Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 396 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Spartan sex

Caleb whispered to Chris as he stood, "Go look in her bag of sex toys. Grab the strap-on, and any vibrators you see. I'll let you know when to join in."

Chris grinned and nodded before turning to search Mrs. Garcia's bag.

Caleb turned to Elena Garcia and smiled at the sight of her bent over her desk, wiggling her plump ass at him. He smirked when he spotted the jeweled butt plug sparkling between her ass cheeks. He briefly wondered why all the women he knew chose that type of plug.

He stepped up behind her, deciding the answer to his question didn't really matter. Thanks to Chris's blowjob he was already hard as a bar of steel, so he slid it between her cheeks like a hotdog in a bun and ran his dick back and forth a few times.

Elena whined in a cute tone, "Go ahead, Caleb. I'm already lubed and ready. Just take my butt plug out and get your dick in me. I've been waiting for this for days."

Caleb thought back to the things Tina and Sonia told him about anal sex. He remembered Tina, an experienced butt slut, had a hard time taking him inside. Sonia had as well, but she had almost no experience.

He warned her, "He we go." Then grabbed the bottle of lube and drizzled a fresh coat on his cockhead. He drew his dick back and lined himself up, gripped the butt plug and pulled it out, before pressing his cock helmet against her gaping hole.

As his cockhead pressed against her anal ring, he repeated Tina's instructions in his head. Go slow. Nice and slow. Take your time. It won't stretch like a pussy.

He felt his cockhead pop past her anal ring, the sudden release of pressure causing him to slide in another two inches.

Elena cried out, "Oh shit!" and rose up on her tip toes for a moment. "Fuck you're huge. Give me a second Caleb."

He held himself at that depth, placing his hands on her butt cheeks and rubbing them while he reassured her, "I won't move till you tell me to Ma'am. This isn't my first time doing butt stuff."

Elena half giggled half grunted, "For the last time Caleb, when your dick is inside me, call me Elena. And thank you for going slow and giving me time to adjust."

She looked up at her class and said, "If any of you every try anal, I recommend doing it with someone that is experienced, for your first time. Though maybe not with someone as big as Caleb."

Back to Caleb, Elena said, "Okay stud. Give me some more."

A second later she moaned as Caleb slid another two inches inside her hot and tight ass. "Whoa fuck! That's fucking big. How much do you have in me?"

Caleb grinned even though she couldn't see. "I'm about a third of the way."

He bit back a laugh when she said, "Shit! That's all? I feel fucking stuffed already. Okay. Huuoooh. Okay. Um, try fucking me a little. Slow short strokes Caleb. Very slow. Put a little bit more in as you go, and add more lube too. We're going to need it."

Caleb reached for the bottle and drizzled more lube on his shaft as he pulled out a few inches. Then he slowly eased himself back inside. When he was able to get half his dick in her butt, he asked, "How you doing Elena?"

She blew out her breath and moaned, "I'm good for now. Holy crap you're big though. It feels good. Really good. Can you reach around and get to my clit though? I usually wear my butterfly harness when my wife does this, and that helps."

Caleb could, but he had a better idea. Looking up at the class he said, "Hey Angie, come help, please. I need you to play with her pussy, and lets get her top off too."

Aside from his sisters fiancée Tina, Elena was the only woman he knew with nipple piercings. The first time Caleb fucked Elena, she'd been wearing weights that caused a constant pulling sensation on her nipples.

Angie hurried to the front of the class and began unbuttoning Mrs. Garcia's blouse before getting her bra off. Caleb resumed feeding his cock up Elena's butt as soon as Angie got her fingers between Elena's legs.

Chris moved beside him and held up several different vibrators. Caleb looked at her nude muscular body and smiled at the strap-on she wore. It was much smaller than the ones his harem used. He joked, "Damn Chris. You look like a Spartan warrior woman about to go to war. I might have to get you some armor to go with your rubber dick."

The blush that spread across her face and upper chest made her look very cute. She posed and flexed her arms. In a gruff tone she asked, "Does that mean I get to peg you?"

He squinted his eyes at her and said, "Only if you want to be kicked out of my harem. Aren't you supposed to be the harem's butthole guardian?"

He was referring to Chris's job of preventing anyone from trying to have anal sex with Kathy. Chris had offered her own ass in exchange for the right to be the only one allowed to play with Kathy's butthole. So far, Chris had only used her tongue back there.

She dropped her arms and shook her head. "I'm sorry. I'll be good."

Looking back at Angie he said, "Didn't you say you wanted to try anal? We've got the lube, and it seems Chris wants an ass to plunder. That strap-on she's wearing would be easier to take than my big dick."

Angie shook her head, "No. I only want to try it if you want my ass. I've given you all my firsts, and if I ever do anal, you'll get that one too."

Elena rolled her eyes and said, "That's all very touching, but can we get back to fucking my ass. Caleb, go a bit faster and give me some more. Angie, just rub my clit. Don't bother fingering me."

Caleb grinned at Angie and gripped Elena's hips before pushing much deeper into her butt. Elena let out an unintelligible shout at the unexpected action. Caleb didn't give her a moment to adjust before he began thrusting at a moderate pace.

Elena put a hand over her mouth and whimpered. Looking down, Caleb could see her asshole stretched tight over his thick cock, the girth of the exposed shaft looking far too thick to fit in such a tiny hole. With a grunt he increased the pace a bit more, driving himself back and forth, eliciting small gasps from her as she bit her finger to keep from shouting.

Caleb smacked her ass, which caused a muffled scream to **** it's way past her fingers. He smacked it again while plunging deep up her butt.

He growled, "You need this? Huh? You need my cock filling your butt? Fuck, your ass feels amazing, Mrs. Garcia. It's so incredibly hot and tight. It's gripping my dick, begging for my cum. But I ain't gonna cum yet. Not till you beg for mercy. Chris, hand that clit vibe to Angie, then hang those vibrating weights on her nipple rings."

Caleb only slowed down enough for Chris and Angie to finish putting the toys in place before he sped back up and gave her long fast strokes. Elena gripped her desk as pleasure bombs shot up her ass every time he rammed himself deep. The shockwaves of pleasure shooting through her caused her legs to begin to shake. She stood up on her tip toes again as he drove his dick deeper and deeper.

As he continued hard and fast thrusts Elena let out a pained gasp that turn into a pleasurable moan. "Fuck me! Fuck you're so big! Fuck you're stretching my asshole! I'm so full! Turn the vibe up Angie! Turn it all the way up!" she babbled.

He looked down, only an inch or two of his thick cock left to stuff inside her. He barked, "You will take all of my cock, and you will fucking love it."

Gripping her hips, he yanked her ass back and thrust as hard as he could. Elena cried out as her anal ring met the base of his shaft. Her pussy juice splashed Angie's hand and Caleb's thighs as an orgasm exploded like a bomb up her butt.

Caleb grunted, "Okay Angie, that's enough. Chris, you ready?"

As Angie stepped back, taking the clit vibe with her, Chris cocked her head and asked, "Ready for what?"

Caleb put one arm around Elena's torso and lifted her leg with his other arm. With a grunt he lifted her off her desk, keeping his cock stuffed up her ass as deep as he could, and turned towards Chris. "We're going to fuck her like Spartans. Now grab her other leg and get that rubber dick inside her."

Quickly, Chris grabbed Elena's leg and lifted it while using her other hand to guide her rubber dick into Elena's soaked cunt. Her asshole got much tighter the more Chris fed her dick into Elena's pussy.

Caleb grinned at Chris, Elena wedged between them. "Okay. Now lift together, and let gravity pull her back down. One. Two. Go."

After about two dozen lifts Elena was reduced to whimpering through almost constant orgasms. Chris's face had a huge grin on it. "This is fucking fun. Why have we never done this before?"

Caleb laughed even as Elena put her head on Chris's shoulder and shuddered through another orgasm. "Because we've only got one butt slut at home. Tina is so gonna get it now. Hazel gets to do this first though. As the harem's butthole guardian, I'll even let you do it with her."

Chris laughed, "You better not keep calling me that. And how exactly am I guarding buttholes like this? I'm only supposed to be protecting Kat's."

Caleb grinned, "Ah, but can you imagine me and you doing this to Kat? You're protecting her ass by doing this with the other harem members. Don't get me wrong, I'd still rather be in your pussies, but damn does this feel good. Now get over here and kiss me."

Chris pressed her body against Elena's to kiss Caleb, but that **** them to stop lifting her. The kiss was awkward, but they managed. When they pulled away Caleb said, "Okay, now just hold her up and thrust when I pull out. We can saw on her insides. I did this with Kat when we double stuffed Amber's cunt."

Elena cried out again at the new sensation. Her eyes rolled back into her head as the power of the orgasms assaulting her grew. She cried out again when Chris began kissing and nibbling her neck. When Caleb's lips attacked the other side she thought she would die of a pleasure overdose.

A few more minutes went by with the two teenagers continuing to plow Elena's insides. Sweat dripped off their bodies from the exertion. They skin grew steadily slicker, their hands slipping along her skin, making it harder to keep her up in the air.

Chris panted, "Shit Caleb, are you ever going to cum? I don't know how much longer I can keep this up."

Caleb chuckled. For all Chris's strength, she didn't have a ton of stamina. Not when compared to Caleb's hucow milk enhanced muscles. "Hell, I've been fighting it for a while now. My balls are about to burst. It's so much damn fun that I didn't wanna stop. Her ass clamps down every time she cums. It feels fucking amazing. and just listen to her. I love to hear a woman whimper through an orgasm like that. Don't you?"

Chris grunted as she continued driving her fake dick into Elena. "Damn it Caleb. Yes. I love hearing that too. Now fucking cum already. I'm about to drop her."

Caleb laughed even as she drove his dick deep and released his hold on his ejaculation. As cum rocketed into Elena's ass he exclaimed, "Uh yeah! Take my cum!"

He fired off inside her several times. Elena let out a moan as the biggest orgasm so far filled her like the hot cum filling her ass. Her juices squirted against Chris's thighs and stomach even as Caleb stumbled back and hit the whiteboard behind him. He held Elena tightly as he slid down and fell to his ass, still while his dick pumped the contents of his balls deep up her butt.

Angie appeared beside him with a yoga mat so he could set her down without putting her directly on the floor. When he stood up he smiled down at Elena. His cum dribbled out of her gaping butthole.

He stood up straight and stretched. Then he caught a whiff of his sweat. Looking at Chris he said, "Come on. Let's hit the showers."

Chris was staring at the cum flowing out of Elena's butt. She licked her lips. She'd eaten Kathy's ass once, and enjoyed doing it, but it didn't have any cum in it at the time. Elena's cum stuffed butt made Chris drool. As she got down on her knees she said, "Hey Angie? Will you take Caleb to the showers and I'll meet you guys there in a bit? I worked up an appetite and that's a snacky I don't wanna waste."

Tina had mentioned enjoying anal pie, and as she licked up the tangy treat Caleb left her, Chris decided she liked it too. She could hear her classmates whispering about her. Some in astonishment, some in disgust. She didn't care. She knew what she was doing was whorish, but that was okay with her. She was a member of Caleb's harem and proud to be Caleb and Kathy's whore. She decided weeks ago that she would do any sex act they wanted.


Thank you for reading. Please leave a comment if there is something you would like to see. If you loved the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)