Take them both

You reach down and grab the long eared girl by her green hair with one of your massive hands, while you drop the club to grab the crying priestess. She flinches and tries to crawl away, but you simply grab her by her long blonde hair and begin dragging the two out of town. You never saw any of the villagers, but you figure they must have seen their rescuers defeat, and should be properly scared off from attempting this again. The priestess wriggles and struggles, as she begs and pleads to you and her gods for mercy of any kind, while the green haired girl remained limp. Their clothes start to rip and tear on the rocky ground as you drag them up the mountain into you cave.

One you get into your lair you drop the **** woman in a corner, figuring you will have time to deal with her after you set up the priestess. You roughly drop the girl, and look over the first of your prizes. After dragging her up the mountain, her formerly white robes were now brown with mud and in complete tatters. Her skin, once pale and innocent against her blonde hair, are also covered in mud and scrapes from the rough trip. She seems exhausted from her struggles and cries, and just limply lies in your grasp.

You take a long piece of metal, and with your immense strength bend it around the girls throat, forming a collar she would never be strong enough to remove on her own. You strip the tattered robes from her, leaving her only in her new metal collar as she weakly tries to cover herself.

Now is the time to set her proper training. You could simply rule by fear, but you may get more loyalty if you mix fear and reward in equal measure.