More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by bryce193 bryce193

What's next?

More then friends

Sarah is sleeping over at Libby’s tonight, shr see them at school Monday..are libby and Sara together romantically, is Sara even into girls.Rachel’s fingers worked faster between her thighs as the vampire maidens on screen writhed in ecstasy, their fangs glistening under moonlight that didn’t exist in her darkened bedroom. A shudder ran through her—half from pleasure, half from the guilty thrill of imagining Libby’s hands instead of her own. What if Libby walked in right now? The thought sent heat flooding Rachel’s cheeks.Back at Libby’s, soft laughter drifted from the dimly lit living room, where Sarah and Libby were sprawled across the couch, a half-empty pizza box between them. A horror movie played on the TV, ignored in favor of hushed conversation. Libby tucked a strand of dark hair behind her ear, her fingers lingering near Sarah’s shoulder. “So, you really don’t mind that I kissed Jenny at the party last week?” Sarah shrugged, but her cheeks warmed. “Why would I? We’re just friends.” A beat of silence.

Then, the creak of a floorboard made both girls freeze. The living room door swung open, revealing Janice—Libby’s mother—leaning against the frame with a knowing smirk. Her sharp eyes flicked between them, lingering on the scant inches separating Sarah and Libby on the couch. "Movie night, huh?" Janice purred, crossing her arms. The hem of her silk robe slid just high enough to tease bare thigh as she stepped forward. "Funny. The TV’s been on mute for the last ten minutes." Libby stiffened.

Sarah's pulse spiked as Libby's fingers twitched against the couch cushion—so close to brushing her own. The air between them crackled with something unspoken. Janice arched a brow, her smirk deepening. "So? Are you two in here making out instead of watching your little horror flick?" Libby choked on a nervous laugh, but Sarah didn't miss the way her gaze darted to her lips. "Mom, god—we were just talking!" "Mm-hmm." Janice's robe whispered against her skin as she stepped closer, her perfume—something off and vanilla—drowning out the scent of cold pizza. She tilted Sarah's chin up with a manicured finger.

Sarah's pulse spiked as Libby's fingers twitched against the couch cushion—so close to brushing her own. The air between them crackled with something unspoken. Janice arched a brow, her smirk deepening. "So? Are you two in here making out instead of watching your little horror flick?" Libby choked on a nervous laugh, but Sarah didn't miss the way her gaze darted to her lips. "Mom, god—we were just talking!" "Mm-hmm." Janice's robe whispered against her skin as she stepped closer, her perfume—something off and vanilla—drowning out the scent of cold pizza. She tilted Sarah's chin up with a manicured finger.

"lt's fine if you are," Janice murmured, her thumb tracing Sarah’s lower lip. "After all, no one chooses who they end up liking. It just happens." Her gaze flicked to Libby, whose breath had gone shallow. "What matters is if you act on those feelings… or not." The words hung in the air like a dare. Sarah’s pulse roared in her ears. Libby’s knee pressed against hers, warm and trembling. The movie’s flickering light caught the green in Libby’s eyes—wide, ****, wanting.

Back at Rachel’s house, her breath hitched as her fingers worked faster, her laptop screen casting eerie shadows across her flushed skin. The vampire maidens on-screen writhed in unholy pleasure, their moans muffled only by the thick, humid air of her bedroom. What if it was Libby touching me instead? The fantasy sent a fresh wave of heat between her thighs. She imagined Libby’s hands—strong, confident—sliding up her plush hips, her mouth trailing kisses along Rachel’s neck before biting down— A sharp gasp escaped her lips. Her free hand fumbled for her phone, her thumb swiping clumsily to Libby’s Instagram.

Rachel’s phone screen illuminated her sweaty face as she scrolled through Libby’s latest post—a candid shot of her and Sarah laughing, their shoulders pressed together. A fresh pang of jealousy coiled in her stomach, mixing with the throbbing between her legs. Her wet fingers slid faster as she zoomed in on Libby’s lips—that cocky smirk that made Rachel’s thighs clench. She imagined those lips whispering filthy promises against her ear, those hands pinning her wrists to the bed while— Knock knock knock. Rachel froze. “Rach?” Her mother’s voice, laced with amusement, came through the door. “You’ve been in there a while.

Knock knock knock. Rachel’s breath hitched, her fingers stilling between her thighs. The laptop screen flickered, casting eerie shadows across her flushed face as the vampire maidens continued their sinful dance—unaware of her sudden panic. “Rach?” Cassie’s voice was light, teasing. “You’ve been in there a while. Everything okay?” Rachel’s heart pounded. She yanked her hand from her shorts, wiping her fingers hastily on the hem of her shirt before slamming the laptop shut.

“Y-yeah, Mom! Just—uh—watching something!” Rachel stammered, hastily shoving her phone under her pillow. She winced at the sticky dampness between her thighs, praying her mother wouldn’t notice the telltale flush on her cheeks. Cassie chuckled lowly, the doorknob rattling slightly as she tested it—locked, as usual. “Mmm, I bet.” There was a knowing pause. “Well, don’t stay up too late. And maybe… crack a window?

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)