Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 84 by DarkSoulDrinker DarkSoulDrinker

Who to follow next?

Lisa

Lisa dashed past the group of teens drinking in the kitchen. She flashed them a smile but felt like a fraud. She just couldn't get Zack out of her head. After their initially breakup, she'd been upset, but mostly mad at Zack for not paying attention to her. Now she regretted the breakup. Zack was just a guy and guys liked looking at girls. He'd never cheated on her, but she'd been sure he wasn't interested in her, despite the two of them fucking pretty often.

Lisa burst into her room and flung herself onto her cot. Zack's dick filled her mind. She'd only ever been with Zack, but she knew his cock was special. Every time they'd fucked she'd felt amazing. She knew from what she'd heard other girls talking about that a lot of their boyfriends barely got them off, if at all, unless they used their tongues. But Zack always got her off. Multiple times actually. Lisa slipped her hand under her bikini. She was still wet. Oh Zack. If only you'd come in here and fuck me like you used to. The door started to open and Lisa caught her breath. Was her wish about to come true? Madison stepped into the room. She noted Lisa's hand and both girls blushed.

"S-sorry," Madison stammered out. "I was coming back to lay down. I didn't realize you were...busy."

She started to turn around but Lisa hopped up. "No stay, Mads. I-I'll go to the bathroom." Lisa pushed past her friend, too embarrassed to say anything else. She quickly darted to the bathroom and locked the door. Looking in the mirror, Lisa sighed. What's wrong with me? Kurt seemed into me. He seemed nice enough. I probably messed it up with him too though. She heard giggling and feet pounding down the hallway. Everyone is having a good time. Why can't I? She slipped her hand back down to her pussy but didn't feel any excitement. She needed the real thing. Lisa splashed some water on her face and looked into the mirror for a bit before finally sighing and stepping back into the hallway.

Music was still playing in the living room, but Lisa couldn't hear anyone chatting out in the kitchen. She started to walk back to her room, intending to go to bed, when she passed Zack and Chloe's room and heard moaning. She paused. The door was partially cracked. Whoever had closed it must not have realized it hadn't latched and it had slowly pushed back open. Another moan came from the room. Lisa couldn't help herself, she pushed the door open a little further and peeked in.

Zack and Meagan were sitting on the bed kissing while Chloe appeared to be licking the other girl's pussy. Meagan was stroking Zack's cock and her small hand made it look even larger that Lisa remembered. She sighed as she looked at it and felt her nethers tingling again. Oh Zack, why did I push you away? Chloe stood and pushed Meagan onto the bed. Lisa bit her lip and slipped her hand into her bikini bottom as Zack climbed over the petite girl. She closed her eyes and imagined she was lying under him.

Meagan moaned loudly and Lisa shuddered. She opened her eyes and watched Zack's cock disappearing inside the lucky girl. He seemed to be going slow. If it was me, he could fuck me silly. Lisa could hear the teens saying stuff but her mind focused solely Zack. Her ex gave some quick sharp thrusts and Lisa moaned quietly. She covered her mouth, hoping they wouldn't hear her. Fortunately, Meagan was much louder.

"FUCK. FUCK! FUUUUUCCCKKK! I LOVE THIS COCK!"

I love it too. Lisa rubbed herself faster. She felt close to an orgasm, but couldn't quite reach it. She flicked her clit but it still wasn't enough. Lisa started to get frustrated and missed what the others were saying. She had to stop suddenly and pull the crack in the door smaller as Zack started leading Meagan towards the wall. What are they...HOLY FUCK! Lisa watched in disbelief as Zack lifted Meagan and impaled her on his cock. Lisa saw the wall shake as Zack pounded into the girl. She gasped when she saw that further down the hall, Kurt was staring at her.

Kurt had actually been watching Lisa for a couple minutes. He'd been about to head back outside when he first noticed her peeking into Zack and Chloe's room. At first he'd started to get angry again, but as he watched her grow frustrated and fail to cum, his anger dissipated and all he felt was pity. The poor girl was broken. When she noticed him watching her he made a decision.

Lisa gulped and pulled the door fully closed as Kurt walked down the hall towards her. The wall continued to shake and Kurt paused for a second to look at it. He couldn't help but give Zack props for whatever was going on inside. Lisa just stood like a deer in headlights as he looked at her. Her hand was even still unconsciously trying to get her off.

Kurt reached down and pulled her hand out of her bikini and brought it to his mouth. He sucked on her fingers and she shuddered. As he pulled her fingers back out of his mouth, he stepped even closer and whispered into Lisa's ear. "I'm going to fuck you now. You can pretend I'm Zack if you want, but you need a dick and you know it."

Lisa couldn't say anything. Kurt pulled her up against him and kissed her. She melted. In her mind, he was Zack. She knew it was wrong and unfair to Kurt, but he was right. She felt his hands go to her hips and lift her. Lisa stopped thinking and lost herself in her imagination. She wrapped her legs around 'Zack' and kissed him back, letting him carry her back towards her room. Her butt hit the door but a second later it opened. The lights were off but Lisa didn't think she'd have cared if Madison had still been awake. She needed this more than she had been willing to admit. Kurt carried the girl to her cot and dumped her on it. He quickly shed his swim trunks and climbed on top of Lisa.

She immediately positioned his cock at her slit and pushed the bikini fabric out of the way. "Please fuck me, Zack. I've missed you so much." Kurt thrust forward and Lisa came as soon as he was in here. "YESSSSS. Oh Zack, FUCK ME."

Madison had woken as soon as she heard the door open. She couldn't see who'd come in and was about to say something when she heard Lisa's voice. Did she somehow seduce Zack? Madison couldn't believe it. She'd been pretty sure Zack was tied to Chloe, but obviously Lisa had worked a miracle.

"Fuck me, Zack. YES YES YES." Lisa's built up tension was coming out all at once.

With each thrust from his cock, Kurt felt the latino girl shaking in orgasm. He honestly would have been proud of himself if she hadn't kept calling him Zack. He kept thrusting as Lisa went wild beneath him. Having just cum down Heather's throat a little while ago, he knew he could last a while, despite how crazy she was getting.

Madison listened to Lisa's moaning and felt herself getting wet. If this was how well Zack fucked, it was no wonder Lisa was still pining after him. Why did she break up with him in the first place? Madison slid her hand down to her panties and could feel her wetness. She pondered turning on the lights so she could see the couple but decided that might cause them to stop. She knew Brandon wanted another romp with her, and she wasn't against it, she just wasn't sure if she really wanted Brandon or if she was just keyed up. Part of her initial draw to him had come from spying on him and Ashley roleplaying. And now she was spying on Lisa and Zack. She started to touch herself and pictured what being with Zack might be like.

Kurt felt Lisa cum again. He'd lost count of how many times it had happened. Lisa was digging her nails into his back and he was pretty sure it would be obvious what he'd been up to if anyone saw him without a shirt on. She'd finally stopped calling him Zack, but only because now all she could do was moan. Kurt felt his balls tensing up and decided to leave her with a little present. He pulled his dick out and quickly stroked himself off. In the dark, he couldn't see where he was coming, but he spurted several times and was confident he'd just covered Lisa in his cum. She just lay there, half moaning, half sighing.

Kurt shook his head and fished around in the dark till he found his swim trunks. They were still a little damp and he figured with his back all scratched up he didn't want to go out to the hot tub. Shrugging, he walked naked to the door. A moan came from the bed and he paused. Madison must still be awake. Is she getting off to listening to us?

"Oh Zack," Madison softly moaned from her bed.

Fucking hell. Kurt sighed and left the room. He wandered into the living room and shut off the music and lights before flopping down on to his couch/bed and falling asleep.

Who to follow next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)