Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by shotgn shotgn

What's next?

Date

It was a few days later. I was walking into my girlfriend's work to pick her up for our date. She worked at a gym and I tried not to show up at her work too much. But she had quite the hot body, so I still couldn't help but arrive early and see her in her sports bra and those tight fitting shorts.

She came up to me giving me a hug and a kiss. "Wait for me a second I still need to get changed." She had a co-worker seated at the entrance. We had met multiple times before... She was a futa, at first I was suspicious about the fact she was here. But then she just straight up asked me for permission to fuck my girlfriend.

After that it became routine to have her ask me for permission. She was just **** only able to look at my girlfriend. With my girlfriend gone the co worker spoke up giving me her usual question. "Jack! Come on! Please~ I really want to fuck Alice, she's so hot!"

I laughed at the girl. She was more muscular wearing the same sports bra and tight shorts except with the outline of her cock threatening to grow out the bottom of the left leg. "Sorry Stacy, You know I'm going to say no. Why do you keep asking?"

She smirked back sending back a joke my way. "What? Can you blame me? Besides, never know when you might change your mind." She was right about that, I couldn't blame her for asking. Her straight forward desire made her hard to dislike and that was the basis of our... admittedly strange friendship. "Anyways, what have you got planned for your date tonight?"

I chuckled at her, accepting the new direction of conversation. "Oh yeah, we're going to a coffee place. Just a short subway ride." I could tell she was going to say more but stopped as my girlfriend returned. Now wearing a short skirt that certainly made her more attractive and drew the eye to her ass.

We left as Stacy waved us goodbye. We chatted and soon we were on the subway.

It was the evening rush so the train was packed. No one even stood to give their seat to my girlfriend. In the end we ended up packed together her chest pressing against mine. She smiled at me knowing I was enjoying the attention from her.


After getting on the packed subway car with my boyfriend I felt packed in. If I was here alone I definitely would have got off and just walked. The doors closed and we were moving. That was when the touching started. A hand rubbing my hip over the skirt. At first I thought it was my boyfriend but when they got to the bottom of my skirt and their fingers touched my skin I realized they were on the wrong side of me...The hand was still on me as I tried to grab the hand but ended up elbowing someone... Which sent of a chain of people cursing as everyone moved in response. So I had to endure as the hand started to slide back up this time lifting my skirt... To say I was uncomfortable was an understatement. My boyfriend didn't seem to notice anything was wrong. Suddenly the videos we had watched together were in my head... Damnit now I was enjoying this situation. So I smiled at him even the hand moved and was pulling the rear of my skirt up... Here I was, someone has exposed my ass fully and my boyfriend had no idea.

The thrill of it was making me wet and they now knew it as the hand was rubbing over my panties. They must have thought that meant I was fine with it and a second hand was on my ass confirming they were directly behind me. But then I stiffened. There was a cock pressing against me ass and the hands were trying to remove my underwear. The cock was quite large, too big to not be a futa. Sure enough when I turned my head and glared at her there was a futa who had decided not to push me.

The cock was put away and instead fingers tucked into my slit instead. "What's wrong?" My boyfriend said no doubt prompted by my sudden turn of head.

Feeling those fingers gently sliding in and out I was now more excited than ever, so I lied to him. "Oh nothing. Just stretching my neck." I bit the inside on my lip I really wanted to moan.

Suddenly the fingers were removed and I felt them slip a paper into my panties as my skirt was quickly pulled back down leaving me incredibly frustrated. I couldn't help but fidget as the doors opened and we were exiting the subway. After I was off the heat of the moment was gone I felt disgusted. I couldn't believe I just let them touch me and hid it from Jack. But I had enjoyed it a lot... She really know how to finger a girl slowly to leave her right on the edge...

I was in a daze for the the entire date, I even agreed to go home with him despite the fact I had to get up early to get to work tomorrow.

Except I had forgotten about the fact she had left me something. Thus I was mortified when my panties were removed as I lay on my back and saw Jack look confused and grabbed the slip of paper. "What's this?"


I brought my girlfriend back laid her down on my bed and then holding her legs together up over my shoulder. This was to remove her panties, after this she'd be able to spread her legs for me. But when her wet panties got to her knees a wet paper fell out of them. "What's this?" I said as I grabbed it.

It was the size of my thumb, all it had on it was a phone number... I looked at my girlfriend. "So? Care to explain why you have someone's phone number in your underwear."

She looked awkward but fidgeted, "I uh, I forgot about that. We were on the subway, when it was super packed and someone was feeling me up. Then they just kind of stuffed that in there just before we got up."

What? She was molested on the train and didn't say anything? Not to mention she looked like it didn't really matter to her... "You don't look like you care all that much."

She looked away from me. "At the start I was, but then I looked at you and you didn't notice a thing and it was reminding me of the show we had watched..." I certainly remembered the show, and most importantly she still had her underwear over my shoulder and I could see her wet pussy soaking my bed.

I pushed her legs to the side as I got closer to her. "You liked it that much?" My hand went her her slit, rubbing the slick surface gently.

She hummed pleased. "Hmm~ Yeah- It was so exciting. They tried to fuck me, but I managed to stop them. I feel like I can still feel their cock on my ass. And they were experts with their fingers, they knew how to make me so wet without making me cry out."

I wasn't talking about the encounter in the subway... I pushed my fingers into her pussy as I saw her eyes were closed and she ended up moaning and continuing to speak about what happened. "I got fingered the entire time on the subway, It was so hot~" Then she opened her eyes and finished kicking off her underwear and turned to me with a serious face.

"What about you? What do you think of it?"

I was... well, I had no idea what to think of it. I didn't hate it as much as I thought I would, and she really seemed to be enjoying it. While I would prefer it not to happen at all, I decided to tell her. "Well, I'm happy you enjoyed it... But its not safe to let people do that on a subway."

To that she agreed she rolled over and pulled me down for a kiss. "What do you say, instead of fucking me we watch this show again." She said with a grin, her wet pussy in my hand told me she really wanted to enjoy this new kink of hers more.

So we did.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)