Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 40 by Gamma Boötis Gamma Boötis

While you’re dancing with Louise―

Victoria makes a discovery

Meanwhile Victoria walks around the party, her legs still trembling a little from the intense gangbang she experienced with you and the frat bros just a half hour before. As she mingles and chatted with other partygoers, she suddenly feels a strange sensation between her legs.

The thick, viscous cum that you had so clandestinely deposited deep inside her pussy during the raunchy group sex session begins to uncoagulate and liquefy, prostate fluid breaking down the proteins in the semen, transforming it from a thick, sticky, honey-like consistency to a much more watery texture. The change in consistency causes the copious amounts of semen to start dripping and leaking out of her thoroughly fucked pussy.

At first, Victoria thinks it might just be her own arousal leaking out. But as more and more of the watery cum drips down, completely soaking her panties and then running down the inside of her thighs and legs in rivulets to drip onto the floor, she realizes something is terribly wrong. She excuses herself from the party and hurries to the bathroom.

In the privacy of the bathroom, Victoria hikes up her dress and reaches between her legs. She feels the wet, slippery cum coating her inner thighs and running down her legs. When she touches her pussy, she finds it overflowing with your watery, liquefied semen. She is shocked to discover that someone has cum inside her, despite her insistence on condoms, her mouth hanging agape in horror.

Victoria sits down on the toilet and spreads her legs wide. She reaches into her red, swollen pussy with two fingers, trying to scoop out as much of your cum as she can. She brings her fingers to her nose and sniffs, confirming that it is definitely semen and not just her own juices. The smell is heavy and pungent, a testament to the quality of your load.

She furiously fingers herself while fighting back tears, trying to expel as much of your cum as possible. It leaks out of her in a steady stream, pooling in the toilet bowl below. Victoria watches in a mix of fascination and dismay as your semen drips and dribbles from her used pussy. The sight of it makes her feel dirty and violated, less worried about being impregnated then about venereal diseases and the betrayal.

She sniffs, holding back tears. Looking at the quantity of the semen that continues to steadily drip out of her cooch, her mind wanders back to the thought of how your orgasms filled those condoms to the point of bursting with virile seed in front of her eyes and in her mouth. Maybe, she thinks, maybe one of them had burst. By accident, of course, she assumes. After all, you're Louise's little brother, there's no chance in her mind that you go so far as to hurt her by not wearing a condom after she had explicitly asked you to. She had seen you put the last rubber on yourself! It had to have been an accident! It just had to be!

Once she has gotten out as much of your semen as she can with fingers alone, Victoria grabs a wad of toilet paper and starts wiping up the cum that has dripped down her legs and thighs. The tissue quickly becomes soggy and saturated, and she has to use several handfuls to get herself relatively clean. She drops the cum-soaked toilet paper into the toilet bowl, where it lands with a wet plop.

Victoria flushes the toilet, watching as the evidence of your massive load swirls away. She takes a deep breath, trying to compose herself before leaving the bathroom stall. She washes her hands thoroughly at the sink, splashing cold water on her face to try to reduce the redness in her face from holding back tears. Then she squares her shoulders and exits the bathroom, determined to put on a brave face and return to the party.

Victoria returns to the party, your cum starting to leak out of her pussy and drooling down her legs anew. She scans the party, looking for Andrew. When she spots him talking with some friends, she hurries over and pulls him aside.

"Andrew, can we please go somewhere private? I really need to talk to you. Right now," she says, her voice trembling slightly. Andrew takes one look at her distressed expression and nods, leading her away from the party.

They find an empty bedroom upstairs and slip inside, Victoria closing and locking the door behind them. She turns to face Andrew, her cheeks flushed and her eyes still a little red from fighting back tears.

"Someone came inside me," she blurts out, her voice trembling. "I was having fun with some boys downstairs earlier. I― I didn't realize until just now, when it started leaking out of me."

Andrew's expression darkens with anger and concern. "What? Who?" he demands, his hands clenching into fists at his sides.

Victoria shakes her head. "I don't know. One of the frat guys, I think. I― I was so caught up in the moment, I didn't even notice until afterwards," she says, very conveniently leaving you out of the story.

Andrew pulls her into his arms, hugging her tightly. "Fuck, Vic, I'm so sorry," he murmurs into her hair. "That shouldn't have happened. You told them to wear condoms, right?"

Victoria nods against his chest. "Yes, of course. But,” she hiccups, fighting back the tears. “But maybe one of them got too excited and forgot, or the condom broke, or―" She trails off, shuddering at the memory of cum leaking out of her.

She looks up at Andrew pleadingly, her blue eyes wide and ****. "Please," she whispers. "Please take me raw, right now. Get all of the stuff out of me and fill me up with yours instead. I need you to replace it, Andrew. I need you to make me yours again."

Andrew hesitates for a moment. But the sight of her looking so fragile and needy is too much for him to resist. He crushes his mouth against hers in a passionate kiss, his hands roaming over her body possessively.

They tumble onto the bed together, Victoria spreading her legs eagerly for her boyfriend. Andrew yanks her dress up and over her head in one practiced, fluid motion and positions himself between her thighs, his already hardening cock jutting out from his body. Meanwhile your cum is still leaking out of her slit in a slow trickle. He looks down at Victoria's pussy and feels a surge of possessive jealousy. He's determined to erase any trace of this mysterious interloper from her body.

He thrusts into her in one smooth motion, his cock sliding easily into her wet and slippery pussy. Victoria moans loudly in response, wrapping her legs around his waist to pull him deeper.

He starts fucking her hard and fast, his glans acting like a cum scoop as it pushes into her. With each thrust, he forces more and more of your semen out of her pussy, until it's dripping down her ass and pooling on the sheets beneath them.

Victoria’s constant moaning and whining urges him on, begging him to fuck her harder, to fill her up with his cum.

"Yes, Andrew, yes!" She gasps, her nails digging into his back. "Please! Fill me up, ~ahh~ make me yours, ~gah~ only yours!"

Andrew grunts and obliges, slamming his hips against hers with enough **** to shake the bed.

Some of your semen is also **** deeper into Victoria's reproductive tract, pushed down against her cervix and even into her womb by the insistent pounding of Andrew's cock. Victoria can feel it, the distinct sensation of your thick, viscous cum that hasn’t been watered down yet being shoved inside her most intimate places by her boyfriend's pistoning hips.

Finally, with a low groan, Andrew buries himself to the hilt inside Victoria’s sodden folds and starts cumming. His cock throbs and pulses as he pumps her full of his hot, sticky semen, filling her again.

Victoria whimpers with pleasure, feeling his cum mixing with yours inside her stretched and swollen pussy.

After a moment, Andrew pulls out, his softening cock coated in a sticky mixture of his cum and yours. He looks down at Victoria's pussy, watching as their combined fluids leak out of her in thick, creamy dribbles. He brushes a strand of hair away from her face tenderly. "I'll get you a Plan B pill in the morning just in case," he promises. "And we can go to the student clinic to get tested, just to be safe."

Victoria nods, smiling up at him gratefully. "Thank you, I love you," she whispers, pulling him down into another deep kiss. "Thank you for making me yours again."

OOC: As always feel free to drop questions, comments, or suggestions for the next chapter as a comment!

Andrew makes an effort―

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)