One Good Turn Deserves Another

Disengaging from the twins, Ashley stepped back to admire her handiwork. The athletic football player’s muscles tensed and bulged as he gripped onto the underside of his sister’s smooth, sleek thigh, her arms around his broad, toned shoulders, foreheads resting against each other, supporting each other’s weight as his cock pistoned into the wet box between her legs. As a cheerleader, Madison had exceptional balance, but even she couldn’t remain on one leg for long with her brother’s powerful, animalistic thrusts pushing his member inside her, **** to be balls-deep inside her once more.

It was strange for Ashley to be standing in the living room, watching her ex-boyfriend fuck his own sister with such need. It was stranger still to be proud of the sight. This was her doing. She’d brought them back together, helped them see past all the bullshit, back to their love together. And though she knew it was wrong, brother and sister fornicating went beyond the rule of law and nature, but she also had to admit, they looked together, the hulking form of Brandon holding onto Madison’s smaller frame as he fucked her, his muscles throbbing as he thrust forward, Madison’s breasts bouncing between their bodies, the very definition of ‘slim and stacked’, their skin glistening with sweat that flew off with every movement. As she watched them, Ashley felt a prang of jealousy, noting to herself that she never remembered Brandon fucking her with such manifest desire.

Good as they looked together though, it was clear what they were feeling was ten thousand times better, even to Ashley who was only looking on. The glazed look in Madison’s eye, her open, panting mouth and the fact that with every passing minute, every successive push of Brandon’s cock inside her, her body slid closer to him, melting into him, made it clear that Madison was losing herself to the pleasure of her brother’s dick. Brandon’s breathing was labored too, though the fucking of his sister hadn’t let up, so he obviously wasn’t tired, but the groans from his mouth when he found himself deep inside his sister made it quite obvious that Madison’s tight, wet puss was having the same effect on him as his cock was having on her. And for the twins, being reconnected only heightened the experience.

What was also apparent to the petite blonde was that they didn’t need her anymore. Her work was done. She could stay and watch and get herself off at the sight, but it would only make her feel down since she didn’t have a cock to give her pleasure, and the closest she’d come today was that creep Mr. Ward who almost put his dick in her ass. Not wanting to disturb the siblings, she snuck quietly from the room, heading to the hallway, considering finding Trent for a repeat of yesterday. Or perhaps, if she could wait, she could take Kurt for another ride.

“Wait.”

She was pulled back by a small, soft hand on her arm, and looked back to see Madison. She wasn’t sure what was more surprising; that the brother and sister had even noticed the lack of her presence, that they’d stopped fucking long enough for Madison to grab her, or that the naked, sweaty brunette pulled her into a tight hug, and whispered, “Stay. Join us.”

Ashley chuckled breathlessly, feeling Madison’s naked flesh burning against her body, her sweat soaking into her clothes. “You don’t need me. And I didn’t do it for me. You want each other.”

“I know, and that’s why I owe you. We owe you.” Madison pulled back from the hug and looked into Ashley’s brilliant blue eyes, close enough to kiss. “I was never opposed to the proposition of fucking other people, just that I had to choose between Brandon and someone else. I don’t mind so long as it’s Brandon plus, and that he’s cool with whoever I’m fucking.”

“That might be a problem, fucking the ex-girlfriend that cheated on him.” Ashley looked over Madison’s shoulder at the naked football player, specifically his hard cock standing erect between his legs, jutting out and colored an angry kind of purplish red, a drop of precum forming at his tip. It was enough to make the blonde teen’s mouth water. So, it was a little conviction that she said, “I don’t want anything in return.”

“Please, you think he’d pass up this chance to make his dream come true.” Madison grabbed hold of Ashley’s legs, reaching beneath her dress, and pulled her blonde teammate’s body closer to hers. Pivoting to the side, giving Brandon a perfect view of their figures slotted together, Madison glanced sideways at her brother with a smirk. “Remember all the times he’d drive us home from practice and he’d stare at our sweaty bodies, and we’d laugh about how much of a perv he was later.”

“No, I wasn’t-” Brandon began to deny it, but seeing their faces, he knew there was no point. They’d already figured it out. “You…uh…you saw that, huh?”

“Saw you? It was hard to miss,” Madison teased him, her breath brushing against Ashley’s mouth. “The way your eyes would linger, and you’d lick your lips.”

“You did always fuck me so good on those nights you brought us home from practice,” Ashley confessed, her own body getting hot from the memories and the anticipation of what might come. “I guess I always thought you were just getting off on the idea of me…” she gave Madison a quick kiss on the lips. “…and…” A second kiss followed, this one a little longer, a lot wetter. “…another…” And another kiss, this time with tongue, slowly so Brandon could see. “…girl…” For their final kiss, they grabbed and pulled at each other, a ****, needy make out; Ashley took a handful of Madison’s taut ass in each hand, while the brunette tugged at her small tits through her summer dress.

Breaking the kiss after a long minute, Ashley looked at Brandon, smiling when she saw him idly stroking his cock. “But you were probably thinking about fucking her, weren’t you?”

“I was…wasn’t…I…” his mind struggled to form the words through the haze of lust, as well as the distraction of Ashley pulling on his sister’s firm asscheeks. “I was imagining both. Me and her, you and her.”

“Sounds like I get very lucky in this scenario,” Madison said, as she reached up and pulled at the straps of Ashley’s dress. “Those nights after you brought us home were ones I looked forward to as well. I could hear you through the walls, and I’d touch myself too, imagining it was me and you…” she looked pointedly at her brother, then turned back to Ashley, and nibbled on her earlobe. “…me and her.”

“I told Ash to keep it down when you were in the house and she always promised to be quiet,” Brandon noted, remembering how Ashley would crawl on top of him, freed from her cheerleading outfit, and ride him, hard, the bed creaking along with the moans, the headboard beating against the wall, with new added revelation that Madison was on the other side of that wall, fingering herself in sync with their fucking.

“Oh, yeah, well, you were just so wild.” Ashley grinned sheepishly. “I just couldn’t help myself. When you fucked me like that, I couldn’t hold back.”

Brandon wasn’t smart but he wasn’t that dumb either. “Wait, were you being loud on purpose, so that she could hear?”

Biting her lip guiltily, while Madison giggled beside her, Ashley fessed up. “It was just a little pact we made when we saw you checking us out. To let her hear just how turned on we’d got you.” Her eyes turned on Madison then. “I had no idea you were getting off on it too, though.”

“Well, it’s not like I was getting dicked down on the regular,” Madison defended herself. “But if I knew this is how you both felt, maybe I would have just joined you.”

“So, all that talk of getting out of your uniforms and showering…” Brandon said, eyes widening with realization. “…that was all just to tease me?”

“It wasn’t just to tease you. We did get awfully hot and sweaty in those uniforms during practice.” She trailed a finger along Ashley’s bare arm and added, “say, Ash, that dress looks like it’s got you all hot and sweaty as well.”

“Oh sure, it’s the dress,” Ashley mocked playfully, while Madison pulled a little more insistently at the straps. Allowing the brunette to slide the dress over her shoulders, she felt the front become loose around her tits, the gentle swell of her chest keeping it from falling completely. “Better take it off then.”

“Let me help,” Madison offered, though she had already been doing just that. Stepping behind Ashley, she let the blonde slip her own arms free of the straps as her hands reached around and tugged the dress down, her small, perky boobs jiggling as they were freed. “It’s only fair after you helped undress us.”

The thought of protesting her good intentions crossed Ashley’s mind again, but she decided to let it go. It didn’t really matter anymore, not now that it was abundantly clear that Brandon and Madison wanted her to join them. Watching Brandon stroke himself as he took in the naked form of his ex-girlfriend being bared before him, she felt Madison’s hands glide down over her body, and pull her skirt up. The dress bunched around her waist, her shaven pussy exposed completely for the brother and sister to see.

“No panties?!” Madison tsked. “You really are a slut.”

“I…I…lost them…” Ashley admitted, her cheeks turning a deep red, the memory of Mr. Ward ripping them from her body and tossing them aside having slipped her mind until right that second.

“Yeah, like that makes you any less of a slu-” Madison’s jaw dropped further open, figuring that the only person Ashley had been near today that might have had a chance to make her lose her panties was their least favorite teacher. “You lost your panties with Mr. Ward?”

“What’s this about, Mr. Ward?” Brandon looked between the girls, hoping for an answer from at least one of them.

“Nothing, nothing happened, and I really don’t think it matters right now.” Distracting them, she grabbed her dress and lifted it over her head, leaving her just as naked as the others. “Do you wanna talk about school? Or do you wanna fuck?”

At that, the most inopportune, moment, the three teens heard noises and voices outside the cabin. The closing of car doors brought them all back down to earth, realizing just how public a setting they had chosen for their reconciliation.

“Quick, to the bedroom,” Ashley insisted, waving them down the hall.

“Leave it,” Madison insisted, pulling her brother by the arm when she saw him reach to recover his underwear, dragging him with her as she followed her teammate to the lake side room, seconds before the cabin door opened.