An issue in the hot tub

"Oh fuck Daddy. Yeah. Oh that feels so fucking good. Ah! I love your huge fucking cock! Oh fuck! It feels so much better that I dreamed!"

"If you think Daddy's cock is great you should try his tongue. I'm sorry I didn't believe you Coach. Holy fuck! Yes! Right There! Ah! Shit! Cumming!"

Caleb lost track of who was bouncing on his dick. He was sitting in the hot tub but he couldn't see a damn thing. He was literally surrounded by the nubile flesh of young women on the school softball team. When there wasn't a tit in his mouth, there was a pussy there wanting to be licked. His hands were just as occupied as his tongue. His right hand was fingering someone while his left was rubbing a clit. Aside from Holly and Shannon, he didn't know the girls on the softball team well enough to distinguish between their bodies. He could barely tell who was who when they spoke.

He got help figuring out whose tight pussy was riding his dick when another girl complained, "Come on Maggie! Squeeze your fucking pussy and make Daddy cum so I can have a turn!"

"Oh screw you Dorothy. I have to go home soon. I get Daddy's cock next."

Caleb jerked in surprise when Katie barked next to his ear, "Girls! If you can't fucking share, I'll ride his cock next and you can all do without! You're supposed to be a team! Where the hell did all the teamwork I saw yesterday go?"

A chorus of apologies answered the coach. Shannon then spoke for her teammates, "Don't be too mad at us Coach. There's only a few more weeks of school left. Some of us might never get a chance to get bred by Caleb if we don't get his cum now. Kathy said he might not be around much this summer, and if we don't get pregnant before we head off to college, we might never get one of his babies."

Kimberly the first basewoman held Caleb's hand against her clit to slow his rubbing so she could speak clearly. "Space at college daycares is limited too. But if we get bred by a Stretcher King like Caleb then we are guaranteed to get spots."

Another voice he didn't recognize said, "This might be my last chance to get bred. My family is going on vacation to visit family in Europe this summer, and we won't be back till just before fall."

Holly said, "We'll also only have a couple more team orgies with Caleb before the year ends. I am going to miss those the most. I get to stay with Caleb and will get to keep having awesome orgies with the harem, but not with all you girls. I want to make the most of the ones we have left."

Caleb didn't like how the mood was turning somber. He lifted his hips to slam into Maggie and let go of his hold on his own ejaculation. Maggie cried out in joy as his cum filled her sucking womb.

Dorothy shouted, "Fucking finally! Get out of the way Maggie!"

Caleb withdrew his hands from the pussies he was playing with and pushed the tit in his mouth out of the way so he could shout, "Enough!"

Maggie rose up a few inches to get off of him but he grabbed her hips and pulled her back down his shaft. Then he glared at the rest of her team as they backed away. "Katie is right. If you can't be a damn team, then I won't breed any of you."

They began to apologize to him but he held up a hand and growled, "Save it. I don't wanna hear it. You girls are acting like it's the end of the damn world."

In a softer tone he spoke, "I never said anything about this being your last chance to have one of my babies. Or that you'll never have another orgy after we graduate. You are all just assuming it. Kathy or Angie can have all of you flagged on the service website. All you have to do is submit a damn application and I'll make damn sure to pump a baby into you. For fucks sake, you are all best friends and yet you act like none of you will ever see any of the others again."

He patted Maggie on the ass and let her up. His cock stuck out of the water like a periscope, but he ignored both it, and the hungry looks on the girls faces. He felt a twinge of guilt when he realized not one of these girls was married, and that having babies straight out of high school would add a burden on them he wanted to avoid. "Are you all just going to go your own way after graduation and never see each other again? Because that's fucking bullshit. I honestly thought you girls cared about each other. There are fourteen of you, not counting Holly. Are none of you dating each other? Do none of you love each other? Because I thought you did. Is there not one couple among you that are going to raise my babies as a family?"

Maggie raised her hand and meekly stated, "Me and Lonnie are dating, but we aren't going to the same college. And what if we meet someone we want to be with there?"

Caleb smacked his forehead and rubbed his face. He glanced to the side of the hot tub and saw his watch sitting on the ground next to his t-shirt and socks, the only clothing he still had on when the softball team dragged him around the side of the mansion. He took it off because his mom told him he wore it at odd times. He could really use it right now to fix the situation the girls were in. But he couldn't get to it without it seeming odd, and June warned him not to draw attention to it.

He looked at Maggie and said, "So why can't you keep dating her long distance? Do you love her? Or is this just a fling before college where you will try to find someone you like better?"

Maggie looked at Lonnie with an expression of love mixed with uncertainty. Caleb correctly assumed neither one had discussed their relationship beyond graduation. Then a thought popped into his head. Maybe he could solve the issue without the watch for once. He looked around the gathered women and spotted the one he wanted, "Shannon, come here please."

Shannon got up from her seat at the far end of the hot tub and approached him. Her apple sized boobs jiggled a little as she glided through the water. He indicated his dick and said, "Hop on."

Shannon's eyes went wide and she scrambled to rise out of the water and straddled him. She let out a happy sigh as his cock slide inside her. Just before she bottomed out she grunted, "Holy shit, you really are bigger."

She started to rise and fall on his shaft but he put his hands on her hips and held her down, the suction of her womb was like gentle kisses on his cockhead. "Just stay like that for a bit Shannon. My dick was distracting everyone, and I have a couple questions for you."

Shannon had her eyes closed as she reveled in the sensation of being fully stretched on his long thick dick. "Mmmhmmm. Take your time Daddy. I'm in no hurry to go anywhere."

Caleb chuckled but said, "Everyone drop the Daddy roleplay, Okay? It was fun, but I would like to be serious for a moment. Shannon... You and Holly are best friends, I notice you always seek her out whenever we have orgies and stuff. But have you ever wanted more than that?"

Shannon blushed, which told Caleb what he wanted to know. She confirmed it when she nodded and said, "Well, yeah. I just never got up the courage to ask. I was afraid of rejection and losing my best friend. Then you claimed her for your harem, and she started dating Coach. By then, it was too late."

He looked over at Holly, then at Katie. He cocked his eyebrow at Katie, and Katie gave him a subtle nod while wearing the smirk he loved so much. Caleb ran his hands up Shannon's sides and then around to her breasts, cupping them and giving them a gentle squeeze. He began giving her very small slow thrusts, only going in and out of her pussy a half an inch or so as he said, "Okay, so why do you think it's too late for you to date her?"

Shannon felt the pressure on her womb increase before easing off only to increase again. The pleasure was exquisite, causing her to struggle to think. "Be... Because she's dating Coach Katie."

Caleb briefly held himself fully inside her for a few seconds before he continued his slow gentle thrusts. "So? Just because you go out on a date with Holly, doesn't mean she has to break up with Katie. Holly can have more than one girlfriend. Kathy's mom is girlfriends with Amanda and her mom Amber."

A tiny orgasm caused Shannon to shudder before she could respond. When she finally did her voice was confused, "But they are all in your harem. They can feel each other's love. I can't have that with Holly."

"Amber is in Kathy harem, not mine. So no, they can't all feel each others love. And that's besides the point. You love your mom right? I mean, girls usually have their first sexual relationship with their mothers. You know she loves you, but you can't feel it the way harem women can. You don't have to be in my harem to know Holly loves you too. So why can't you ask Holly out? Why can't you be her girlfriend too? Or Maggie's girlfriend? Or Dorothy's? Or Katie's?"

Katie's mind was a whirl. I thought that look Caleb gave me was him asking me if I was okay with sharing Holly, but that isn't what he wants. Then a new thought popped into her head. Could he want us all to be together? "Caleb, what are you saying? Be specific, please."

Caleb grunted as Shannon's womb sucked a little harder. He loved breeding married women because he got a thrill out of a woman's spouse being such enthusiastic cuckolds, but that isn't what he told them, "Look, I don't like the idea of creating a bunch of single moms struggling to raise my babies, not if I can do something about it. I prefer breeding women that are in stable relationships because I want my kids to grow up in happy homes. So here is the deal. You girls are all best friends, so I want the entire team to try dating each other. I know many of you are moving away once college starts, but that doesn't mean you can't still be in love. Hell, I will even help you girls get together on holidays and shit. I have more than enough cash to buy plane tickets a few times a year. I don't care if you split into couples, or threesomes, foursomes, or end up in one big poly relationship. I just want you to try. In return, I will breed every one of you. Every child any of you ever have will be mine, so long as I know you girls are together and will give my babies the happy homes I want. That includes you Katie, and you Holly. You girls have spent the entire year having a team orgy after every game, so you know you are sexually compatible. Let's see if that can turn into something more. Okay?"

Katie smirked and said, "So we'd be like our own harem."

Caleb smiled back at her. Katie got it. "Yeah. That's exactly what I would like. Chloe and Chris are in both mine and Kathy's harems, so I think it could work for you and Holly too. The question is, will it work for the rest of the team?"

Shannon laughed as shuddered through another orgasm, "Hell, thanks to the dildos and strap-ons Sonia gave us, no other guys cock will ever compare to what we can do to each other. And you give us all plenty of cum, so we don't really need boyfriends or husbands."

Katie glided through the water of the hot tub towards Caleb. When she reached him she put her hands under Shannon's ass and raised her up a few inches, only to push her back down on his dick. With the smirk he loved on her face Katie said, "I guess the only way to make this happen is to keep on fuckin' and have one big ass team orgy."

"Kathy, are you spying on Caleb again? Why don't you just go join them?" June asked.

Kathy spun around. She opened her mouth to tell June the great news. That Caleb was creating another new harem without using the watch to do it. But then she saw her mother Mary beside June and she quickly thought of an excuse. "I'm not on the softball team, and this is their time with Caleb. I get more time with him than anyone, and I really love watching, especially if no one knows I am. As Harem Queen I need to make sure Caleb is enjoying himself. If I join in, he will want to fuck me too, and I'll take his attention away from them. Besides, the daddy roleplay they were doing was hot. But Caleb put an end to it a while ago. I think it sorta lost it's meaning when a dozen girls were all calling him Daddy, especially when they are all the same age as him."

June moved forward to hug Kathy and said, "I'm glad your taking good care of our man, but we need you right now. The rest of the harem is ready for the meeting, we just need Holly and Katie. Or do you think we should leave them here?"

Kathy hugged June back, putting her head on June's boobs as she did. "Leave them. They are having fun, and I'd hate for them to have to stop."

Kathy allowed June to pull her away from the corner of the mansion just as the squeals of someone cumming floated to them from the direction of the hot tub.

Thank you for reading. Please leave a comment if there is something you would like to see. If you loved the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001