Mind reading

"Tell me what I'm thinking."

You freeze. You haven't tried to do anything like that. So far you've been entirely sticking to the physical. Before you can say anything Ashley speaks up.

"I know you can do something like that, because of the 'side effect'."

"That wasn't the same thing. It was my own body I was feeling. I was just picking up on her pleasure."

"Isn't pleasure a chemical in the brain?" Damn. Nancy had you there.

"This is still totally new. I learned I had it like an hour ago, and almost died once already, except Julie saved me."

Nancy starts, and you realize she had completely overlooked the **** naked girl in the room.

"Ashley you had me so annoyed I haven't even been staring at the sweaty naked girl. That shouldn't even be possible!"

You tune them out (they're perving on Julie, and the puddle under her groin) and slowly work on asking your magic intuition the right question (assuming there is one) to get into reading minds. You sit at your desk and start scribbling diagrams, and the next time you look up is because someone just hit you in the ass with a shoe.

Someone turns out to be Ashley. "Forget the proof. We were trying way too hard, E. What's the number one reason most people push the boundaries of what they're comfortable with in bed? A hot girl or guy they're into. Nancy has never touched a cock and doesn't want to. But she's totally willing to get off on your tongue if she's got her fingers in me. Bingo!"

"Not totally, Eddie. I'm not a slut. But... Something really freaky is clearly going on here, so it's more of a situation where the worst that can happen is the wrong sort of threesome, and the best that can happen is completing my life's work at the age of 19. Keep your dick away from me, but do the fucking math. I'm taking that wager." She laughs.

Putting it that way makes you feel a little silly. But I guess if someone had offered you dick that would cure the pain earlier you'd have done what was needed and just scrubbed your mouth and brain after.
Would that give me the same- No! Bad Brain. Don't go there and end up finding out there's some fucked up reason to bend your gender preference. Even Nancy is avoiding true grossness.

"What are you thinking about?"

"That dicks are gross and I don't want to touch them."

Ashley laughs again. "Aren't you glad that some of us disagree?"

You look at Nancy and she shrugs. "I agree with you, Eddie. Like I said, this is the wrong sort of threesome."

Three and a half excruciatingly awkward minutes later you're all 'in position' with Nancy kneeling over your head and Ashley sitting on your groin. Nancy is really not into it, but Ashley starts hamming it up with over the top sexual movements from bad porn. It's apparently both arousing and hilarious for Nancy, and you feel the result from below.

"Eddie, you really need to figure out that healing thing. I could have you inside me right now, and that would be so much more fun."

You pause. First aid on your head taught you a lot about working with biology. What if you just healed the very outer layer, and pinched this particular valve? Worst that can happen is you waste this energy.

"Woah, Eddie! Nice one. Didn't expect that. Let's put you where you belong and hide you from Nancy's sensitive eyes."

"You're such an ass, Ashley." says Nancy.

"Ain't it a fine one?" replies Ashley as she twists a bit and smacks her ass so Nancy can see. She also sinks down on you, which is amazing in more than one way.

"Gods, Ashley. You're turned on as hell, aren't you?

"Did you notice a bit of moisture as you came through, Eddie? Hah! The only thing that would make this hotter is an audience."

Instantly you 'reach out' and boot your PC while getting your video camera out and plugging it in.

Ashley starts bouncing and grinding a lot harder. "Fuck, yeah! Keep it behind Nancy so she's not exposed as bi or something." She notices that Nancy is still just sitting there awkwardly. "Do you need a fucking engraved invitation, bitch?" She grabs her hands and puts them on her tits exactly where she put yours earlier. Then she leans forward and says "Kiss me, Nan! Fuck me! Try and turn this nympho chick les for you! And you down there with the diamond dick. Where is this sex god stuff from earlier?" That seems to remind her that Julie is still in the room and she vaguely tries to get her to wake up, similar to the shoe that hit you earlier.

So it seems you're not great at this without magic feedback. You've already been been doing your best, but while she's wet and willing and her kinks are fully on, she's just not into you as a person. Without the magic from earlier it's really hard to get past that.