Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 163 by JoeSte91 JoeSte91

Ashley lied! How do the others respond?

Ashley's Forfeit

It took a moment for the words ‘I lied’ to sink into Gavin’s brain. Partially because the words had come from the now naked blonde cheerleader in front of him by the name of Ashley Woodsen, his eyes staring at her shaved little pussy, glistening wet with her desire. It didn’t help that she was flanked on either side by two equally naked women in Hannah Woodsen and Chloe McRose, the soft, warm flesh of their tits squashed against his thighs. All three of the girls were kneeling before him, his stiff, throbbing cock jutting out from his body in front of their beautiful faces.

‘I lied’ rang again in his head and the consequences of that statement crashed upon Gavin like a tsunami. She had lied about never wanting to suck his cock…which meant that she did want to suck his cock. Ashley Woodsen, a cheerleader, one the most desired and beautiful girls in the whole school, a girl capable of taking her pick of men who were lining up to be with her, wanted to suck his cock. Fuck, he thought. This was like an excellent wet dream. Then he reminded himself that just because she wanted to didn’t mean that she was going to. Though she was staring at him with those lustful blue eyes and biting her lip…

“You sneaky bitch,” Hannah said playfully to her younger sister. “I can’t believe you lied!”

“That disqualifies her, right?” Chloe asked from the other side, her hand still casually playing with Gavin’s ballsack as she spoke. “So, you win!”

“That’s right! Aha, I win anyway!” Hannah pumped her fists victoriously, but Ashley didn’t seem to mind. She simply watched Gavin with those big eyes of hers, lips excruciatingly close to his cockhead…

“Wait, ah…uh…shouldn’t there be a forfeit?” Gavin interjected, thinking on his feet but only thinking of ways he could get Ashley’s mouth on his cock. She wanted it, he wanted it, they’d both admitted it, it was simply a matter of creating the opportunity.

“Great idea. There should be a penalty for breaking the rules,” Chloe agreed, raking her finger nails along his testicles in encouragement. “But what be a fitting punishment?”

“Oh I think I know what Gavin might suggest,” Hannah teased, wrapping her fingers around his shaft and pointing his cock directly towards her little sister’s mouth. “Maybe that she should have to do the thing she lied about wanting to do?”

“That’s seems fair,” Ashley was quick to respond, her eyes forever fixed on Gavin. “Sound good to you?”

Fortune favours the bold , Gavin thought, remembering Kurt’s advice from yesterday. He looked down at the blonde cheerleader, her mouth slightly open, waiting for his go-a-head and said, “fuck yeah, suck my cock, Ash.”

Without any further discussion Ashley engulfed Gavin’s cockhead in her mouth. He groaned, feeling her expert lips suckling on his tip, coaxing out his pre-cum as her tongue tickled the ridge of his helmet. Eyes still on his, she rolled her head back and forth, working the inch just below his tip in and out of her mouth. The sensation of her hot, wet mouth on his cock along with Heather’s hand gently pumping his shaft while Chloe toyed with his balls had Gavin feeling like a god.

If he thought that was good though, he wasn’t prepared for anything to come. Ashley bobbed her head along Gavin’s cock, softly, slowly drawing his length further and further into her little mouth. She loved the warm, rigid taste of cockflesh in her mouth, salivating all over his dick as she worked it in and out, smearing her saliva over another inch of his cock each time she bobbed her head slightly lower. Inch by Inch by inch by inch by inch Gavin watched as his cock disappeared into Ashley’s mouth, her eyes watching his amazement as she devoured his cock whole. As her mouth slid further down his hard dick, her nose nudged against her sister’s hand, those last two inches kept out of reach.

“Movm mor mamd,” Ashley hummed with the cock in her mouth.

“Didn’t mum and dad ever tell you not to talk with your mouth full,” Hannah joked as she unwrapped her fingers from the base of Gavin’s cock, one by one, just to make her sister wait an extra minute.

Once her fingers were free, she slid her palm south along his cock, the heel of her hand grazing along the root of his shaft, feeling where the smooth warm skin of his dick gave way to the hairy gooseflesh of his ballsack. Her hand continued, fingers bumming against Chloe’s. The redhead jolted, almost pulling her hand away, but Hannah continued, sliding her hand over the younger woman’s, fingertips gliding over the roughness of her knuckles. Chloe’s breath became ragged, simply feeling the college girl’s hand on hers while she cupped her friend’s nutsack. Their hands parted, each taking a ball in hand, their little fingers proding and stroking the other’s.

Above, Ashley sucked and slurped on Gavin’s cock, head bouncing along his shaft, tongue flicking along his underbelly as she shoved her mouth down those last two inches. She felt his cock nudge the back of her throat, and to Gavin’s surprise, without any coughing or spluttering, Ashley angled her face, titling her head back and took the last inch, his cockhead sliding into her gullet proper. And she held him there.

“Oh Shit,” Gavin swore, seeing Ashley’s lips at the base of his cock and silently glad that he had fucked Chloe at the waterfall earlier. If he hadn’t cum today, the sight and sensation of Ashley’s hot wet mouth sheathed around his cock while Hannah AND Chloe played with his balls would have been enough to send him over the edge. Thankfully, he was able to hold off just a little longer, though just barely.

“That ‘no gag reflex’ thing is a Woodsen family trait, you know,” Hannah informed Gavin, her eyes sparkling with lust.

Ashley lifted her head from Gavin’s cock, her tongue trailing along his undercarriage as her lips moved along his shaft, her frothy drool leaving foamy, white streaks along his cock. Sucking tightly around his cockhead, Ashley pulled her mouth from his cock with a loud, wet pop and gasped in air.

“I didn’t know that,” Ashley replied, panting.

“Why would you? It’s not like we make a habit of deepthroating cocks around each other. This is a pretty special occasion,” Hannah said, glancing up at Gavin with a smirk. “But, if you don’t believe me…”

“I bet you’re all talk, right, Gavin?” Ashley challenged her sister. “What do you think, Chloe?”

“Yeah, no way, she can do what you just did,” Gavin agreed, buzzed with **** and drunk with desire, not willing to miss the opportunity to be sucked off by the two Woodsens in the same night.

“I’d like to see that,” Chloe confessed, biting her lip and watching the older blonde.

It was an obvious set up, not that Hannah really minded. With a hand still gripping his balls, Chloe’s hand still rubbing hers, Hannah leaned forward and opened her mouth. She stuck out her tongue first, sliding under the head along where the foreskin met the glans. Immediately she could taste the cocktail of Ashley and Gavin’s fluids, the saltiness of his precum combined with the crema of Ashley’s throat. Elevating his cock with her tongue, she lifted his head upwards into her mouth, wrapping her lips around the base of his tip and slurping at the precum dribbling out.

Bringing her hand up from his balls, she snaked her arm around his hip and grabbed Gavin’s buttocks. Pulling him close, she pushed her head forward, his cock sinking into the mouth in one seamless thrust until once again he felt his cockhead hit the back of a girl’s throat. While Ashley had drawn him in slowly, savouring his cock, Hannah worked her mouth along his shaft much quicker, taking only seconds to go from supping on his tip to having her throat filled. And Hannah didn’t hold it there, but quickly pulled her mouth back, sliding back up the length of his dick until her lips were just at the edge of her glans before shoving his cock all the way back into her throat again.

Bowing his head and groaning, Gavin was mesmerised by Hannah’s rapid fire sucking, pistoning her face up and down his cock, feeling the tightness around his tip every single time his cockhead entered her throat. Her hand on his ass pulled him in every time she swallowed his cock and Gavin began absent-mindly thrusting to match her furious deepthroating of his cock. Fuck, he thought, enjoying the machinations of this college girl’s mouth on his dick, slobbering all over his dick, spittle flying all over his thighs and dripping onto Chloe’s hand that was still fondling his ballsack.

“Alright, alright. You were only supposed to show us you could deepthroat a dick, not devour the poor man whole,” Ashley interrupted, moving in close to his cock again, playfully bumping shoulders with her elder sis. “This is meant to be my punishment, remember?”

Hannah released Gavin’s ass cheek and slid her mouth back, this time slipping off the cock completely, before she said, “As the proper winner, I reserve the right to change your forfeit at any time. Soooo, maybe your penalty should be not getting to suck Gavin’s cock? Since you seem to like it so much!”

“Now that wouldn’t really be fair to Gavin,” the blonde cheerleader argued sweetly, Gavin shaking his head in agreement above them. “To not let me finish what I started.”

“That’s true,” Hannah admitted, but moved the cock past her sister, offering it to the redhead on the other side. “But I think it’s Chloe’s turn.”

“Oh, Chloe, yes, yay,” Ashley cheered, the **** making any issues the pair had seem largely inconsequential. “You’ve sucked his cock before, so I bet you know all the nooks and crannies that’ll make him pop.”

“Oh, um, well, I can’t deepthroat it like you girls can,” Chloe replied, surprised at being called to join in but drawing her hand up from his ballsack all the same and gripping the base of his cock, aiming it towards her face. “But I do have a few tricks of my own.”

His redheaded friend leaned forward but not towards the tip of his cock. His length slid up along her face until she came to the base of his cock where she pressed her lips. Feeling his cock shiver as she planted a tender kiss at the root of his shaft, Gavin looked down, Chloe’s own blue eyes staring back at him from behind his cock. Moving up, she planted another soft kiss against the undercarriage of his cock, feeling his veins warm and throbbing on her lips. She kissed here and there, sometimes moving to one side, then back to the underside, moving methodically up along his length, inch by inch, kiss by kiss. She left wet lip prints along his cock, the salvia of the two other girls to suck his dick before her sticking to her lips, leaving strands of their leftover slobber hanging from her mouth.

She planted a kiss against the ridge of his helmet, flicking out her tongue, glancing across the edge of his glans as she finally reached the head of his cock. Gavin groaned, his cockhead receiving some attention after having been neglected while Chloe had kissed her way tenderly, slowly, from the bottom of his cock to the top. Of course, that had been her intention, to take her time, to keep him waiting, to get him yearning for another mouth to wrap itself around his cock. And that’s just what she did, leaning in and opening her mouth, inhaling Gavin’s mushroomed head into her tight, hot, wet, little mouth.

While her tongue lapped at his sensitive tip in her mouth, her lips sucking tightly around his cockhead, Chloe brought her hand up from Gavin’s pelvis, gently wrapping her fingers around his shaft and slowly beginning to stroke his cock. Up and down her hand slid, easily moving along his shaft thanks to the lathering of saliva from both girls before. The drool squelched in her hand as her hand pumped his cock flesh, the skin bunching against his balls and then against her lips, her mouth still tightly wrapped about his tip, hot, wet, slurping sounds coming from her throat as she sucked hard on his slit. He could feel the precum practically being squeezed out of is cock by her mouth and hand. Then he even felt something wet against his ballsack.

Forcing himself to look past his hot, big-titted friend, he saw Hannah, or more accurately the top of Hannah’s blonde hair as she nestled herself in below Chloe, her mouth on his balls. She lapped at the sack first, coating it in her saliva with her tongue, and then drew a ball into her mouth, sucking on that single teste, stretching his ball sack as it delved deeper into her mouth. Meanwhile Chloe kept sucking, her fist pumping faster now along the middle of his shaft, a short space of a few inches, an inch from her mouth and an inch from the base to keep from hitting Hannah. But in that small zone, her hand jacked his cock furiously now, coaxing the cum from his heavy laden balls.

Just as he began to feel a familiar tingle in his tightening ballsack, Chloe lifted her mouth from his cock and offered it back to Ashley, telling her, “I think he’ll cum any minute now.”

“Fucking hell, she’s right,” Gavin admitted, as Ashley giggled. “I’m not going to last much longer with you girls.”

“Bownt wet whim chome win bjure bwuth,” Hannah called from below with a mouthful of his ballsack, then, pulling her mouth from his nuts for a second, reiterated, “I’ve got somewhere more fun for his load.”

Ashley’s mouth was already back on Gavin’s dick before Hannah had finished her sentence, bobbing her head up and down the top few inches of his cock, working the head and shaft into her mouth routinely. Inside her mouth, her tongue swirled around his exposed glans lapping at the precum leaking out and slathering his tip with her drool. She couldn’t quite deepthroat him this time, Hannah’s head was in the way, but the way she rolled her lips up and down the top half of his cock, coupled with Hannah’s own sucking of his balls was an absolutely exquisite sensation all of its own.

He hadn’t expected Chloe to join in too, didn’t think there was enough space or much of his cock that wasn’t covered, but Chloe found a way. Slipping in below Ashley, Chloe brought her tongue to the base of Gavin’s cock, lapping at the root. At the same time, Hannah’s tongue slipped out, wetting his ballsack and drawing more of it into her suckling mouth. Their tongues bumped and the girls hesitated, though only for a moment. Hannah’s was the first to move, flicking against Chloe’s tongue and stroking Gavin’s balls. Chloe’s tongue replied, sliding between Hannah’s and the base of Gavin’s cock.

He looked down, mesmerized once again by the sight that he saw; Ashley sucking hungrily on his cock, while Chloe and Hannah were pretty much lip locked around his balls. Never in his wildest dreams had he imagined these three girls together, not a one without their mouths on his stiff, hard cock. It was enough to make any man weak and Gavin was no different. The combined sensations of their lips and tongues all over his cock and balls had the cum surging up along his shaft within seconds.

“Ah, fuck, fuck, I’m cumming,” Gavin warned them. “I can’t hold it back any longer.”

The first spurt splashed against the back of Ashley’s throat before she could even think about moving. She managed to pull her lips from his cock, just in time for the second rope to draw a white, creamy line down her perfect little face. Hannah and Chloe broke contact with his balls and base, sliding up beside Ashley, as Hannah wrapped a hand around Gavin’s slick shaft. As the third blast erupted from the head of his cock, Hannah pointed the tip towards her tits, his cum spraying over the swell of her breasts. Another spurt shot out, slapping against her cleavage and splashing out over the width of her tits. The next couple loads were reserved for Chloe, soaking her tits with his seed just as he had done Hannah. And when he was dripping and drained, Ashley brought her tongue back to his cock head, lapping up what was left in the pipes.

“Good job, Gavin,” Hannah said, swirling a finger around the cum on her chest as it ran between her tits and over her nipples. “Now I can’t say a man has never cum on my tits.”

Are they done for the night? Are the others returning any time soon?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)