But never far enough to forget you

“I’m a fan of edging,” Holly muttered under her breath, “but this is getting ridiculous.”

She rubbed her legs together in mild frustration. It wasn’t like she wanted to cum (actually, tonight would be hotter if Nick was so obsessed with the girls he was in bed with that he forgot all about the two of them) but she was starting to get impatient, wondering when they would get to the good part.

Nick wasn’t going to have sex with Cinder. She understood that much. And he obviously wasn’t going to have sex with Dani, either. But right now, it seemed like Dawn was the center of the show, and his penis hadn’t gotten anywhere close to her vagina!

Hell- his pants were still on!

How long was this going to go for? Even Holly needed to get sleep!

…But it wasn’t like she could go and say “Hey, are you guys going to get to the fucking yet?”

That would be a little too intrusive. So, she just kept rubbing her legs together in spite of her chastity belt, and hoped that Nick would psychically sense her wishes and get to the good part.

Instead, Cinder looked back at her. The other girl’s lips pinched together in a tight scowl that made Holly roll her eyes.

Just what she didn’t need- the rude girl to be giving her the stink-eye.

“This is your problem, too,” she mouthed to Cinder. “If you don’t move things along, you’re never getting that collar off.”

Maybe it was a bit mean of her to say that. But Cinder seemed to be waffling between what she wanted and she what she needed, and at times it wasn’t even clear which of those things applied.

Luckily, Dani eating Dawn out had done a lot for boosting the excitement in the bedroom. Holly could feel the desire rolling off of Nick as he watched the two women go at it together. She knew that he was aroused by stuff like that, and was glad that Dawn was happy to indulge. It had been one of Holly’s biggest concerns when Dani had presented this idea to everyone.

Nobody liked when a girl was just playing at liking women to please a boy- but it seemed that Dawn was actually starting to get into it.

That was information Holly could file away for later, and confront Dawn about when she was in a clearer mental state.

At length.

A small smirk touched Holly’s lips as she considered that possibility. She wondered how the so-called “genius” would explain her way out of THAT one! Good luck, cat girl!

…Okay, maybe that was a little mean of her.

Holly cleared her throat slightly. Not enough for anyone on the bed to even hear. But, to her relief, it seemed like she and Nick were on the same page, because he was starting to get drawn in even further to what was happening.

He never looked her way- never took his eyes off the two girls enjoying a sapphic embrace. But somehow, she just knew that he was sensing her thoughts.

Or maybe that was more wishful thinking on her part.

…Nope, no, because he was starting to take his pants off. Oh, yeah, now it was a show!

“What are you doing!?” Cinder responded with the outrage Holly had come to expect from her. “Don’t take out your-! …Th-that!” Her face was glowing so brightly Holly wondered if it could serve as a replacement for the bedside lamp.

“I’m getting tired of waiting,” Nick said, pulling down his underwear and revealing his cock to everyone in the room. Cinder immediately stiffened (fitting) when she laid eyes on it. She started grinding her teeth in obvious agitation, but Holly noticed that she hadn’t looked away yet.

How curious. What could it be that intrigued her so much, hmm?

As Holly suppressed her amusement, she leaned in intently. Cinder wasn’t the only one responding to Nick’s manhood. Dawn, who until this point had been showing quite a blissful expression in the wake of Dani’s tender touch, was roused from her sleep as if the scent of Nick’s cock was a smelling salt to cure her of an affliction.

“Mmmmm…” she purred, propping herself up on her elbows and shooting a hot gaze over to Nick’s erection. “Something sure looks goooood…”

“Oh, really?” Dani playfully raised her head, wiping off her moist lips as they turned into a smile. “So, that’s it, then? I give you an orgasm, a darn loud one, at that, and your first instinct is to run over to Mr. Cock once you’ve gotten yours, without any reciprocity?”

Holly wasn’t sure what surprised her more- Dani using the term “Mr. Cock” without a single touch of irony, or knowing the word “reciprocity” and using it in the proper context.

Both seemed out of the realm of possibility if she was being frank.

Dawn glanced over at Dani and pinched her lips together in a wry smile. “Hey, have a little heart,” she said, her tail twitching behind her as she smacked her lips together. “Nick’s been a very patient boy. Doesn’t he get at least a little treat? For waiting such a long time?”

Her hand was already drifting towards his lap. Which was pretty bold of her, considering they practically had an entire bed between the two of them.

Dani sighed and rolled her eyes in playful exasperation.

“Hey, don’t look at me, I can wait,” Nick said. As if he hadn’t just pulled down his pants for a very obvious reason. Not even Mary was buying that.

“Sure, sure, you just showed off that penis of yours to tempt Dawn away, because you’re waiting for your turn,” Dani said sarcastically. The grin on her face showed that it wasn’t as big of a deal as she was making it out to be, which was a relief to Holly.

But for Cinder, all of this was just confusing. She didn’t understand the dynamics at play between the three of them, so Nick’s statements, Dani’s jests, and Dawn’s teasing all struck her as very confusing and strange. And the fact that it all revolved around sex, which she was still uncertain about, didn’t help matters.

“Who said he was taking it out for me?” Dawn pointed out, pivoting back to Dani in the interest of keeping the peace. And also because, as nice as it was to think about Nick and his cock, there was a chance for something more interesting to arise here. “…We have someone else who might want a turn first, you know.”

Cinder blinked. It took way too long for her to realize that Dawn was talking about her. “…Wait, what are you talking about!?” She screeched, jerking upright. Her eyes went wide and she looked at Nick in disbelief. “I-! I’m not going to-!”

“Oh?” Dawn pounced on her hesitation immediately and adjusted her glasses. Her orgasm had kicked her brain back into working order, and she was going to take every opportunity that presented itself. “Not going to whaaaat?”

“Have sex with him!” Cinder sputtered. “I already said that, so don’t try and pretend like you can fool me!”

No matter how many… pheromones they pumped into the air, Cinder wasn’t going to be like Dawn and give into her base urges like some sort of animal! She couldn’t find a trace of the genius Ella had befriended anywhere on this bed, just a horny little feline pervert! And Cinder wasn’t about to let the same thing happen to her!

Dawn sighed and rolled her eyes. “No one says you have to have sex, Cinder. There are other ways you can get familiar with Nick’s cock.”

Nick glanced at Dawn worriedly. He didn’t want to push Cinder too far, but at the same time, he couldn’t help but be intrigued by the possibility in Dawn’s words.

Cinder’s voice cracked a little. “Wh-what are you even talking about?” She demanded, pretending to be clueless.

Dawn rolled her eyes again. “Well, for starters, you’re the only one here who hasn’t taken any clothes off,” she pointed out.

“Not true!” Cinder protested. She jammed an accusatory finger at the blue-haired tomboy. “She certainly hasn’t-!”

Her exclamation died in her throat as Dani immediately pushed her shorts down to show her panty-clad pussy. Her juices were causing the fabric to cling to her womanhood so tightly every detail could be seen through it.

Cinder let out a squeak.

Holly watched on, intrigued. This was going in a direction she didn’t expect.

“What? I’m not saying you have to do it,” Dani said, pulling her panties down as well. “But I got in the hot spring with him this morning. I’m certainly not afraid of showing him my body!”

Nick appreciated that, he really did. And as thanks, he tried to look at her as respectfully as possible and not stare at her pussy lips.

Keyword being “tried”.

Cinder was now the only person on the bed who was still fully-dressed, and she could feel the tension in the room. She squirmed awkwardly, rubbing her legs together. “I… I can… I can’t… I…”

Her thoughts were all a jumble. And the way everyone was looking at her didn’t help. Neither did the fact that her eyes kept drifting to his erection, even when she tried to stop herself from doing that.

She swallowed nervously. “I-I…!”

“Cinder,” Dawn said, crawling over to her flustered friend and taking the other woman’s hand in hers. “It’s alright. You can stay clothed. No one’s saying you have to show him the goods, alright? Just go at your own pace.”

For Cinder, who had grown accustomed to responding with anger at every slight, being treated with kindness like this was a little overwhelming.

So overwhelming that she didn’t respond to Dawn slowly leading her hand over to Nick’s cock until her fingers were wrapped around it.

Then something else overwhelmed her even further.

Touched the Master’s Penis! +2 VP

Cinder’s first reaction was to pull her hand away as fast as possible, as if she’d just been burned.

But she didn’t do that. The warm throbbing of his cock felt strange in her grasp, and the way it seemed to move, like it was alive (which it was) left her stunned in place.

What the fuck!? Why am I-!? What am I touching right now!? Her brain screamed, even though she knew exactly what she was touching, even though she stubbornly refused to lower her eyes to confirm her suspicions.

Looking down would be admitting defeat. She might as well wear a big sign that said “Yes, I’m touching a penis right now, and I’m proud of it!”

…Not that she was proud of it.

Or liked it.

No, of course that wasn’t the case!

But she was hypersensitive to the perception everyone had of her, and right now, they all must be thinking the same exact thing. Time seemed to slow down to the point that each second became an endless eternity, and as her ears picked up the way Nick quickly sucked in a tense breath of air, she flinched.

His cock throbbed. That… that was a sign that he liked what she was doing. He liked the fact that she was touching him.

…Why was she still touching him!? She should have let go the second she knew what she was doing! But she didn’t. She just sat there, in her drenched, ruined maid outfit, caressing his throbbing cock…

No, no, she wasn’t caressing it! She was just touching it! If her hand reflexively squeezed when she felt it throb, that-that was just a reflex! And besides, Dawn was the one who had made her touch it in the first place, she was the one who-!

Dawn was holding up both of her hands. A sly smile was on her lips as she scooted away, wiggling her eyebrows.

Cinder’s brain took a second to reboot as she processed just what that meant, along with taking in the throbbing feeling of his shaft in her grasp.

Nick’s cock was hard.

She was touching it- no, she was holding it.

One might even be able to make the case that she was fondling it.

And what was she doing about it?

…

“Ungh…” Nick grunted beside her as Cinder squeezed his cock again. Like she was feeling it out. It seemed like she was completely unaware of what her hand was even doing, given the vacant, glassy stare of her eyes as she gazed off into the distance.

She tightened her grip even more, and gave it a stroke. The sort of treatment that you’d expect from a loving girlfriend, not… whatever his relationship with Cinder was. At this point, there was no way of dismissing what was going on as just an inadvertent situation orchestrated by Dawn’s mischievous personality. No, Cinder was unquestionably an active participant at this point.

You couldn’t really “accidentally” stroke somebody’s cock. And you definitely couldn’t do it three times in a second.

That understanding was what finally brought Cinder back down to reality, and helped her realize what exactly it was that she was doing.

“Wh-what-!?” She gasped in disbelief, and finally looked down at where the two of them were connected.

The first thing that caught her eye was the throbbing head of Nick’s erection. Seeing it in this state, it was bigger than she’d expected, downright menacing, even. Or maybe that was her brain playing tricks on her, trying to intimidate her a bit.

Once she managed to focus on the other details, like the rounded tip and the curve of the shaft, she couldn’t avoid the caramel-colored hand that was gripping it tightly, like it never wanted to let the thing go.

At that point, any chance she had of denying what was going on had disappeared.

“Hyiieeee!” Cinder let out a very Ella-like shriek, and finally managed to tear her hand away from Nick’s cock. Way, way too late to convince anyone that she hadn’t been enjoying herself, even if only on an unconscious level.

And it didn’t help her case that she’d given it a final stroke before pulling away from him, either, but only Nick could really feel that.

Cinder brought her hand to her chest, and clutched her wrist tightly. Her fingers were trembling, and she still felt the phantom warmth of Nick’s shaft in her grip. Her palm felt a little sticky, and another errant glance at his cock (just for the purposes of verification, you understand) identified the culprit- the clear liquid oozing from the hole in the tip.

“Urgh…” Cinder thought she was going to be sick. Surely nausea was the only reason for the achy, strange feeling she felt in the pit of her stomach, and not some form of excitement! No, Cinder wouldn’t allow that!

“Aww, look at that,” Dawn cooed, wagging her tail behind her as she leaned forward on her hands and knees to get a better look. “His cock’s all hard and desperate now… poor thing… you coulda helped him out a little longer, you know!”

“I-I-!” Cinder babbled out, unable to stand up for herself. Her eyes were twisted with confusion and disbelief, and Dawn was happy to take full advantage of her flustered state.

“Well, if you’re not going to help, I certainly will,” she said, leaning forward and giving his cock a lick. She drew her tongue from the base of the shaft all the way up to the tip, swirling around the head and licking up all that yummy precum that Cinder thought she was too good for.

Cinder’s breath hitched in her throat and she watched Dawn, enthralled by the lascivious girl’s performance.

Holly felt the need to give applause. Dawn was really holding nothing back here! From one pervert to another, she had nothing but praise for her fellow shorty.

But not everybody was satisfied by Dawn’s actions. As the cat girl sampled Nick’s cock some more, she started wagging her behind, letting her tail dance behind her tantalizingly as she showed off her round bottom to the woman who she’d left high and dry.

Dani wasn’t done with her quite yet.

In her right mind, she probably wouldn’t have done something like this. But Dani was horny. So, she reached out and inserted two fingers into Dawn’s soaking wet snatch, pushing down on her sensitive buttons with the insistence of someone who didn’t like being forgotten about.

“Haaahn!” Dawn’s head jerked up and her eyes went wide as she arched her back in a way only a master gymnast could. Cinder gasped, wondering if the cat girl had just broken her spine from the sharpness of the angle. But no, Dawn just needed a moment to come down from her high and regain her focus.

Then, she looked back at Dani and pouted. “What was that for?” She flicked her tail against Dani’s face in protest.

Dani pinched her lips together in a tight smile. “Don’t forget, I think you owe someone else on this bed oral sex first, before you get your treat,” she gently reminded Dawn.

Even as the words left her lips, she was anxious. If Dawn wasn’t comfortable performing oral sex on another woman, then obviously, Dani wasn’t going to push her. But if she was willing to, then-

“Okay, fine, you got me,” Dawn said wryly, smacking her lips together. She sat up straight and turned her head towards the tomboy. “You’re right, I suppose it’s only right I return the favor.”

Even as she said that, though, her hand reached out and gave Nick’s cock a quick stroke. And a handjob from Dawn was pretty damn good.

Nick grunted in approval and nodded, assuring her that he was fine with waiting a little bit longer if Dawn wanted to “repay” Dani’s favor that badly.

Dawn was thrilled to hear it. She licked her lips and fluttered her eyelashes towards the tomboy, who was getting hot under the collar. And, as she turned around and got ready to show Dani just how much she appreciated the other woman’s gentle touch, Cinder found herself enthralled.

All of this… the three of them… they were really going at it so passionately. And meanwhile, Cinder hadn’t even been able to touch his cock.

It felt like something she should be ashamed of, but she wasn’t.

If anything, she felt like this was only making her more excited.

Her heart began to pound rapidly in her chest, and she found herself licking her lips as well. Her sticky hand was hot against her chest, and she didn’t even notice.

As Holly watched Dani lean back and Dawn get to work, she found herself wondering if maybe she should step in and say something again. As nice as this was to see… she really hoped that they would actually get to something juicier.

She was really starting to regret telling Nick he couldn’t stick his cock inside of that bratty latina. Even if she knew it was wrong. Stupid Nick being all reasonable and stuff, that wasn’t sexy at all!