Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 46 by legolus legolus

What's next?

An End To Chaos

“But I’m perfectly willing to be mischievous. So Mary, I’m giving you the desire to play more games tonight.” As Chloe said this Mary groaned, a haze overtaking her thoughts.

God damn, I’m so turned on right now. Even more so that Chloe and Ellen actually want to do more of this tonight. And the candies seem like a great idea, wait… what will they do for me? Fuck it, EMBRACE THE CHAOS! What is Allie saying… Something soaked? Yeah, I’m soaking wet. I wonder what sex feels like as a woman. Climax? Yes, I’m close. Pervert? Yea duh, never hid that from you. Oh Sam. I like Sam. Almost as much as I love Allie. Her touch is gentle.

“Hey Mary, you okay?” Sam asked

Come here my sexy sailor. Her lips are soft. Her everything is soft. I want her to feel safe. Freya why are you pussy blocking me?
“Maybe we should get her to bed.” Sam said to Freya.

Yes, we should Sam, the bed is definitely where I want to be. Wait no SAM you don’t need to fight Freya bring Freya along we can share. Mary felt Sam tug at her hand. Okay, I’ll follow. Wait, the bed is over there. OH 15 minutes in heaven. Okay keeping with the slumber party theme. You’re on point Sam.

Sam shut the door to the closet and grabbed some clothing to tie the door shut so Freya couldn’t intervene. “Mary. Mary?” Sam started to shake her a bit, wanting to make sure she was lucid.

“No need to get rough, Sam. I thought you wanted to show how appreciative you could be.”

“Oh, I do. Trust me I do.” She moved Mary to a bench near a rack of dresses. “But Mary, you aren’t acting like yourself.” Sam sat down besides Mary. Mary grabbed her face with one hand and started to kiss Sam. After a moment Sam broke the kiss, and in a low voice said “Mary, please stop.” Mary let go of Sam’s face and just stared at her.

“Sam? Did I do something to upset you?”

“No, Mary you didn’t.” Sam grabbed one of Mary’s hands. “I’m concerned about you, and until that concern goes away I don’t want to continue this okay?” Mary nodded slowly. “Thank you. Can you tell me why you’re acting so weird?”

“I’m really horny.”

“That’s it. Really?”

“Normally I would masturbate when I got this horny and Allie wasn’t interested in sex. It would clear my mind right up. But I think part of it is being a woman is just different.” Mary was trying to take deep controlled breaths and not pant. “Sam would I be wrong, in assuming that you are concerned that you might be assaulting me if you did everything you wanted right now?”

“No, you wouldn’t be wrong. That is what I’m concerned about.”

“Well, don’t be. I want this. I want you. I don’t care about my body for that. But more than that remember I said that a game effect couldn’t be what pushed you to do something. Right now all these game effects are making me super horny. I want that orgy badly Sam. I’m holding back because I know that all of you don’t. Sam right now it isn’t a question of if I’m going to be intimate with someone tonight it is a question of whom and how many of you. Sam right now, I want you. I want you to show me that you appreciate me and for you to know that I appreciate you in return. I want my first time as a woman to be with someone who is going to make sure I feel safe and comfortable. I love Allie, I really do, but I worry that she might get carried away with me like this and do something we both would regret later. I’m both exhilarated and terrified of experimenting in this body. So please Sam help me explore it together. I want to be with you the most right now. So please, kiss me, hold me, explore my body.”

“Okay Mary.” Sam moved a hand to her face and pulled her in to kiss her, moving her other hand around Mary’s waist. Mary began to undo the clasps on her dress and slid it off her shoulders down to her waist. Then she and Sam switched as she held Sam’s face as they continued to make out and Sam began to remove her uniform jacket and blouse. They broke apart so they could finish undressing.

+5 VP Fully Naked for Master/Mistress
+3 VP See the Mistress Fully Nude

Mary looked around and pointed “There’s a couch over there I fancy that more than this hard bench or the floor.” She got up first, walking over to the couch. Kind of hope Sam is staring at my butt right now. Sam wasn’t far behind but was taking her time to check out Mary’s back and rear. Mary lay down on the couch so Sam could be on top of her. Which Sam happily obliged. Mary put an arm around Sam and pulled Sam into herself. They began to kiss again this time Mary held Sam as Sam ran her hands up and down Mary’s body.

Sam moved her hands towards Mary’s arms and started to push them above Mary’s head. Mary realized what Sam wanted to do as she held Mary’s wrists together above her head. Mary began to squirm in Sam’s grasp and broke off the kissing. “Sam… no” Mary said barely audibly. “I… I don’t want that please, Sam. I don’t want to be tied up. I want to be able to touch you.” Sam let go of Mary’s wrists putting her own hands on either side of Mary’s head, while Mary brought her arms in close against her chest. Mary tilted her face away from Sam. “I don’t want that, Sam.”

“Mary… I’m sorry. I just… last time it didn’t seem like it was a problem.”

“Last time I was a foot taller than you and had something like eighty pounds on you. Now I’m so much smaller, weaker… I don’t want to lose more control. If… if you need to tie me up, or restrain me to continue…” Mary said the next part with such sadness and disappointment, “Then I don’t want to continue.”

“Mary…” Sam sat up, still on top of Mary “I’m sorry, I don’t know. I don’t know if I can.”

“Sam, you don’t have to be sorry. But, I don’t understand. Not your hesitancy, I know where that is coming from. Rather I don’t understand, because I’ve held you, your face, your body next to mine. I’ve placed my hands on a lot of you. That wasn’t a problem. You slept in my arms. You trusted me then, trusted me to respect you and make you feel safe. Can’t you trust me now?” Mary was close to crying.

Sam just looked down at the woman. She’s right. I did feel safe, cared for, and respected. I did trust him as Mark. Mary is so much smaller… She must feel so helpless right now. “Mary, I’m sorry. I didn’t think about your feelings. It didn’t really occur to me that I’m actually stronger and bigger than you. That’s pretty much never been the case for me. But I’m still worried.”

Mary looked up at Sam. “Then guide me.”

“What?”

“Take my hands Sam and guide them. Show me where you want to be touched, how you want to be touched. I do want you to feel safe, so show me.” Mary held out her hands to Sam.

“Okay.” Sam hesitantly grabbed Mary’s wrists and brought them to her waist. “Is it okay If I hold onto your wrists like this?” Mary nodded vigorously. Sam backed up slightly so Mary could be in a half sitting position. They resumed making out and Sam guided Mary to run her hands along her side. Finally Sam guided them to her breasts, flinched slightly at the sensation but from pleasure not anxiety and relaxed. Sam let go of Mary’s hands and started to touch Mary in the same way running her hands along her sides and back slowly moving towards Mary’s breasts. Then they both began fondling one another.

+2 VP Breasts Touched (Sam) (x2 First)
+1 VP Touch Mistress's Breasts (x2 First)

Sam took one of Mary’s hands and guided it down her body and hesitated for a moment with Mary’s hand on her side. She broke the kiss. “Please be gentle. And are you okay if I do the same?”

“I will be, and yes, very much yes.” Hearing that from Mary she guided Mary’s hand to her crotch. She tightened her grip sharply for a moment when Mary’s hand rubbed against her clitoris. But she relaxed it but didn’t let go. “Please go ahead Mary. I want this.” As Mary began teasing her slit and circling her clitoris with her fingers, Sam felt safe. “Mary… can, can you finger me, just go slow.”

“Just pull my hand away if it’s uncomfortable okay.” And Mary stuck one finger gently into Sam and stroked her insides. Sam’s grip tightened like before but didn’t pull Mary away and Sam let out a squeak of pleasure, so Mary continued, and began moving her other hand grazing across Sam’s body. Sam let go of Mary’s hand and started to play with Mary’s erect nipples and leaned in to kiss her. Sam began to move her hips in pleasure and then bucked pulling Mary into her hard as she came.

+1 VP Fingered by Master to orgasm (x2 First)

“That was. That was fantastic. Now Mary, lie down. I want to taste you down there. If you’re okay with that.” Mary lay back and spread her legs. Sam put her arms around Mary’s legs and began to lick her. Mary was indeed soaked. Sam focused on the clitoris at first and then stuck her tongue inside of Mary. After a moment Sam came back up for air. “Mary, would you be okay if I got a couple toys? I saw some near the entrance that we passed. If it’s too much that’s fine I can just lick you and use my fingers but… I would really like to give you the full experience.”

Mary bit her lip. Then shook her head “Sam, sorry I don’t think I’m up for that kind of penetration. But I really liked what you were doing.” Sam smiled at her and went back down on her. “Yes, Fuck Sam.” Mary arched her back as her hips started to quiver. Mary moaned in delight as she climaxed for the first time as a woman, and then collapsed into the couch. Sam moved Mary a little so she could slip in and cuddle with her. Both of them enjoying, the post-cloital bliss and intimacy. Sam, just holding Mary in her arms.

+2 VP Cunnilingus on the Mistress (x2 First)

Please log in to view the image


A bit later Sam and Mary heard knocking at the door. “Feeling better Mary? Not so horny?”

“Much better. Still horny though. Still want to have an orgy tonight. This was nice and intimate but I feel like that will get out of hand.”

“Hey, Sam? Mary? Not trying to disturb you but we wanted to make sure you two are okay. As you’ve been in there for a while.” Laura yelled through the door.

“Be out in a minute! Just got to get dressed first.” Mary shouted.

“Okay.” Then with some humor in her voice. “Oh, by the way Sam. You tied for first with Chloe so Mary owes you a boost and we all decided that you can choose Mary’s first outfit since she came dead last.”

“I didn’t agree to that!” Mary shouted. Laura just left, laughing.

“But Mary…” Sam pouted. “I mean don’t you want to look sexy for us? I mean you want us to look sexy for you right? After all, you are still getting to dress up the other losers.”

“Fine! Why am I so weak, to a cute face.”

“Don’t worry, I’m sure we can find something that you would actually like wearing.”

“Just please don’t make it overly skimpy.”

“I can work with that.” Sam said mischievously. “Actually I can already see exactly what I want you to wear.”

Mary looked in the direction Sam was looking, “Oh. Great. I’m sure Cassandra will be pleased. Fine… but I’m not wearing the pink one.”

“Pleeease for me? You really do look good in pink. I’ll even wear a matching outfit. We can do it as a couples outfit.”

“Fine but only because I like you so much and you’re cute.” Mary kissed Sam and went over to the outfits. Where they changed then went to rejoin the others.


“Okay, sounds like they’re coming out. All bets are now finalized” Chloe said.

Mary and Sam walked out of the closet together holding hands. Mary and Sam were both wearing magical girl outfits. Mary with a pink dress showing her midriff with plenty of frills and a short skirt with thigh high stockings and boots, with her hair done up in twin tails. Sam was wearing a matching blue dress but without the midriff showing and a hair ornament on one side of her head.

Please log in to view the image

Please log in to view the image

“Chloe did I just hear you say bets? What were you betting on?” Mary inquired.

“Oh lots of things, we were bored waiting for the two of you so we made a game of it. Currently Freya and Allie are tied.”

“I see… and what exactly did you bet on?”

“Oh, duration, if you both would climax, what you would come out wearing. If you would actually let Sam dress you up. If Sam was wearing a matching outfit you know stuff like that.” Chloe explained.”

“So what things are left outstanding.” Sam asked?

Talia rattled off the list. “Who orgasmed between you two, and how many times. How far Sam would allow Mary to go with her and vice versa. If you two, would confess your feelings to each other. If you two became an official couple. Care to answer any of those for us?”

“No.” Mary made an annoyed face.

“Sure.” Sam said, “Both, once. She fingered me, I ate her out, sort of, and technically no but I guess I should change that. Mary, I really like you.” Sam kissed her. “I know I’m already in your harem and everything but would you be my girlfriend officially.”

Mary reeled for a moment. Then processed what Sam said. “Umm,” Mary glanced at Allie and found her vigorously nodding in approval. “Yes, Sam. I would love for you to be my girlfriend. You are okay with me turning into your boyfriend though right? You don’t just want me for my body do you?” Mary teased her.

“Mary! Of course I’m fine with that. Mark is attractive too. Though I don’t think you could pull off that outfit as Mark.” Everyone laughed.

“So…” Laura began.

“Laura, I haven’t removed the order from Freya to gag you if you bring that up. Also someone let Freya free the magical binding is gone.” Mary stated and as Ellen was closest and immediately removed the belt.

“You really are no fun, we all know you want it.” Laura said.

“Another time, maybe. So after my now girlfriend revealed all those personal details about us who won your little bet and what were the stakes.”

“Well.” Chloe began. “Okay so it depends, I’m going to have Mary decide as the neutral party here. Does the confession and relationship count or not because it was what would happen between you two while in there. And those technically happened out here.”

“I’m going to say yes, as those were a direct result of the events and the immediate aftermath, plus Sam did specifically call these a couples outfit, inside.”

“YES!” Allie exclaimed.

“So, I take it, Allie won then.” Mary guessed correctly. “What did she win?”

“She gets to pick your next outfit tonight and gets to sit next to you for the next game.” Chloe said.

“Well, that and I just got some VP and BP” Allie added.

+2 VP, +2000BP Allie (Reward for helping Sam overcome past trauma and start a relationship.)

“Wait really for what?” Laura asked. “You’ve been here the whole time, how did you get the VP?”

“It’s her boon,” Talia clarified. “Remember if she helps someone overcome a hurdle with Mark or in this case Mary she’s rewarded based upon the difficulty of the task. I would assume to get VP at all it has to be a pretty big deal.”

“I would call what Allie has done significant, yeah.” Sam said. “But can we not talk about it?”

“First sorry Allie. We aren’t going to be playing dress up Mary tonight. I decided I wouldn’t be a sore loser and accept the same thing as the others at the bottom having my outfit chosen, but that is where I draw the line. Now who are my victims…”

“Flora, Talia and Freya. There was a tie for 9th so they both still have to do it.” Hilde took great enjoyment in teasing her sister.

“Alright you three come with me, we’ll be right back.” Talia and Flora went along without complaint. Freya was grumbling the whole time. They came back a few minutes later. In new outfits.

Mary walked back out first, followed quickly by Talia, in a black latex cheerleaders with red trim outfit complete with black pom poms.

Please log in to view the image

“Mary, this is a little bold for me. So, don’t go expecting me to wear this all the time.” Talia then winked at Mary. Flora came out in a skintight top and pants showing midriff, with red armour pieces that matched her hair, and a prop katana to complete the warrior look.

Please log in to view the image

“Okay Mark, I had some doubts about what you would pick for me after seeing what you chose for Talia and Freya, but this is actually really cool looking. I feel like a ninja assassin or maybe a samurai. “Hey Freya, are you coming out? You know if you don't, everyone is just going to come in to see what Mary chose. Plus it’s that or go nude for the next twenty-four hours.” Flora shouted back through the closet door. Freya came out with a rather annoyed expression with her lips pursed to one side. She came out wearing long black gloves, one black legging, a dress that was split most of the way down the middle showing much of her belly and navel, and a pair of black leaf hair ornaments and a black choker with everything having bright red trim.

Please log in to view the image

“I’ll have you know Mary, that I will find a way to pay you back for such an outfit. Why did you even pick this outfit? Like I don’t understand, the others were at least interesting, this is just revealing.”

“I picked it because you’re Freya.”

“That either explains nothing or that you hate me, but since I can tell you didn’t have any malice I am going to assume you are just once again terrible at explanations.”

“The outfit is for a character named Freya, specifically a version of the goddess Freya.”

“Let me guess this is from some harem anime isn’t it.”

“I’m not sure I would call it—”

“So, yes. Mary might I remind you that I am not in your Harem.”

“Yea but you want to be!” Hilde shouted at her sister.

“Hilde! Stop that, I do not want to be added to the Harem. I don’t know what happened but that wasn’t the truth.”

“Sure, sis whatever you say.”

“So we are doing another game or are people done?” Mary asked.

“Oh don’t even pretend you aren’t up for more, you could barely think straight you horny little pervert.” Talia said. Everyone glanced at her in surprise. “What? Oh right you are all not used to me being more open about this stuff. Look, I want to make this clear. Still a virgin, here and even now, before the show I would have told anyone that asked ‘I am going to wait until marriage still.’ But I am going to be with Mark or Mary, he/she is going to marry me. I’m not getting eliminated, that's for sure. So if I have to accept that Mary is just going to have to take responsibility later, fine. Still not going to just jump to sex though. Sorry Mary.”

“Take your time Talia a lot has just changed for you. We can talk about that more tomorrow. So what is the next game, did you guys decide?”

“Well we found a board game, it’s on the table. Want to take a look?” Aubrey said.

Mary went over to the table and read the name of the game. It was a game she had heard of before and there was absolutely no way they were playing something created by former staff of Harem Hotel, especially those two.. “Freya, would you get the door to the balcony?” Mary picked up the game, walked out the door Freya was holding open and chucked it as far as she could watching it disappear in thin air.”

“Umm so I take that as a no then.” Laura chuckled.

“Yea no, if you ever see a game made by those people, do not play it.” Mary explained.

“I’m glad that Miss Mary can see some sense.” Freya chuckled. “I did try telling them we shouldn’t play that to the point Hilde and I were sitting out if they did. But they were like ‘what's the worst that can happen, Mary would love this.’”

“Okay, well we could play truth or dare. Where you have to respond, or do the dare.” Laura suggested.

“No. Because you are just going to dare people to have sex the entire time.” Mary said, staring directly at Laura.

“I would not… well not the entire time at least.” Laura grumbled.

“Where did you find the board game? I didn’t notice a game closet or anything.” Mary said. Multiple people pointed over to the far side of the room. “Okay this definitely wasn’t here before. Cassandra must have added it. Let’s see.” Mary started going through the game cabinet muttering. “Sex game, sex game… some more involved games, really no non-sex related party games. Okay, that is in line with what I expect of this show.”

Mary turned back to the group “Okay I have an idea. It would involve buying something from Chloe though, which I already checked I can’t buy. She can only sell to other contestants, not me. Probably to stop me from just buying a bunch of candies and not using them. So is anyone willing to front the cost?” Mary got multiple hands indicating they would help pay. “Okay good. So I’m thinking we, go with, ‘would you rather’ instead of truth or dare”.

“Booooo…” Laura cupped her hands over her mouth to complain.

“Okay I guess we could just watch a movie if Laura really thinks this is so boring that even with the twist I was going to add. Oh well alright let’s move to the couch everyone.”

“Okay. Okay. I’m sorry for interrupting.”

“So I thought of two things to add. The first, is the choice you pick happens. So would you rather have big tits or a big ass. You will have one or the other for at most the next twenty-four hours, you can put a shorter time limit on something if you want. Alternatively, you can take the forfeit which is the second thing. If you hate both options you can take one candy from the assortment of random candies we will be buying.”

“Oh well this is great!” Laura exclaimed.

“And that,” Mary said pointing at Laura “is why we will be in teams, both people will have to answer the same question but each person selects one half of the would you rather. So we don’t have something like Laura asking would you rather eat me out or have me eat you out. Also if the majority of us think that both parts of a question is egregious to the point that it was essentially forcing a forfeit then the question givers must take a candy. So please show some restraint.”

“I call a team with Mary,” Allie exclaimed.

“We will be drawing lots for teams, Allie. Because I imagine most people want to be on a team with me.” Mary saw Allie’s disappointment but acceptance at her words. So Mary set up lots for people to draw, with the teams coming out as:

Team 1: Freya, Laura

Team 2: Chloe, Flora

Team 3: Ellen, Allie

Team 4: Merida, Aubrey

Team 5: Sam, Talia

Team 6: Mary, Hilde

Before starting, people went to the kitchen to get more snacks and drinks. Hilde hung back to talk to Mary. “Hey, Mary, can I talk to you for a sec? Like privately.”

“Sure.” while the others were in the kitchen Mary tried to move so they would have a bit more privacy. “What’s up?”

“It’s about Freya.”

“Hilde I’m not going to add her to my harem and I don’t think you really want that either it is just the effect of the game.”

“Really? Are you forgetting your own rules? Because right now I really want to help you figure out a way to make her yours and I’m actually willing to help. Which according to your rules I couldn’t do if I would regret it later and I couldn’t do it if Freya would be unhappy with me because of it.”

“I…” Mary thought for a moment. That… That is a really good point. “Still unless she wants it herself, asks for it, I won’t do it.”

“Fine, so we just have to convince her then.”

“Hilde…” Mary hissed.

“Mary, listen to me. Freya is obsessed with helping Astrid. Not in a healthy way either. She feels like it’s her fault for Astrid being like she is. She is wrong, but that doesn’t matter. This has led her to not really have hobbies or interests. My sisters and I actively helped her for a long time too. But we’ve worked for Cassandra for hundreds of seasons. We might have actually broken a thousand I don’t know for sure. In all that time we have made almost no progress after an initial bit. Only Freya is truly trying at this point Petra is humoring her and the rest of us don’t believe that it’s possible or that it would take essentially a miracle. Maja isn’t quite as strong as Cassandra was when Cassandra started as a host but once she isn’t your tailor she is probably going to be her own host. She understands the magic involved, Maja thinks that the only hope Astrid has is for her to become a producer, and that is a long shot at best. Freya likes you; That should be evident from the game. She hasn’t really taken an interest in any of the other Masters or Mistresses that have come by before. She just can’t admit it to herself because if she does, if she tries to be with you, she knows she can’t have a foot out the door looking for ways to help Astrid. So seriously think about it.”

“Hilde, I’ll… I’ll think about it. But I still won’t do it without her permission.”

“Okay. Looks like everyone is settling in for the game. So, shall we teammate?” And they walked over to join the others.

“Okay everyone, by their teammate?” Mary asked. “Good now, I’m going to offer the same prize as last time to the team that everyone subconsciously agrees was the most fun in this competition.”

“Now could we get this from your shop Chloe?”

Assorted Candy Bowl: A bowl of surplus candy supply, mixed together for a surprise each candy is wrapped so you don’t know what you are getting until you open it. Must consume candy after unwrapping it. (12 pieces) (2000 BP)

“I’m happy to pay for the candy bowl if I get the leftovers, since I just got a big payday,” Allie said.

-2000BP Allie
+1000BP Chloe

“Now we’re going to do this spin the bottle style to not have anyone picked on all night. I’ll start and then whoever was asked a question gets to spin next.”

“Okay looks like we are asking Ellen and Allie.” Mary and Hilde whispered back and forth for a moment.

Mary and Hilde said “Okay we are going with:”

Would you Rather: Have to wear a collar and leash where you have to follow around the person holding the leash or emit a scent that causes people to be slightly more willing to act on subconscious desires.

“I know that for sure.” Ellen said “I take the Collar and Leash.” And a nice black collar appeared on her neck with a leash attached.

“Well I think I’ll take the scent.” Allie said she also reached out to take Ellen’s leash, and giggled. Mary followed shortly after realizing what she found funny.

“You two want to explain?” Freya inquired.

“Allie’s got wolf ears and a tail, but has Ellen on a leash. The reverse of walking the dog kind of.” Mary explained.

"Aye, see now, Mary's patter is awfy, it's infectious, and Allie's picked up a wee bit o' it." Merida complained.

Ellen went ahead and spun the bottle, “Okay Sam, Talia looks like we got you, give us a second.” Allie and Ellen went back and forth and came up with

Would you rather: become more aroused anytime someone compliments you or have your breasts be the same size as Ellen’s

“The compliments” Both Talia and Sam said without hesitation and in unison.

“How could you even think we would take that Ellen. I bet you were hoping we would and then increase your cup size a few more times so we would keep getting bigger weren’t you” Talia accused her.

“So what?”

“So, I don’t want you to give me Q-Cups on my date night tomorrow.”

“Oh sorry.” Ellen said with sarcasm. “Then again, I love how you’ve embraced the goth look Talia, it is so fetching. Your makeup is really nice and striking. I just have to get a dress like that, maybe you can help me put together a goth costume so we can match, since I can see you have a great sense of style. Must be because you are so smart.” Talia squirmed as she spoke.

“Okay I think we might have chosen poorly, Sam.”

“It’s fine I can handle this. Allie, you might want to control your teammate. Or I might just tie your hands behind your back with her leash, and bind it magically. Now let’s see who’s up.” Sam spun landing on Laura and Freya.

Would you rather: Have to respond to any question asked with the truth or randomly blurt out your innermost thoughts uncontrollably.

“Wow I’m not sure I would want either of those.” Laura began “Freya do you have any thoughts I don’t know myself I think I would take a forfeit but open to opinions”

“I would definitely not take the second choice. I am already compelled to speak the truth to Mary. At least if she demands it. So I have some experience navigating that. I’ll take the first choice myself. But I think the forfeit holds merit Laura.”

Talia spoke up, “Darn and here I was hoping that maybe we could get to know each other better later Laura.” She teased the amazon.

“Oh, you’re not fooling me. You’re smart sure but we aren’t roommates after tonight and you have your date tomorrow so no time to chat. I’m taking the forfeit.” Laura reached into the bowl picking out a candy, and unwrapped it, seeing a half black and half white gummy bear. “Bottoms up” Nothing appeared to have happened.

“Any clue what it does, Laura?” Flora asked her.

“I want to take Mary into that closet just like Sam did. Crap. I didn’t mean to say that.”

“Is that what you really want, Laura?” Mary inquired, seeming to not be totally opposed to the idea.

“What I really want to do is strip Talia out of that dress. Okay well I have an idea of what’s going on now. Could you not ask me questions please.”

“That’s fine, I want to ask my sister something instead.” Hilde began.

“Hilde, don’t please.” Mary began.

“Mary… fine I’ll find her tomorrow and ask her, maybe we can have that talk after all sister.”

Laura went ahead and spun the bottle, landing on Merida and Aubrey

“Well for my half I know what I want. You Freya?” Freya took a moment to consider.

Would you rather: Gain a strong desire to give oral pleasure to others or Gain a temporary TF for one of your paths.

“Okay Um… Isn’t this a bit much?” Aubrey said to the group. “Like knowing Laura, a strong desire is a very strong desire. And temporary TF is kind of a lot.”

“I don’t agree, Aubrey.” Mary contradicted her. “I mean not about the Laura thing, you are probably right about that but the other one I actually see as a positive.”

“Well of course you do Mary, that turns you on.” Aubrey complained.

“That isn’t what Mary means.” Talia said, coming to Mary’s defense. “Think of it like this: you get a preview at a possible permanent TF in the future if it is something you really like and can embrace. The audience will likely vote for it, if it comes up later. Alternatively if we need to spend Mark’s BP on something and you know you like it that is an easy way to spend it down without worry.

“Oh… that’s really clever. Thank you Talia. You give really good clear advice.”

“Not a problem but maybe don’t compliment me so much tonight and tomorrow.”

“Sorry, In that case I’ll take the temporary TF, what about you Merida?”

Aye, reckon I'll dae the same. Cheers, Freya. Assume it was what Talia was sayin' that made ye pick that option, eh?

“Exactly correct, Lady Merida.”

The Lost Lamb: This little lamb is lost and confused and needs to be guided. Aubrey will now seek out Mary’s guidance when she is struggling on how to do something and Mary will do her best to guide her towards the path Mary believes best, with Aubrey trying to follow that guidance. [Mary Has a Little Lamb (Hitsujimusume)]

Quiver of Fate: Princess Merida is all about seizing her own fate. Now Merida will be able to help others seize theirs. She now has an invisible quiver and bow that only she can see, she receives a quiver with three arrows in it that will help the person struck with it seize a fate Merida desires for them.

Och well now, that's interestin'," Merida said, looking at something in her hands.

Then Merida went ahead and spun to keep the game flowing. She landed back on Mary and Hilde.

“Oh I know just the thing, come here Merida.” Aubrey leaned over and whispered conspiratorially into Merida's ear.

"Och, that's pure brilliant, aye, reckon I'll agree to that. Ye get a good result no matter what, far as I can see."

“Oh no…” Mary did not like that tone.

Would you rather: Feel a greater desire to do what you really want every time you refuse to be honest about it, or tell each other person here the one truth that you feel you're too afraid to tell them.

“Oh, well that’s easy for me. Never had an issue being honest about what I want” Hilde said, “So I’ll take the first one.”

“This feels targeted at me…” Mary complained.

"'Cause it is. Ye really need tae be mair open an' honest aboot what ye want, that's why we didnae word it as somethin' ye dinnae want tae tell us, but are too feart tae tell us. Elseways, when ye just refuse tae be honest aboot what ye truly fancy, ye'll want it mair. So either take what ye want or get shoved intae it." Merida said.

“I’m really tempted to eat a candy…”

“BOOO!” Everyone but Freya and Hilde said

“Seriously? All of you, want me to pick one of these?”

“Frankly I want to know what you would be too afraid to tell me, after all we’ve been through.” Allie said.

Mary thought about each of the options. What would I likely tell them… Lets see, fine, fine, fine, Oh, yeah not doing that one for sure. Absolutely not. The other is really prone to ****. They could just ask me a bunch of stuff to push me into acting…

“Yeah, I’m eating a candy. I don’t feel comfortable with the first and I feel like multiple people here” Mary stared at Laura, then Merida, then Aubrey. “Would start asking me a bunch of sexual questions on repeat just to push me into doing something or admitting that I want something.”

“You said multiple people but why does it feel like you just mean me?” Laura complained.

“Why would you think that, Laura?” Mary replied tersely.

“Oh, because I think it would be hot to see you strip, for me. Okay seriously please don’t ask me questions.”

Mary went ahead and grabbed a candy, “Interesting this looks like a pink starburst.” Mary began chewing and felt like it was leaving something behind in her mouth.

“Well that tasted great, pink starburst are the best ones.” Everyone else felt a slight tingle of pleasure wash over them at the sound of Mary talking to them. “I wonder what it does though. Something to do with my mouth… it feels different but… Hmmm…” Mary turned to Sam next to her and asked. “Hey Sam, could I try kissing you? I want to see if I can figure out what this does, and it has something to do with my mouth. I can tell that much.” Sam felt a much greater wave of pleasure wash over her.

“I don’t mind kissing you at all, but I think I know what it does.” She leaned over and they kissed.

“So what does it do then?” Sam squeezed her needs together at the question.

“Well… actually you know what, this is going to be funny and I trust you not to target me with it. Well too much anyway. It seems that when you are talking to us it is pleasurable the more directly to us the better it feels, also the more you do it. Since I felt something small when you said something to the group as a whole but nothing when you were just musing to yourself.”

“Thank you, Sam. Maybe I should just keep talking to you as a reward. Would you like that? Because I think this is going to be a lot of fun.” Sam let out a quiet moan of pleasure.

“Well Merida… you wanted me to tell you what I really wanted right. Just to let it all out… right? Come now be honest with me, you just want me to continue talking to you until you’re a quivering puddle on the floor here right?”

"Mary!" Merida felt the pleasure but it wasn’t overwhelming. "Please dinnae, am sorry, richt?"

“I forgive you. Now let’s see who Hilde and I get to ask next.” Hilde spun the bottle this time landing on Chloe and Flora. Mary and Hilde whispered between themselves, which might have been a mistake on Mary’s part as Hilde had a hard time thinking clearly.

Would you rather: Feel the desire to do what Laura tells you to do or Think being in Mary’s harem is the greatest thing to ever happen to you.

“Hilde, that is not what we had discussed!” Mary shouted at her teammate.

“Oh, I know this is much better.” Mary pursed her lips and glared at her response.

“Mary,” Chloe cut in, “I mean… I’ll say it is actually up there for me, already. Though I’ll have to apologize that you aren’t the reason for that feeling.” Chloe looked over at Aubrey, who blushed at Chloe’s response. “So, I’m going to actually go with that one, since it will only be for a day. Wow, I hadn’t considered it would feel better than sex but damn, it does. Also Aubrey don’t worry you’re still half the reason I feel this way.”

“Hey Flora, maybe you would be up for some fun. I know you liked what you saw with me and Sam. Care for some more?” Laura really wanted Flora, to want, to do, as she said.

“Laura, I mean maybe, but I’m taking the forfeit here.”

“Darn.”

Flora reached in and grabbed a candy, finding a rolled up rope of white sticky taffy, when she unwrapped it. “Okay well I know exactly what these do. Mary, you should probably not take this one. Because I really want you to make me pregnant right now. I’m glad you don’t have a cock right now because if you did I might just jump you now to satisfy this craving.”

Aubrey was thinking, now how can I get Mark to have one of those I bet it would make him want to get us pregnant.

“Hey do we want to end it here?” Freya asked “Before things get more out of hand.”

“That’s not fair Chloe and I haven’t gotten to ask a question of anyone yet.” Flora complained. “And you are just afraid that someone is going to start questioning you about things you would rather keep private, aren’t you?”

“Yes I am.” Freya replied immediately.

“Well I want to continue.” Flora said as she spun the bottle. Landing on Freya and Laura again.

Getting a groan from Freya. “Fine, ask your question but seriously, how long are we going to go for? Could we please just end it after this.”

“Okay how is everyone else feeling?” Mary asked. “Show of hands, who would like to end after this next question?” A few people raised their hands.

“Okay, this isn’t a democracy, if that many people want to finish then we’ll be done. Maybe play some normal board games or watch a movie and then turn in.

“Thank you Miss.”

“Well I know what I’m asking, what about you Chloe?”

“Hmm, give me a moment… Can you tell me what yours is, Flora?” Flora whispered it into her ear. “Oh, Fair enough. I got mine so…”

Would you rather: have to be within five feet of another person here for the next twenty-four hours or hear any thoughts about you the rest of us have for the next twenty-four hours.

“I hate you both.” Freya said “I’d rather be within five feet of someone. Not taking a forfeit.”

“I think I’ll go with the five feet too.” Laura said. “Wouldn’t mind the company.”

“Okay so movie? It seems like people are kind of tired of games.”

“Oh, we should totally watch another of those anime films. That we watched on our date.” Sam excitedly suggested.

“Anime films? I mean not really into anime.” Laura said.

“Trust me what you’re thinking of Laura is not what these are.” Sam countered, “They are FANTASTIC. Well at least the one we watched, I wasn’t into anime either but this was good.”

“Okay, okay. Fine. I’ll watch.”

“Okay we’ll watch Princess Mononoke, then. It’s one of the earlier ones but also I think it would appeal to more people here.” Mary said.

So they settled in to watch the film with: Chloe and Aubrey cuddling together; Sam and Allie clinging to either side of Mary; Talia went to sit beside Laura and Freya. The rest just found an open spot on the couch.

As the movie ended. Laura spoke up “Okay, that was much better than I expected. Not the greatest thing of all time, but I enjoyed it.”

Sam was not having it, “Okay sure not the greatest thing of all time is fine I liked Howl’s Moving Castle more, so fair but that was fantastic!” Sam then in a deadpan voice imitating Laura “‘I enjoyed it’, come it was great.” Sam and Laura kept bickering over the film’s quality as they all got ready for bed, after a long night and drifted off to sleep.


“Ah my dear viewers, doesn’t that just warm your heart… and your loins? Such fun times and juicy secrets, now I promised to give some rewards to the ladies based upon your votes.” Cassandra said sitting on the stage in the Dragon’s Lair. “Now I have four polls open up for the events tonight starting from the moment Mary got back to the suite until they went to bed. They are: Who was the most entertaining? Who did you like best during their Two Truths and a Lie? Which Team did you like best in Would you rather? Finally who was the greatest agent of chaos tonight. The polls will be open for a week or until we reach the first challenge, whichever is first. In addition we thought having a midweek update would be nice so if you want to know how much VP or BP a character or forgot what all has changed look for the update coming soon. I was also asked by my producer… To provide a list of magical effects that are in place from the sleepover. Thanks, and don’t forget to tune in next time.”

Most Entertaining: https://strawpoll.com/XmZRQ1r0wgd
Two Truths and a Lie: https://strawpoll.com/GeZARDY6EyV
Would You Rather: https://strawpoll.com/X3nkPDG8PgE
Agent of Chaos: https://strawpoll.com/XOgOVrxjQn3

Authors note: Polls will be open until 5/18/2025 or until I reach the first challenge if that happens first

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)