Continue fucking. Then some pillow talk.

“Holy… Holy shit, David! Just… oh my fucking God!” The always well-spoken Sophia swears, looking back at you as you keep going.

“I didn’t think you had such a dirty mouth.” You tell her with a teasing grin.

“Well, apparently I do when- oh! Oh fuck! …when you make me come three times in a row!”

You lean in, hovering over her as you keep thrusting slowly. “I’ll take the compliment then.” You kiss her naked shoulder. “We’re not done yet. Are you up for more?”

“Fuck yes. I meant what I said, David. Make me yours.” She purrs seductively.

You stick out your tongue and Sophia reciprocates. You share a sloppy kiss that more of you licking each other’s tongues than anything else.

You pull out and roll her over again. You climb on the bed and on top of her. You spread her legs wide, caressing her inner thighs. You lean forward between them and kiss them. You enjoy seeing your lover’s reactions. She trembles in delight at your touch, her breathing intensifies. You decide to taste her pussy, sopping in juices from her several orgasms. You run your tongue along her slit, making Sophia yelp.

“W-What are you doing? You haven’t even come, right? Why are youuuoooh!”

She moans when your tongue finds its way inside her. You lap her thoroughly for a while before you go back up and give Sophia a taste of her own pussy through a wet kiss. Again, her body relaxes and your partner wraps her arms around your neck.

You line up your dick with her slit and effortlessly penetrate her again. She’s tight, but she’s still so wet it’s not a problem.

“Fuuuck…! Ah! Ah! Ah! Oh! Yeah! Yeah!” Sophia wraps her legs tightly around your waist. “If I’d know… this is was waited for me… I wouldn’t have hesitated so much…!”

You slide your arms under your lover and hold her. Then, you roll over again, taking her with you. With positions now reversed, you start thrusting from below. You take one of Sophia’s nipples into your mouth, flicking your tongue around it. She’s glad to reposition herself to make it more comfortable for you.

“Shit…! I’m coming again! Fuck!” Sophia presses her lips and shuts her eyes as she waits for her fourth orgasm. Now you can feel yourself getting closer as well. Of course, you want to come. You love the ability to pleasure a woman until she’s completely satisfied but taking so long to come is also annoying. You’ll chalk that up to the condom though.

You manage to come along with Sophia. Once more, her body trembles in your arms. You shoot your load inside the rubber, but you can’t help but miss the feeling of doing it inside a woman.

Your own body relaxes as you share the afterglow of sex with Sophia.

It was sudden, but also amazing. You didn’t wake up today thinking you’d bring this girl back and start a relationship with her, but hey, you’re not complaining.

“God… I love you. I love you so much, David…” Sophia says tiredly, resting her limp body on top of yours.

Your heart skips a beat. You remember you have the Sex is Love trait. By how much did your love score with her improve? No, more than that, hearing those words is still a critical hit on you. You truly are weak against women.

Sophia rolls from over you and pants heavily. You watch her chest rise and fall with every breath for a few moments before you build up the motivation to finally get out of bed and go to the bathroom to throw the condom in the trash and clean up your dick.

When you go back to your room, you pick up your phone and quickly check the AMA. To Sophia, this shouldn’t look odd. You could just be checking your messages. Though she doesn’t seem to be focused on you at all right now.

-Johnson, Sophia-

Affection Score: 90. (+15)

Love Score: 58 (+38)

Lust Score: 80. (+7)

Holy crap! That’s a huge fucking jump! Though you did make her come four times.

…

No, it’s no use speculating. You’ll just have to talk to Sophia. You sit down at the edge of the bed, looking over your exhausted lover. You move her bangs out of her face and can’t help but look at her lovingly.

“How are you doing?” You ask softly.

“Heavenly.” She answers with a bright smile. “I have to apologize again. I really was unfair when I wrote you into my stories. You’re WAY better than the fictional you.” She giggles.

“Glad to know you enjoyed it. I’m not used to doing it like that. I was afraid I was being too… I don’t know…”

“Don’t worry. You were perfect.” Sophia sits up and hugs you from behind. Of course, her huge tits press against you. “Some fantasies really can come true. Thank you.” She kisses your cheek. “So… we really are boyfriend and girlfriend then?”

“Up to you. Do you want to be my girlfriend?” You turn your head to her.

“You mean one of them?” She chuckles. “I do. I said something in the heat of the moment. I said that I loved you. I don’t want to take back those words, even if I don’t really know what love is.”

You turn your body and gently kiss your new girlfriend. Very technically speaking, she’s the fourth, since you and Mia are still in a sort of trial period, and nothing is happening with Jessica yet. You have everyone’s approval to go out with her, though it was a little hasty since the situation came out of nowhere.

You really need to have a talk with everyone again, Sophia included. Speaking of… Should you tell her about Emma and Mia? Even disregarding her love and lust scores, Sophia’s affection score is at 90. You know you can trust her.

“Hey, Sophia. I have to talk to you about something.”

Your girlfriend raises an eyebrow. You kind of get it though. Having to reveal something right after sex is kind of foreboding.

“I was telling the truth when I said I was officially dating three girls, with two developing relationships. Well, there are two people there that I can’t exactly be open about with anyone else other than those close to me. I don’t plan on keeping secrets from you, so I’ll tell you.”

Her eyes widen and she’s taken aback by your words. “Wait a moment! If it’s so important, why would you trust me with it? We- We only just started dating!”

“So you’re saying you’ll reveal my secret if I tell you?”

“Of course not! I would never! I know I have a good network of information, but I don’t use it to spread secrets!” She immediately and forcefully answers.

“Then I can trust you, just like I though.” You smile at her.

“There is such a thing as too trusting, you know? Still. It makes me happy.” She giggles. “Fine, I promise I won’t tell a soul. What’s the big secret?”

You tell her how the first person you got close to in this town was Emma, and how she’s one of your official girlfriends. She’s speechless for a few moment, but before you can tell her about Mia…

“Oh my God! You’re dating Ms. Owens too!” She deducts, covering her mouth with her hand.

“How… How did you know!?” You ask, dumbfounded.

“The rumor that Ms. Owens is dating someone is well known. They say she admitted it in one of your classes. So if you’re already secretly dating a teacher, then the other secret person is her!

“…” She’s good. Hopefully no one at Hayes is as good as her, or you’re fucked. “I can’t believe you got it just from that bit of information.”

“I like Ms. Owens, so I was happy when I heard she was dating someone. I pressed her for details, but all I got from her was that the guy was younger than her.”

Oh. Is that dangerous? You don’t think so. With how hot Mia is, it wouldn’t be strange for her to be dating a younger guy.

“Oh my God. You’re dating two teachers! If the school finds out, you’re ALL gone!” Sophia eyes you with a worried look. “I’ll do my best to try and dispel any rumors about you guys. After all, I can’t lose two of my favorite teachers and my boyfriend at the same time. Of course, losing any of you would be terrible, but all at once would break me.” She hugs you tightly, maybe even a bit fearful of letting you go.

“Thank you. I’d really appreciate it if you did that for us. I promise I’ll make it up to you.”

“Keep treating me like you did today and you’ll owe me nothing.” She laughs.

“You’re amazing. Have I told you that yet?”

“No, but I’ll gladly take it.” She throws herself back on the bed. You thought this before, but her naked figure is a sight to behold. It makes you want to jump right in again. But first, you need to tell her about the meeting.

“Hey, so we, as in my girlfriends and I, set up a few simple rules for ourselves to help our little arrangement work. We don’t keep secrets; we’re open with each other about the things that bother us and try to get along together. I don’t want to keep several different relationships separate. I want to be able to, well, be with all of you at once.”

Sophia smiles. “I see. No wonder you all seem so close then. And hey, you read my notebook. I want you to be with all of us at once.” She blushes as she admits.

“So I’d like us to get together one of these days. Kind of like an official introduction, if you will.”

She nods. “Yes. I think we should. I admit, though, I feel like an outsider.” She smiles wryly.

“They’re all great. I promise.” You smile. You crawl on top of Sophia, who looks excited. You kiss and lick her neck, eliciting your lover to moan softly. “By the way. About birth control…”

“Yeah. I’m getting pills as soon as I can.” She assures you.

You play with each other for a while longer. Or it’d be best to say that Sophia lets herself be commanded to do as you please.

She gives you her first blowjob. She definitely knows what to do to make it good, but since she’s never done it before, it’s still sloppy. However, it’s the fact that she’s giving you her first that makes it feel amazing. You took her first kiss, her virginity and her first blowjob.

You spend one more hour in bed, helping Sophia familiarize herself with the pleasures of sex.

You walk her to the bus stop, where you end up making out passionately. So much so that she even misses the first bus that passes by.