More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 67 by Duskford Duskford

What does Zack do now?

He fucks her, with an audience

Zack stood there staring at Lisa, one thing that he always liked about her when they were dating was her curvy body. He didn’t know how she came to have a body like that, despite the fact that she danced sometimes, she wasn’t a cheerleader. He guessed that it was due to her heritage.

He knew that he had given her his blessing to pursue Gavin, but seeing her almost naked like that again made his cock throb, especially after the frustration of being unable to jerk off to Chloe’s pictures. But what aroused him more was remembering the fact that he never got to have full blown sex with Lisa, he lost his virginity to the unknown girl at Ashley’s party and Lisa dumped him for that before they got past the heavy foreplay stage. When her shirt fell off and he saw her round tits again, he couldn’t take it anymore and his feet started moving before he even noticed.

“Zack?” Lisa asked a little warily.

Zack didn’t say anything. When he got to her, he snaked a hand behind her head and brought her mouth to his in a hard kiss, a kiss in which Lisa melted right away. While he viciously plundered her mouth with his tongue, his other hand lowered down to her firm ass and squeezed it hard, causing Lisa to moan into the kiss.

Lisa didn’t know what made her agree with this, maybe it was the memory of the good times between them or the sense of unfinished business and resentment from when they broke up, or even the frustration she felt for not being able to go further with Gavin.

He pressed her body against his own, making her feel the bulge of his dick against his stomach. All of a sudden, Zack didn’t care about anything he might have said or allowed her to do, Lisa was scorching hot and he was going to have her once, for the first and last time.

The young man then started to lead her to the back of the couch, backing her up against it. After he enjoyed the taste of her mouth for a little while longer, Zack broke the kiss and spun Lisa around, bending her over the couch. She looked back at him with a look of pure and raw lust in her chocolate brown eyes, with her amazing, rounded ass sticking out for him.

”Dammit, I didn’t remember her ass was almost as perfect as Victoria’s.” He thought while placing a hand on one of the cheeks and lightly digging his fingers in the firm flesh before he took a hold of the waistband of her black panties and lowered the garment all the way down to her feet, baring her naked glistening pussy.

Lisa whimpered at his touch. As she looked at him, it became clearer in her head why she consented to this, she wanted Zack to see what he missed out when he fucked that girl on Ashley’s party and continued to pine over Victoria. She wanted to punish him for all the suffering she endured when they broke up and that remained bottled up in a hidden part of her heart.

She wiggled her fine posterior for him. “Tell me, Zack,” She said, provocatively. “Does your sweet Victoria have an ass as nice as mine?”

Zack smirked and raised an eyebrow. “You would be surprised.” And then he delivered a light swat to her right buttock.

Lisa yelped, glaring at him. “Don’t do that!” She saw that he was raising his hand for another one. “I’m serious, Zack, I don’t like it!”

Zack chuckled. “Ok, ok.” He then lowered his boxers and kicked it off to the side, his long cock springing out. Lisa’s eyes widened when she saw it.

“Fuck, the thing seems even bigger now!” She whispered.

Zack just grinned and, taking a hold of his dick by its base, he finally positioned its tip at the entrance of Lisa’s wet pussy, ready to penetrate his hot ex-girlfriend’s body for the first time. “Can I?”

“Hold on,” She replied, burying her head on the couch, to muffle the scream she was sure it would come when he penetrated her. She had lost her cherry to the only boyfriend she had after Zack, but his dick wasn’t even near Zack’s size. In the end, the arousing thought of being fucked by her ex’s big dick that she never got to try in the past in places other than her hands and mouth won over her mind. “Go, stick it in!”

“Here I go!” He whispered back, shoving his dick into her pussy almost in one go, Lisa’s loud moan muffled by the couch. It slipped in like a hot knife slicing through butter and Zack immediately began rocking his body against hers, effectively fucking her tight snatch.

He let out a long moan as he grasped her hips for support, it was good to finally be inside of a girl again. The past few days with Victoria and Heather haven’t been exactly easy for him, so he could certainly use a little tension releasing right now. Lisa was tighter than any of the girls he had sex with after the mystery girl, her walls gripping his shaft deliciously.

Zack picked up his pace, ramming into her a little more forcefully, which had the effect of making Lisa scream loudly, her mouth thankfully muffled by the couch that she was holding in a tight grip.

“I can’t believe I forgot how hot you are,” Zack said, grunting at the sensation of thrusting his dick into Lisa’s willing wet cunt. “We should have done this when we were dating.”

Lisa’s long black hair flew as she snapped her head back with a smirk. “Make sure to enjoy it while you can, then, aaahh,” A moan interrupted her speech. “This is the only time we’re gonna fuck, you and me.”

“Don’t worry,” Zack groaned while his fingers dug into the skin of her waist. “Now that I’ve started this, I intend to fuck you as best as I can!”


Chloe had ran to the bathroom when she heard Zack’s curse and didn’t dare to get out of there, even after a few minutes had passed and no one came to look in the bathroom. She had been interrupted just when her fantasy with Colin was reaching its peak, which would without a doubt trigger her own climax as well.

”Why in the hell did Zack curse for?” She asked herself. ”Well, seems like everything calmed down, maybe it’s safe to go out again.”

The redhead then opened the bathroom door, twisting the door handle as slowly and carefully as she could, however, as she peaked through the gap, her eyes almost bugged out of her head when she saw the shocking scene happening at the living room.

Chloe couldn’t believe what had happened during the short time in that she was hidden in the bathroom. Lisa went from giving a handjob to Gavin in his room to being roughly fucked by Zack over the couch. When she saw Lisa with Gavin, she assumed that something had happened between them over the past day for Lisa to be acting so forward with him, but now, in a matter of a few minutes, everything seemed to have turned upside down.

Her blue eyes lowered to the point where Zack’s crotch repeatedly met Lisa’s backside with a slapping sound and she let out a gasp at what she saw. ”Oh my fucking god, he’s huge!” She thought as she gawked at her oldest friend’s long penis sawing in and out of Lisa’s pussy.

”Zack’s even bigger than Gavin and Kurt.” Her hand began to find its way towards her panty-covered pussy at the sight. It was like watching a brother have sex, something that, even though Chloe knew it was wrong, she supposed that it only added to the hotness of the situation.

As her fingers snaked under the fabric of her panties, Chloe moved to the wall beside Gavin’s room, so that Zack and Lisa couldn’t spot her. When she touched her drenched pussy again, Chloe had to bite her lower lip to stifle her moan of pleasure, her mind once again bringing her to the fantasy of being with Colin in the middle of the woods.


Gavin was worried. He was tired and sleepy when Lisa left the room, but the thought that someone had spied on them was bothering him and making him lose sleep over it. That and the fact that his cock was still hard after Lisa’s unfinished handjob.

”Did she bump into whoever it was?” He mused.

He sighed as he remembered what Lisa did for him, he never meant for that to happen. Sure, Lisa was a very nice and sexy girl, damn good girlfriend material, but his mind was revolving too much around his good old friend Chloe lately. He couldn’t give Lisa false hopes, no matter how hot she was.

As for Chloe, he tried to avoid her during the hike to the cave, before it all went wrong, but it was of no use. Ever since that morning at the cabin when he woke up spooned to her, Gavin couldn’t take Chloe out of his head. As much as he tried, he couldn’t shake off the vision of her panty-covered ass, or the large mounds on her chest, or her beautiful clear blue eyes, or her sexy pouty lips or even her long flaming red hair.

When it was clear that he wouldn’t be able to fall asleep anytime soon, Gavin decided to try and stand up for a while. He got to walk to the table at dinner and fortunately, he didn’t feel any pain. ”Let’s see if I can do it again.”

With relative ease, the young man succeeded in swinging his legs out of the bed and stand up on his feet shortly after. ”Nice!” Gavin thought with a grin. ”Maybe I can go to the bathroom.”

He then picked up his t-shirt from the desk and went to the door while putting it on. However, when he opened the door, the first thing he saw was Chloe, which made him stop in his tracks. His friend was with her back turned to him, with her green nightshirt bunched around her waist as she appeared to be masturbating. ”What the fuck?!” Gavin thought while feeling his cock get even harder.

His brown eyes fixed on her panty-covered ass, he took a few steps toward her until he was standing directly behind her. The pleasant smell of her red hair hit his nose at once as he looked from over her shoulder. His eyes widened in surprise.

Lisa, who just a few minutes before was in his room jerking him off, was now bent over the couch with Zack pounding her hard from behind. Ignoring thoughts of how that lewd scene came to be, the only thing that Gavin could think of was how he admired and envied his best friend.

Despite being a geek like him, Zack never had any problems getting girls, with the notable exception of Victoria. More than ever, Gavin wished that he was more like Zack, so he could be able to do what his friend was doing to Lisa. ”Except that I wished I could do that with Chloe.”

His eyes shifted to Chloe standing in front of him, she hadn’t noticed Gavin behind her yet. Gavin’s heart soared with affection for the redhead, the only girl who was always there for him, who didn’t make fun of him and shared a lot of great moments with him since the day they met when both of them were only eight years old.

”I wonder what she’s thinking about.” He thought while watching Chloe masturbating. Somehow, he was finding that sight way more arousing than what was happening on the living room.

His cock was about to explode, so Gavin figured out that he had a decision to make, to continue being a coward forever or man up for once and take the risk.

He raised his right hand.

What does Gavin decide to do?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)