Nicole gives you permission, but you decline

When Miranda sits next to Sarah, the two instantly embrace arms and lips. As they do so, Nicole turns to you and looks you in the eyes. "Hey, if you want Miranda, you should go for her."

"But I want you."

"Really?"

"Yeah."

"I thought you liked Miranda?"

"I did, but to be honest I never saw you in that way before, but now I think do. You're a beautiful woman Nicole, and I want you."

Nicole pulls you closer and the two of you kiss passionately. You grab her ass, and indulge in your new desire. No one else matters in the world. Not Matt, not Sarah, not Tom, and not even Miranda. After a few kisses, you ask her "Do you want anal?"

"Yeah. I want to try it with you."

"You sure?"

Nicole nods. "I trust you."

"Hey Sarah." You call out.

She pauses from kissing your former crush for a second. "Yo?"

"You got that lube."

"Here stud." Sarah throws you the bottle and you catch it. "Go easy on her."

"Oh I will." You look to your best friend, who's stroking his cock to the show Miranda and Sarah are giving him. "Sure you can handle those two girls for me."

"I'll do my best."

"Yeah come over here stud." Sarah says. Matt steps over, allowing Sarah to grip his erection. Meanwhile, you take Nicole to the guest bedroom. Now it was just you, her, and a bottle of anal lube.