More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 65 by Duskford Duskford

What happens at night?

An eventful night at Ravers' Cabin

A restless Ashley tossed and turned on the bed as Brandon slept at her side. It already was the third night in a row that they didn’t have sex and she could tell that her boyfriend was becoming uneasy because of it. She was after all running out of excuses, having already used headaches, tiredness and an inexistent pain on her back to keep Brandon at bay.

She felt like a true monster for denying him what they both wanted, but she felt like she couldn’t be intimate with him now, not with all the thoughts and urges that have been running through her head for the past few days.

With a heavy sigh, the petite blonde began to entertain the notion of breaking up with Brandon, even if it was just for a while. She loved her first and only boyfriend, but Ashley was starting to think if she would ever be able to be with him again without satiating some of her urges and desires first.

”Like seeing what another guy feels like.”


Heather was laying on the bed in the master bedroom, dressed in a black tank top and white cotton panties, her dark brown hair fanned in the pillow below her head. Her blue eyes stared at some point on the ceiling as she tried to fall asleep, without success.

The reason of her lack of sleep couldn’t be other than Zack Bishop. She really had wanted to talk to him the previous day after Ashley interrupted them at the waterfall. But then they arrived back at the cabin to find that bizarre situation caused by Kurt and Zack set off to the woods again without Heather having the chance to talk to him and reward him for the wonderful orgasm he gave her behind the waterfall.

Now, he had spent a night with Victoria in a cave and god knows what things they done to each other while there. Heather wasn’t stupid, she knew that something had happened between the two of them during the night, otherwise Victoria wouldn’t have acted the way she did during the day.

At her right, Victoria was already sleeping like a log, her back turned to Heather and the covers up to her shoulders. The brunette sighed, her blonde friend had almost driven her crazy with all the worrying about Zack being out in the woods, she only calmed down after he called Heather to let her know about Gavin and spending the night with the Riveras.

Heather, on the other hand, wasn’t too happy with the thought of Zack sleeping at a cabin with an ex-girlfriend of his. She tried to not let her mind obsess over Zack like it was doing during the last few days, but somehow it couldn’t be helped. She briefly wondered if that sudden obsession wasn’t because of the fact that she hadn’t had sex in over a month now, but she doubted it. If that was the case, Zack wouldn’t be the only one featuring in her fantasies.

Sometimes, Heather wondered if her life would be better if she didn’t enjoy sex as much as she did. The blue-eyed brunette knew that, with the exception of Ashley and possibly Zack, all her friends thought that she was a sex starved slut and it made her sad. Ever since the night when she lost her virginity eight months ago, a night in which she really felt like a slut and decided to forget all about the occasion, she chose to embrace sex and enjoy it like it should be enjoyed instead of running from it.

That didn’t mean that she ran around fucking random guys like everyone thought she did. ”Hell, Kurt seems to think that I keep a list of kinky stuff to do.” She chuckled. The only truth was that she didn’t like to leave her any of her exes unsatisfied, and since all of them were jerks who couldn’t miss an opportunity to brag to their friends, that earned her a false reputation of being easy, when in reality she didn’t even have sex with a guy until the third or fourth date.

”People would be shocked if they knew the truth.” She grinned.

Her thoughts wandered back to Zack, and as she did so, her left hand slowly glided through the smooth skin of her stomach towards the waistband of her panties.

”Now, that’s a guy I wouldn’t mind letting ravage me whenever he wanted.” She thought while her fingers reached her patch of pubic hair.

When she touched her hot pussy lips, Heather was amazed at how wet she became just by thinking about Zack. She briefly glanced to her right to check on Victoria and, seeing that her friend still slept soundly, the captain of the cheerleading squad let her imagination run freely.

She withdrew her hand from under her panties to lick at the fingers for a while before reaching down again to gently rub at her wet center. She was brought to the cave behind the waterfall once again as she imagined Zack ignoring Ashley’s presence this time and walking over to her with his long cock standing up proudly at his crotch.

Heather imagined he would take her by the back of her head and stick his dick into her mouth to **** her to return his earlier favor. She felt an electric-like jolt at her pussy as the thought of submitting to Zack that way settled in her mind.

She caressed her folds faster while she imagined herself worshipping and slurping at Zack’s manhood. Fantasy Zack would then gather her naked breasts in his hands and stick his shaft between her mounds, initiating a sexy titfuck.

Heather had to bite her lower lip as her self induced pleasure escalated to new heights every time her fantasy evolved to another act. Her previously unused right hand slipped underneath her top and began pawing at her own tits while two fingers of her left one penetrated her sopping wet pussy.

Her thumb rubbed furiously at her sensitive clit at the same time that her index and middle fingers went in and out of her slippery love hole, the thought of Zack bending her over in front of Ashley’s wide eyes and shoving his mighty cock into her from behind bringing her close to her edge.

“Yeah, Zack, fuck me,” She whispered, unable to control herself. “Just like that, screw me with that monster…”

Her right hand was mauling her soft big breasts by now while her teeth were on the brink of drawing blood from her lower lip. The busty brunette then began to buck on the bed, her eyes tightly shut as a powerful orgasm began to spread over her body like wildfire. In her mind, Fantasy Zack had just pulled his dick out of her, spun her around and proceeded to paint her breasts with his hot white cum.

“That’s it, cum all over me…” She said quietly as her body rode out her climax.

It was about a minute later that a breathless Heather regained the ability to move her limbs after the amazing orgasm provided by her fantasy of Zack. However, what she didn’t take into account while in the throes of pleasure was that someone was in bed with her. And surely enough, when she slowly turned her head to the right, Victoria’s green eyes were staring at her amidst the darkness.

Victoria’s expression was one of shock as the two girls stared awkwardly at each other for a couple of minutes before the blonde shook her head in disapproval and turned her back to Heather.

The brunette cheerleader looked at her left hand glistening with her juices for a few seconds and frowned. “Fuck!” She shouted, before standing up and going to the bathroom to wash the aforementioned hand.


Despite the fact that it was already a little after midnight, Kurt decided to stay at the deck outside for a little while longer so he could enjoy the chilly night air. He had spent the whole day thinking, Heather’s earlier speech having gotten stuck on his mind.

Thinking about Heather brought a small smile to his face, a similar one to all the other smiles he had during the day when he remembered playing with his now sexy cousin as kids and all the fun they used to have. Having her tell him that she was worried about him and calling him a monster was something that touched his heart and made him remember about times when life was more pleasant.

He shifted his line of thought to the other girls, in all his eagerness to blame them and make them pay for what had happened to him, reason had abandoned him and prevented him from realizing that they didn’t have anything to do with his issue and that he couldn’t keep blaming all women for what happened.

”I’d still fuck the shit out of the three of them, though.”

As for the guys, Heather was also right in saying that he hadn’t too many friends back where he lived, as almost no one wanted to associate themselves with someone who scared the girls away. He vowed to change that and try to get to know Zack, Brandon and Gavin better.

And Kurt knew the perfect way to start that while he stared at Gavin’s phone in his hand. He knew right away that Zachary had a crush on Victoria and that later, somehow he got himself involved with Heather. Kurt never considered himself a good reader of people but something intrigued him, despite the torch that Zack seemed to carry for both Victoria and Heather, he thought that the younger guy looked differently at Chloe and was more at ease around her.

”I think the two of them like each other and didn’t realize that yet,” The blonde guy thought, scratching his chin. ”I think that I can help them with a little push.”

As he decided that, he looked up Zack’s number on Gavin’s contact list and sent to his phone all the pictures of Chloe that he took yesterday using the latter’s phone. He smirked at the notion of having somehow helped Zack and Chloe to get together.

Feeling good about that, he stood up and walked over to the rail, he almost couldn’t see Silver Lake and the area around it, but the moonlight illuminated everything enough to make for a breathtaking view. He stared at the moon reflected on the lake for a while before his eyes caught something near the cabin at the other side of the lake.

There were men, two or three of them, Kurt couldn’t tell. They were walking near the big cabin, looking and occasionally pointing at it. He raised an eyebrow, what they were doing wasn’t weird, it was the time at they were doing.

”Gavin’s phone says 12:19 A.M.,” He checked the device. ”It’s a bit late to be sightseeing.”

Kurt observed them for a few more minutes before yawning. He eventually decided to forget about those men and try to sleep, so he turned around and returned to the cabin’s interior.

What's happening with Zack, Chloe, Gavin and Lisa?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)