel uncomfortable.

“Girls, we’re making people feel awkward.” You whisper to them with a wry smile.

Megan suddenly remembers she’s in a public space and quickly straightens up on her seat, while Emily does so reluctantly and with an annoyed groan.

After the movie, you invite the girls back to your place, but they refuse because of something you hadn’t thought about.

“They say… sex before a big game is bad for your performance.” Emily says with a grimace.

“It’s really just a rumor, and we never paid any mind to it, but now…” She smiles apologetically. “We don’t want to risk it.”

You can’t help but groan. “Fine, but just let me remind you it was you who got all touchy during the movie.” You were sure you’d get some relief after.

“I’m sure at least one of the other girls is free.” Megan offers with a sheepish grin.

“Maybe,” You say before walking up to the and giving each a kiss in the forehead. “I wanted you, though.”

You see their faces blush. They both kiss your cheeks at the same time and laugh at having the same idea.

“Sorry, tiger. You know we’d do it if we could, but I couldn’t forgive myself if we lost tomorrow because of me.” Emily says, and her teammate nods in agreement.

“I know.” You nod and smile. “Hey, I’m a big boy. I can take it.” You spare one last look at Emily, then at Megan.

“By the way,” You say, your face and voice turning serious. “I have something important to tell you all. Would you mind coming to my place on Sunday?”

“So, it’s everyone-at-once important?” Megan asks.

“Yes.”

“Alright, we’ll be there.” Emily says, then whispers. “If we’re lucky, it might turn into another orgy afterwards.”

You very gently flick your finger on her forehead, making her give you an annoyed look.

“Don’t go putting more ideas in my head. It’s already difficult to stay calm as it is.”

“Fine. We’ll see you Sunday then.” She says, turning away from you in mock offence.

You part ways at the bus stop, where everyone heads to their own homes.

You decide you’ll tell everyone about Emily’s mother and her AMA. There’s no point in only telling one of them.

Of course, part of it is that Emily and Megan got you in the mood a couple of hours earlier, but you have to admit your sex drive has been just a little bit over what you’d consider healthy since this all started.

You could argue that’s a good thing though, having to please 5 different women. It’s a dream come true. Yet at moments like this, when you’re alone at home and trying to distract yourself with a book, things get really difficult. Doesn’t help the book is as boring as watching paint dry and that you’ve been at it for less than an hour and you’re already ¼ of the book in.

A buzz of your phone interrupts your reading, and you take it see it’s a message from Mia.

Mia: Good evening. How did he date go?

You: It was nice. We had fun.

Mia: I’m glad.

You: Although I feel like I might have robbed the girls from something.

Mia: What do you mean?

You: I don’t feel like I can explain it well in text.

Mia: Are you home right now?

You: Yeah.

Mia: Can I come?

You: I’d be very happy if you did.

Just seconds after your message is sent, you hear the sound of keys unlocking your door and turn to see your English teacher coming in.

“Sorry I took so long. The traffic was terrible.” She jokes with a grin.

You laugh. “Please tell me you weren’t waiting outside.” You leave your book at your side and stand up from your mattress.

“No, I was on my way here walking as we talked.” She chuckles and puts the key away in her purse.

“I’m glad to see you like your present.” You smile, walking up to give Mia a deep kiss on the lips. She makes sure to return it in full, wrapping her arms around you before answering.

“I love it.” She grins. “It means a lot to me that you trust me with it. Although…”

“Although…?” You echo.

Mia gives you a guilty grimace. “I admit I came here without telling you kind of hoping to find you with someone.”

You raise your eyebrows at that. “Why’s that? I mean, it could’ve happened, but why come here hoping to find me busy?”

“I don’t know.” Mia shakes her head, frustrated at her own confusion. “I have yet to see you with any of the other girls. I guess… I want to know how I’ll feel about it. How I’ll react.”

You lead her by the hand and you both sit on the mattress.

“Are you… jealous?” You ask hesitantly, and feel some relief when Mia shakes her head.

“No, I’m not. At least, not when I think about it. And I’ve thought about it a lot.” She smiles wryly. “I understand in my head that what we have is not normal, but my heart doesn’t mind. I don’t care that there are 4 other women and don’t care if eventually there are 5 more so long as I’m one of them.”

She leans her head on your shoulders and lets out a drawn-out sigh. “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to come here and dump more of my worries on you. It’s seems like that’s all I’ve done since we started dating.”

“I don’t mind. I’ve gotten to know a lot more of you this way.” You tell her, smiling and rubbing her back. “Before this, you were my capable, composed and reliable English teacher. Now, you’re Mia. My beautiful girlfriend with worries of her own, always thinking of the future. I’ve seen sides of you I never thought I would, and I’m so happy I have.”

Hearing her chuckle again fills your chest with relief and warmth.

“You’re one smooth-talker, you know that?” She tells you, kissing your cheek.

“So I’m told. And you love it.” You grin mischievously.

“I do.” She mirrors that grin.

“What’s your plan now? You expected to find me with company, yet you found me alone and bored.”

“Well, I came here by bus so as to not let my car outside. What do you think my plan is?” She asks, tracing her finger slowly from your cheek down to your stomach.

“You are one naughty teacher.” Your grin widens.

“I’m your naughty teacher.” She whispers and captures your lips in an intense kiss. She presses her chest against yours and pushes you down on the bed, slipping her tongue inside your mouth in the process.

You both moan into the kiss, embracing your lover tightly. Mia’s orbs feel marvelous against you, as always.

“Now,” Mia gasps, flashing you a smile full of desire. “What does my sweet student want from his naughty teacher?”