A night of firsts for Ashley too

Ashley sat up as she watched the boys move into the kitchen. She slid over next to Chloe and put an arm around her. "So how was your first time?"

Chloe leaned dreamily against Ashley. "Amazing. I don't know which I like more. Zack fucking my ass or my pussy."

"So you like it in the ass?" Ashley asked honestly. Brandon's finger earlier had surprised her and she still wasn't sure what to think of anal. "I've...I've never actually done it in the ass."

"Really?" Chloe turned to look at Ashley. She had a hard time believing Ashley was an anal virgin. "You've never done anal at all?"

"Nope." Ashley conceded. "Never thought about it to be honest. I've always been able to get Brandon off with my mouth or pussy. Now I'm wondering."

"Ash," Chloe was incredulous, "you let Brandon paint your face with his cum but you haven't let him have your ass?"

Ashley reached up to wipe the cum on Chloe's face. "I'm not the only one he painted." She smiled mischievously for a second and then stuck her cum covered finger into Chloe's mouth.

Chloe was surprised but didn't pull away. She thought back to earlier when she'd done the same to Ashley and began to suck on the finger. Brandon tasted a little different from Zack. Not better or worse, just different. As Ashley pulled her finger out of Chloe's mouth, Chloe got an evil idea. She pounced onto Ashley and quickly had her creampied pussy hovering over the blonde's face. "I tasted Brandon. Why don't you get a taste of Zack?" Chloe wasn't sure what surprised her more. Her own actions or Ashley's tongue on her pussy.

Ashley had no problem licking Chloe. She imagined how the boys would react when they came back into the living room and that spurred her on. She was surprised when she felt Chloe's tongue begin to lick her. And she thinks I'm the slut. Ashley decided to up the ante and slid a finger into Chloe's pussy. The other girl squealed and followed suit.

"Oh wow." Brandon stopped in amazement at the sapphic sight before him. He and Zack had just wandered back in carrying glasses of water.

Chloe looked up from Ashley's pussy but didn't stop fingering her. "Hey boys. We decided to start with out you. But Zack, I need your cock in me NOW!" Zack quickly set his water down a moved behind Chloe. He could see Ashley lapping away at her cunt and decided he'd take care of her other hole. Chloe closed her eyes and moaned loudly as Zack pushed his cock into her ass. The combination of a dick in her ass and a tongue on her pussy was magical.

She opened her eyes to find Brandon in front of her staring down. His cock was hard and Chloe got another evil idea. She spread Ashley's legs wide and began licking from her pussy down to her tight rosebud, pausing to egg on Brandon. "Hey Brandon...I think....you should...fuck Ashley...in her ass." A muffled sound came from Ashley, but Chloe ground her pussy down, drowning out whatever she said.

Brandon stared at his girlfriends back hole. Chloe bent down to suck on Ashley's clit, but she also made sure to pull her ass cheeks wide, enticing Brandon. While Brandon stared, Chloe would occasionally stop nibbling on Ashley's clit and give her anus a quick lick. Finally, lust won out and Brandon positioned himself to take Ashley's anal virginity.

"Go slowly," Chloe warned as she stopped to watch the deflowering. Brandon pushed slowly into Ashley's ass and Chloe sighed as she felt the other girl cry "Oh fuck" into her pussy.

Brandon paused, savoring the feel of Ashley's tight ass. Her walls were practically crushing his cock and he was honestly concerned he wouldn't be able to last long with how tight she was. He pulled out slowly, paused, and then slowly pushed back in a second time, while Chloe went back to sucking on Ashley's clit. Ashley's mind was on fire. Chloe's tongue was doing a number on her and Brandon's cock made her feel incredibly full. As he began to speed up his thrusts, she knew she was done and screamed into Chloe's cunt. Brandon felt her ass clench in orgasm and lost himself. He came hard, giving Ashley her first anal creampie.

Satisfied that Ashley's first anal experience was a success, Chloe began to focus on her own needs. Ashley had stopped licking her, but Zack was still pounding away at her ass. She started thrusting back onto his cock, dragging her pussy across Ashley in the process. Ashley's nose pocked into her clit right as Zach was balls deep in her and that was it. She came and knew that she must be covering Ashley with her squirt. Zack grunted a few seconds later and she could feel his seed filling her up. Once her orgasm subsided, she rolled off Ashley, pulling Zack with her.

Ashley lay there panting. Her face was covering Brandon's cum from earlier and now Chloe's too. She locked eyes with Brandon, who still had his dick buried in her ass. "We are doing that again." She slowly sat up and hugged her boyfriend. "But now I need a shower and bed." Brandon happily helped her stand and lead her off to a bathroom.

Chloe and Zack watched them leave while cuddling on the floor. Zack was the first to speak. "I never would have imagined this trip would go like this."

"I know what you mean," Chloe snuggled closer. "It's almost magical. Like anything can happen. But Ashley has the right idea. Shower and then bed. Magic can wait till tomorrow."