Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 12
by
Angmir
Who's up next?
John (Nicole wants out)
Nicole stared absentmindedly at the piece of paper in her hands for a few seconds, unable to focus with her mind clouded, ass a thick rod of Tom's burning hot meat was positioned between her thighs, scraping along the surface of her labia from time to time. Her cheeks were reddened and flushed, excited and embarrassed in equal measure. Confused how even despite her hatred towards Tom, she could not put up any resistance to his caressing hands that started more and more openly gorge themselves on her firm teen body.
... " J.. John" - she finally was able to read the name on card, and her abashed gaze turned towards her childhood friend siting on the couch in front of them.
But she could not maintain the eye contact for more than a second, dead embarrassed of her nakedness. Somehow being toyed by the biggest asshole in the whole school wasn't half as bad as John's gaze on her flushed body.
She tried to formulate some sort of cohesive thought, but a thick prodding stick under her was making it very hard for her. It was kind of infuriating that she was the only one in the room that was exposed like this. Well her and Tom - waist down. She needed to get out of this mess as soon as possible, even if something deep inside was enjoying the warmth pulsating between her legs.
" Oh get it together girl - I know you are enjoying yourself out there, but we also want to play a little. Give us something" - Sarah was making fun of her, enjoying teasing the least experienced girl in the room.
" ughhh, shut up bitch" - Nicole snapped back at her.
" John - I want you to find some blanket and cover ... " - she tried speaking, but Sarah jumped in before she was able to finish.
"Nope Sweet tits, that's not how this game works. You were suppose to undress - you must stay undressed." - she said.
"Easy for you to say - I am the only one basically naked !" - Nicole shouted puffing her nostrils cutely while slapping away Tom's hand that was stoking her breasts, with her only piece of clothing, her bra pushed aside.
She was right. As much as Miranda was abused today, only her panties were taken off when they implanted the butt plug in her. She was sitting on the sofa across Nicole holding her hands between her tights rubbing them together not paying attention to discussion, shooting quick glances from time to time in her direction. Or rather towards what was between Nicole's tights.
"Come on Sarah" - John decided to help her friend as much as he could - "She can cover herself with a blanket for a turn or more, its not a big deal. Its not like she is going to dress up anyway, its just a blanket.
"Maybe, but that's still not a dare really, she has to come up with something better than this".
"Ok then." - Nicole livened up when she saw the possibility to escape. - "Bring me the blanket and let me sit next to you on the couch as before."
"Lame" - Sarah and Tom responded in the same time, Matt did as well following after Sarah.
Nicole was **** to get out of there.
"Ok then - "Get me the blanket and trade places with me" ! She almost yelled.
"What ?" - first time in John's memory Tom and him responded in unison.
"You want me to sit on Tom's lap ? No fucking way !" - John saw that Nicole really wanted to get away, but like hell he will be risking his anal virginity to help her out.
Miranda was looking at it amusedly chuckling a little, but Sarah was really ecstatic about it.
"Yess ! Now we're talking !"
Nicole was ready to scut away across the table to her new seat on the sofa, but unexpectedly Tom's hands pulled her back onto his lap, his half-erect cock dangerously brushing past the entrance of her virgin pussy.
"Not so fast sweetheart. You still didnt finish your last dare. If you are moving from here, you are only doing this with your legs wrapped arround my pole." - he coldly said holding pushing her ear next to his mouth, **** on her neck slightly but firmly.
Nicole body tingled with fear and her body stiffened, but to her surprise she felt a wave of pleasure stirring in her abdomen, something within her enjoying how Tom skillfully manhandled her despite her will.
"Aww too bad, this could have been so much interesting. But Tom is right. I guess you guys can swap places, but Nicole has to stay on Tom's lap. " - Sarah pretended to be disappointed.
"I guess that fine by me". - John was pissed seeing how that jerk always seemed to get the best of any situation, but he was relieved that he was able to avoid the worst at least.
He stood up from the couch and moved to the side to make space for Tom to swap with him.
"Hiiiiii" - Nicole yelped when Tom without any warning stood up from his Armchair, and unceremonialy lifted Nicole with his arms like she weighted nothing, his thick bat still sticking out between her legs despite not being fully erect. He carried her from one side to the other, his hands holding her firmly, possesively, and sat down right in the middle of the couch like he owned this place.
John's teeth gritted once he realised it was again double win for that jock. When the game had started John was sitting on the couch with Miranda and Nicole. He on the right with Nicole between him and Miranda, with Matt on the pouf to his right next to Sarah on her Lounge chair, and Tom on the far side.
Right now it was him that will be sitting on the far side, while his rival sat triumphantly on the sofa, with Nicole in his lap, and Miranda sitting just inches away from him ...
John looked with gut clenching fear as Tom extend his hand arround Miranda's back, pulling her closer to him, resting her on his broad shoulder, and to his terror, she didnt object to it, her eyes timidly looking downwards, but giving no resistance. His other hand was still holding Nicole arround her petite belly, the tip of his fingers playing with the nipple of her left brest. Usually feisty Nicole was totally mellow and meek in his hands, as if resigned to her fate.
"Well Johny - dont just stand there. Give Nicole the blanket she asked for, we are trying to get comfortable here" - he taunted you with malicious green across his face.
You stood there dumbfounded like an idiot, looking arround yourself silly, untill Sarah stood up, ran up to you grabbing your hand, and pulled you after her.
"Come with me Darling, there should be something like that in my room". - she said, dragging you after her towards the second floor.
PS. Updated with custom name tags
What will Sarah do with John upstairs ?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The Afterparty
Six friends continue the party with a naughty game.
A group of friends gets closer than ever.
Updated on Jan 16, 2026
by Cheesers123
Created on Aug 28, 2014
by Cloontang1
You can customize this story. Simply enter the following details about the main characters.
- 51,519 Likes
- 19,198,976 Views
- 4,161 Favorites
- 9,744 Bookmarks
- 3,243 Chapters
- 106 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments