Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 76 by Fantasy Fantasy

What do you do next?

Trying something new.

It’s no surprise that right after eating, things get even more intimate. You don’t even move to the bedroom, going at it right there on the couch. Emma sits on top of you, straddling your lap as she removes her top and her bra, giving you full access to those tits you’ve missed for two long weeks. When your tongue makes contact with her hardened nipple, she lets out a sudden loud moan. “Yes love! I love it when you suck my tits!” With her hands on the backrest of the couch, she thrusts her chest forward for you to play with.

With your pants down, yet not completely off, your erection grinds against Emma’s wet pussy, eliciting even more passionate moans from her. Then, Emma says something that stuns you for a moment.

“Love… would you stick your finger up my butt?” Both of you stop moving. “We said we’d start trying anal, right? I’ve been reading up and they say you should start small. I’ve already tried a bit, and it… wasn’t bad.” She purses her lips, embarrassed. “Don’t worry, I cleaned up.”

You did say you were willing to try. You honestly don’t know how to feel about it, but you’re very willing to try for Emma’s sake, since she seems to be really into the idea.

“Sure.” That single word makes her face light up in excitement, and before you can even ask if you should use lube she runs to the bathroom and brings back a bottle. She gives it to you, crawls on top of the couch on all fours and points her round ass towards you, telling you to put some on your finger, and to make sure to only use your middle one for now.

You spread some lube on your finger and get closer to Emma’s butt, giving it a few gentle squeezes. “You ready, Angel?”

She sighs once, then spreads her cheeks with her hands. “Ready. Do it slowly please.”

That was always the plan. You start probing the entrance of her butthole, running small circles on it. Emma’s body shivers, but she breathes slowly to relax. Then, with a final warning, you start putting your finger inside. It feels odd, but it doesn’t have as many troubles going in as you thought. Emma moans softly as you penetrate her asshole with your finger, stopping every time she gets too tight. After a minute or so, you’re all the way to the base.

“How is it? Does it hurt?” You ask, a bit nervous. Though if it did Emma would’ve told you already.

“No, it doesn’t. It even feel nice.” She assures you. “Try moving it a little.”

You do as told and slowly start massaging her insides, causing your lover to moan in pleasure.

“Aah! Ah! Oh my God…! That feels… Mmh…! Really good!” Emma approves. Her asshole tightens suddenly a few times, but she starts breathing normally again and relaxes. You start to slowly slide your finger in and out of her. It seems she likes it too, because she’s holding onto the couch’s armrest for dear life.

“Keep going love! Just like that!” She grunts. Seeing how much she’s enjoying it makes you want to go faster and maybe even try it with your dick, but you know that’s not how this works. She feels good now, so unless she says so, you’ll keep doing what you’re doing, and after a few minutes of alternating between massages and sliding, Emma’s body tenses and her asshole tightens strongly around your finger, making you stop you movements. She presses her lips to muffle her scream of bliss as she comes from her butt. When you feel her muscles relaxing, you pull your finger out.

“How was it?” You asks, caressing her ass and giving her butt cheek a little kiss

“It was fucking amazing…!” She answers, breathing hard and looking back at you with eyes of adoration. “It was so weird, but so, so good! Way better than when I tried it for myself, too. You seriously have magic fingers.”

Watching your girlfriend basking in the afterglow of her orgasm, her gorgeous figure, her nice, plump butt… you can’t hold it for much more. You lean over her and probe her wet slit with the head of your cock, making her look back at you.

“Think you can go again now?” You tempt her.

She looks at you with sultry eyes, grins and bites her lip. “I don’t know, but I want to try.”

With Emma on her stomach, head resting on the armrest, and you leaning behind her, you easily penetrate her still tight pussy. Emma gasps at the sensation, being a bit more sensitive thanks to her pretty recent orgasm, but doesn’t tell you to stop. Grabbing hold of her ass cheeks, you start thrusting, your pace quickening as you notice your partner’s reaction, her moans becoming high-pitched, short and quick. Her nails dig into the couch. You feel her pussy coiling around your dick and gripping it tightly.

“Fuck!Fuck!Fuck!!” Emma yells as her body trembles, reaching her second orgasm in about two minutes. You slow down to almost a halt, but after probably ten second Emma starts moving her hips. “Keep going David! Keep going!” She urges you, so you do. The sound of flesh on flesh echoes in the apartment as you keep pounding, slowly getting closer to your own climax. Yet before than can happen, your lover manages to reach her third orgasm in less than 5 minutes with a loud groan and a trembling knees. Her body goes limp on the couch, her breathing is heavy and nothing but incoherent mumbling comes out of her mouth.

You feel proud that you managed to take you girlfriend to multiple orgasms, yet you’re also conflicted because you didn’t get to reach your own. You’re incredibly horny, but it doesn’t look like Emma is up for anything right now. You COULD just stroke yourself, but that’d be a waste. You decide to simply sit there and breathe to calm yourself down.

After a few minutes, Emma finally comes back to her senses and sits up, looks you in the eyes and throws herself at you, devouring you mouth with a passionate, wet kiss. You hold her in your arms and press her against you.

“Holy shit, love! I blanked out there for a second!” The grin on Emma’s face says it all.

“It seems I’m getting better.” You want to feel smug about it, but you’re sure it was just a fluke. Probably due to Emma’s first real anal experience.

“David, that wasn’t just ‘getting better’.” Emma says, looking into your eyes. “You’ve made me come twice in an hour and that’s the farthest we’ve gotten. Unless you count us going at it all day long. This, this was three in less than 10 minutes.” She then glances at your still hard cock and gasps, covering her mouth. “Oh my God! You didn’t come!”

“Aha! The tables have turned! Now you’re the one getting off too quickly!” You joke, giving her a goofy smirk and making her playfully push your shoulder as she laughs. Good. You didn’t want her feeling bad for this.

“Still, I won’t leave you like that.” She licks her lips and lowers herself on your crotch, laying on the couch on her stomach as she gives you head. Doing it expertly as always and with your levels of arousal, it doesn’t take long for you to come.

For the rest of the night, you re-watch episode after episode of a comedy show you’ve both watched before and thoroughly enjoy.

The next day…

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)