Sex with another version of yourself is just masturbation… right?

Previously:

Craig fled the scene of a threesome his girlfriend Lily had set up with him and Red (formerly his bully, Hank, now in a new feminine body). By trying to smash the broken Merge Necklace, he was split into two people. Chad was a combination of Craig and Hank while Claire was a combination of Craig and Lily. They found themselves in a strange green-tinged dimension. Will they find a way to escape before their growing lusts consume them?

Claire

Claire shrieked in relief, her body stiffening in climax. Her finger continued furiously flicking her clit for a few more moments until the sensation became too intense. She had tried to be more discreet, but in the moment, couldn’t control her voice. Her cries echoed through the small space.

“It’s about fuckin’ time,” Chad’s voice rang out.

Ugh, I guess there’s no trying to deny it at this point.

“Yeah, yeah. You win,” Claire called back. “Let me get decent and we can talk.”

She hastily pulled her panties and pants back up before making her way back down the aisle. Her long, thin legs wobbled, still weak. Chad was waiting for her, leaning casually against a workbench.

“Gonna gloat?” she asked.

“Why bother? I don’t get it, what were you trying to prove?”

Claire sighed dramatically and rolled her eyes. “Because I’m mad at Lily for wanting to get pounded by the closest person available. But I guess I’m no better.”

“This sex drive is fucking killer, huh?”

“I know! I just came and I’m still not satisfied.”

“Well, we could…” Chad started to say, raising his eyebrows.

“Hold your horses, Romeo. Besides, are you sure you want to be with someone who is half Lily?”

They both sat in the silence, mulling that over. Dust hung suspended in the ever-present green light.

“So,” Chad probed, “we can get down to business, I just have to convince you to forgive Lily first?”

Claire glanced over at him with an appraising eye. The heat within her had not diminished, despite her best efforts.

“It’s necessary, but not sufficient.”

“Okay. Let’s start with this. You have Lily’s memories, do you think she’d cheat on us?”

Claire pondered that. She recalled memories of watching Craig from her locker, of pining after him. She remembered Lily’s excitement to go to the beach. She had secretly been moved to tears when she found out Craig had kept the necklace she gave him.

“No, she wouldn’t.”

“So why did we break up with her?”

“Because I was sure she was going to end up dumping me anyway,” Claire mumbled, looking away. “If not with Red, then someone else, eventually.”

“I bet I know the answer, but was she ever thinking of getting with anyone better before the transformation?”

Claire considered before responding, her face pale.

“No,” she croaked, “she genuinely just loved me.”

Chad looked away and gave her a moment to sniffle and compose herself.

“Maybe she saw something in Craig that he couldn’t. Something still there,” Chad proposed.

Claire nodded absently, a small smile tugging the corners of her mouth.

“So you’re saying we should take Lily back?”

“She made a mistake, but I guess we should let her make up for it. Huh, I guess it’s a lot easier to say when I’m not Craig anymore.”

“A different perspective can change everything,” Claire mused. “There is a lot to like about him, actually. It’s pretty sweet how sentimental he is.”

“And that cute little ass of his,” Chad replied, his mind wandering.

Claire’s hair whipped across her face in a halo as her head snapped toward Chad.

“His WHAT?”

Chad looked away, his cheeks flushing crimson.

Claire rushed him, her eyes wide and sparkling with delight.

“His cute what, Chad? Say it again, I’m begging you.”

Chad couldn’t meet her eyes. He pursed his mouth and silently shook his head. When a delicate hand started stroking the front of his pants, however, his head snapped forward to see Claire’s mischievous expression.

“You can’t hold out on me now,” Claire purred. “I’ll let you do whatever you want with me, but I need the details.”

“Fine,” Chad begrudgingly agreed, “but you better not back out.”

Claire squealed, hopping up and down in delight. “So dish! Hank was really bi? Even before?”

Chad nodded, blushing.

“And he was checking out Craig’s butt?”

Another silent nod.

“That explains so much!” Claire paced, her mind racing. “Why he never left me alone. Why he was always invading my personal space.”

“I honestly don’t know how intentional that was,” Chad interjected, sheepishly rubbing the back of his head. “Hank could never admit his attraction, it wouldn’t fit the image he was projecting. He thought it made him less of a man. He was scared of his own feelings.”

“And when he felt scared, he would cover it up with anger,” Claire continued, nodding. “But now, as Red, she doesn’t have to hide anymore.”

“Nope.”

“Wait, I assumed Red went along with the threesome because she wanted to be with Lily. You’re saying she wanted Craig all along?”

“I’m not Red, but from what I know about Hank,” Chad said, shrugging. “I think we may have a real shot with her after we get out of here.”

“Could you imagine?” Claire whispered, settling back against a workbench.

“I thought we were going to get back with Lily,” Chad said, interrupting her thoughts.

“Lily. Was she right? Could a threesome have worked?”

“Maybe we’ll have a chance to find out once we get out of here. Speaking of which, it’s time to pony up on our agreement.”

Claire’s eyes narrowed.

“You’re holding me to that?” she asked.

Chad grinned and paused a beat before answering.

“Nah. I was just messing around. I don’t want to do anything with you unless you want it too.”

Claire beamed while rocking suggestively from hip to hip.

“Good answer. I see Hank in a different light now. And I guess that applies to you too.”

Chad’s eyebrows rose in surprise.

“You make a good argument,” she continued. “We haven’t found any remnant of the necklace. Why not try to join back together like this?”

Claire’s arms snaked over Chad’s shoulders to tousle his hair.

“Not because we’re horny,” Chad insisted.

“Certainly not. For science.”

“For science.”

Claire pulled Chad’s head to hers, attacking his mouth. His hands encircled her thin waist, but it was so small, his thumbs brushed each other near her navel.

He lifted her easily off the ground, earning a squeak of surprise from Claire before she wrapped her legs around him. The next few moments were occupied by passionate kissing and dry humping before Chad spun around and set Claire down on the edge of the workbench.

Claire released her grip on Chad’s waist and got to work shucking off her pants. After a few frustrating moments struggling with the buttons of his shirt, Chad gave up and ripped them apart, sending buttons flying across the room. Claire’s eyes widened as Chad gripped her shirt and with a flex of his muscular forearms, tore her buttons off as well.

Claire purred in appreciation, her panties finally off. Her eyes bulged when Chad pulled his cock free from his underwear.

“Wow, is that even going to fit?”

“Oh, I’ll make it fit,” Chad responded with bravado before noticing the look of fear on Claire’s face.

“Hey,” he said, more gently. “I forgot that neither part of you has any experience from that end of the equation. We can take it slow.”

“That’s really sweet,” Claire said with a smile. “But if you keep me waiting any longer, I’m going to explode.”

Chad admired Claire’s pussy as he lined up his cock at her entrance. They hadn’t even started and already it was twitching and oozing. He watched her opening stretch to accommodate his thick member as he pushed his way inside.

“OooooOOOH!” Claire moaned, her eyes wide in shock.

“Fuck, how are you so tight?” Chad asked as his forward progress was halted no more than halfway down his shaft.

He tried to pull out but her lips gripped him too tightly. With a grunt, Chad threw Claire’s legs over his shoulders to get more leverage and started pounding into her with quick thrusts.

“God, I’m so full.” Claire squirmed. One hand slid down between their bodies to tease her clit while Chad valiantly worked his way deeper and deeper within her.

Chad paused to catch his breath when he finally bottomed out.

“You’re so big,” Claire moaned, “I think I can feel you all the way in my chest.”

Chad beamed and resumed thrusting, battering the back of Claire’s vagina with each stroke. He thought he could see the bulge his cock was making against her trim tummy.

“Almost there,” Claire warned, her hands desperately pulling at her nipples.

Chad increased his pace, racing to meet her at the summit.

“I’m… I’m…“ Claire screamed as her body went rigid. Chad felt her somehow squeeze him even tighter and he slammed home one final time. As they were both overwhelmed with ecstasy, the very air surrounding them ignited in green flame.

In a snap, what had been split was once again made whole.