Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 33 by Duskford Duskford

What happens at night?

Bad night for some, good night for others

Ashley was lying on her side with Brandon peppering kisses down her shoulder and arm, but she wasn’t even paying attention to his caresses, the blonde’s mind was on the talk she had with Heather earlier.

”Can I really have sex with another guy?” She thought. ”But I love Brandon, I don’t wanna leave him.”

Brandon then snaked his hand around her body and squeezed her firm right breast through the tank top she was wearing, causing Ashley to roll onto her back, her blue eyes staring at the ceiling.

“C’mon, love, let’s play a little before we sleep, huh?” He said, kissing the side of her neck. “What do you say?”

Ashley was really horny and wanted nothing more than let her boyfriend ravage her, but she was feeling too much dirty because of her thoughts, she was too ashamed of herself to let Brandon make love to her, his touch alone was making her feel guilty.

“Sorry, Bran,” She **** herself to say. “But I have a little headache, I won’t be of much use to you tonight.”

Brandon frowned. “Have you taken something for it?” He asked concerned.

Ashley nodded. “Don’t worry, I’ll be better tomorrow,” She smiled. “Let’s just sleep tonight, okay?”

Brandon returned her smile and nodded, but if he could say the truth, his thoughts weren’t too much different from those of his girlfriend. It was on nights like these, the ones when he couldn’t have sex with Ashley, that he found his mind wandering.

Much like Ashley, Brandon didn’t ever have any experience with other girls, since he and Ashley started dating too much soon and stayed strong until today, two years after it all began.

He always felt guilty afterwards, but he often wondered how other girls would be like. He had countless opportunities to cheat on her, including times when some of her fellow cheerleaders threw themselves at him after practice or a game. His faithfulness remained unbreakable though.

As he watched Ashley drift to sleep, Brandon wondered if they were right in spending so much of their young lives together. He sighed.

”I just hope we don’t regret it when we get older.”


Victoria had just gotten ready for bed in the bathroom on the master bedroom, she chose to wear a green tank top and a pair of comfortable white shorts with white underwear underneath it.

When she exited into the bedroom though, the young blonde stopped in her tracks when she saw Heather sprawled on her side of the bed. The surprise being due to the brunette’s sleeping attire for that night, lacy black bra and panties.

“Uhn,” Victoria stammered. “Are you going to sleep like this, Heather?”

The busty cheerleader shrugged. “Well, it’s not like I’m still sharing the room with a boy, don’t you agree?”

Victoria frowned as she sat on her side of the bed. “Heather,” She said. “Did I interrupt something here by switching rooms with Zack?”

Heather shook her dismissively. “Pfft…” She looked at the ceiling. “What could you possibly have interrupted?”

“Well, I don’t know,” The blonde shrugged. “You two seemed strangely close since yesterday.”

“Please, Vicky, Zack’s just a friend that I happen to find cool enough to hang out.” Heather explained. “It’s just that, really.”

“Yeah,” Victoria smiled. “He was really nice for switching with me. I just feel bad that he decided to sleep on the couch though.”

Heather groaned inside her mind. ”Dammit, Victoria! I want to sleep!” She yelled mentally. “I don’t need you here saying how nice Zack is.”

“Not that I can blame him, your cousin turned out to be really mean, you know?”

“Yes, Vicky,” Heather finally said, wanting to make her friend stop talking. “Now please, let’s go to sleep? We’ll have a rough day tomorrow.”

Victoria grinned sheepishly. “Sorry, I didn’t remember the hike.” She apologized. “Night, Heather.”

“Night.” Heather rolled to her right as Victoria got herself comfortable on the other side. ”Damn, I can’t keep treating her like this. It’s not her fault that I’m feeling this pull towards Zack.”

After a few long minutes in which the busty brunette tried to make sense of what was happening inside her head, she eventually drifted to sleep alongside her new roommate.


”Hell,” Kurt cursed silently as he stroked his cock with ****. ”Two days in this wretched cabin and I’m no closer to getting laid than when I arrived.”

On his mind, he envisioned all four girls in the cabin on their knees before him, side by side while he took turns fucking each one of them, even his cousin.

As a matter of fact, besides the innocent, virginal Chloe, Heather was the one that turned him on the most. With that ever present sexy smirk of hers and her luscious big tits, Kurt figured that his cousin must be one hell of a lay.

“Yeah, take my cock, cousin!” He whispered as he shot his cum all over his torso.

When the blonde guy came back from his sexual high, what he considered one of his greatest ideas until now came to his mind.

”I don’t know how you did it yet, but you took Victoria from me, Heather,” He thought. ”Then after I deflower the little ginger, I’m gonna find out how kinky you really are.”

Kurt slept a few minutes later with a smirk on his face, certain that there was no better way to get back at Heather than tricking her into fucking him, a guy whom she allegedly hated.


“C’mon, Gavin! You can do it, c’mon!” An excited Chloe cheered on her old friend playing on his phone.

They were sitting on Gavin’s bed in their room as he battled a tough boss on the game which they liked. Chloe already put her phone aside some time ago, and now she was content in just watching Gavin play.

“I’m almost there,” Gavin said, his fingers moving like blurs on his phone’s screen. “I just have to hit him one more time.”

As he said that, the two excited teens looked at the screen on the very moment that the wizard controlled by Gavin destroyed his enemy with an ice spell.

“You did it!” Chloe gushed, hugging him around the neck in an impulse.

Gavin was so entranced by the rewards that he won in the game that he failed to notice the brief seconds in which Chloe’s large breasts pressed against his arm through the long blue t-shirt she was wearing. When he turned off his phone, she had already released him.

“Wow, now I’ll sleep like a log,” He stated, looking at his friend with a tired smile on his face. “Level 75, now there are only twenty five left.”

Chloe snorted. “Speak for yourself, I still have seventy one floors to climb.”

“Don’t worry, Chloe,” Gavin reassured her. “You’re already going faster than I did, looks like Heather was right about your archer.”

“Yeah, you better watch yourself, Gavin,” She teased. “Or I’m going to leave you behind very soon.”

Gavin chuckled. “The worst thing is that you actually can catch up with me, judging by the way your archer’s going through the floors.”

Chloe smiled at the compliment and stood up to go to her own bed. However, when she got on her feet she felt like stretching her body due to all the time that she remained sitting on the bed.

What she didn’t expect was that would make her t-shirt ride up her body and expose the very bottom of her ass to Gavin’s wide eyes. This time the young geek didn’t miss the involuntary show and his cock stirred inside his shorts. His eyes travelled through her toned, athletic legs to her firm bottom, half displayed to him.

After a few seconds, Chloe turned her head back and raised an eyebrow when she saw her friend’s mesmerized expression. It took a couple of seconds more for the redhead to realize that she was giving a little show for Gavin and it made her flush hotly. However, as soon as that realization came to her, she also remembered Heather’s teasing about her playing with Gavin all night. The normally sweet Chloe grinned and decided to be naughty for just a little while.

“Like what you see, Gavin?” She said to her friend in what she imagined to be a seductive tone.

Her question had the desired effect, which was to make her friend gasp and begin to stammer apologies as his face blushed in a shade of red almost equal to Chloe’s hair.

Chloe felt like chuckling, Gavin was so gentle and adorable. “It’s okay, Gavin, really,” She said, trying to reassure him. “Do you wanna see more?”

That made Gavin **** on his apologies. “What?” He managed to ask.

Chloe grinned at him. “Look.” She said and then began to raise the hem of her t-shirt, exposing her panty clad ass to her old friend, inch by inch.

Gavin was speechless by how forward Chloe was being, although that didn’t stop him from letting his eyes feast on her tight ass, firm and toned by her years of playing soccer. She was wearing a pair of conservative cotton black panties, but for him that never had seen a girl’s butt up close before, it was a thrill seeing his best female friend’s one.

“So,” Chloe drawled. “What do you think?”

“Well, uhn…” Gavin tripped on his words. “You have a very nice posterior, Chloe.”

“You mean my ass?” She teased him with a smirk.

“Well, yeah, let’s go with that.” Gavin scratched the back of his neck.

Chloe laughed, letting the t-shirt cover her bottom again. “I can see that you’ve liked it.” She nodded with her head to the tent sticking out from his shorts.

“But why…”

“Goodnight, Gavin,” Chloe interrupted him as she lied down on her bed and pulled the covers over her body. “Don’t forget that we’re going hiking tomorrow.”

“Yeah, I didn’t forget.” Gavin replied, still a little stunned as he got up to turn off the light.

Chloe grinned with her back turned to him, she was shivering all over with the fact that she could leave one of her oldest friends speechless with just the sight of her ass. She suddenly didn’t understand why she was shy about her body for so long.


Meanwhile, Zack had converted the couch in the living room into a bed and was lying on it trying to sleep. It wasn’t too much comfortable for sleeping, but the alternative was something that he didn’t want to consider. To sleep in the same room as Kurt was out of question.

That brought his thoughts to the two girls sleeping in the master bedroom. He couldn’t even begin to make himself understand the sudden confusion in his mind involving the two of them.

He always thought that Victoria was the one he wanted. The feelings that he thought to be lost when he saw the blonde in Kurt’s arms last night came rushing back strongly when he ate her pussy earlier in the day. But Heather, she was a **** of nature that barged her way into any place she wanted, and as it seemed, had done so with Zack’s mind.

He smiled when he remembered the two of them pranking Kurt and Victoria with the bowl of water. There was chemistry in the air, he couldn’t deny that; and there was the matter of Heather appearing to be upset when Zack decided to take a shower after the prank. He couldn’t believe, as much as he tried, that the brunette wanted him to take her to bed at that time.

Zack usually didn’t give too much thought to stereotypes, but it was hard for him to believe that the cheerleader captain, who could have any guy she wanted, was interested in a guy like him that bordered on being a geek.

In the end, Zack drifted to sleep without finding an answer to his growing problem.

What happens on their third day?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)