My turn to dare

Casey, now also topless, bounced with anticipation, causing her beautiful tits to jiggle enticingly. She thought briefly about whom to choose, then handed the game back to me with a playful grin, asking, "Truth or dare?" I decided on "dare" to keep the game at an intense level.

Casey thought for a moment, then smiled mischievously. "Alright, John, here's your dare: blindfold yourself with your shirt so you can't see. Then, sit upright, and each of us will come to you in turn, without saying a word. You'll have five seconds to touch us and identify who it is. If you don't get all six right, you’ll have to remove your swim trunks later, when we have more privacy. While it's socially acceptable for us to be topless, your trunks are our insurance for later when the lake clears out." She gave me a cheeky smile as she finished explaining the rules.

The others seemed thrilled with this idea. Carole said, "Finally, we get to enjoy some eye candy too!" Anna added with a grin, "I've been waiting for this moment." We began, and I took off my shirt, flexing my muscles briefly as Erica whistled playfully. Alyssia commented with a flirtatious tone, "Wow, John, those abs are impressive! And those pecs... rawr!" I chuckled, striking a brief pose before blindfolding myself with my shirt and sitting upright, ready for the game to begin.

I could hear the first girl step in front of me. As I counted down from five out loud, my hands reached out to explore. I first encountered a soft, delicate stomach with very little fat. I felt the faint outline of abs, then moved my hands upwards to the breasts and felt a bikini top, which ruled out Alyssia, Carole, and Casey. Her breasts were firm and medium-sized, supported by toned chest muscles. It became clear, and as the five seconds ended, I called out, "Erica!" She giggled and confirmed, "Well done, that’s right."

Next was Anna. As my hands explored, I felt her small but firm breasts through the bikini top and her long, slender legs. Her skin was warm and smooth, with a slight firmness, but not the kind associated with a highly athletic build. I could tell it was Anna by the delicate feel of her body. I smiled and confidently said, "Anna," and she confirmed it with a soft laugh.

Then came Sarah. My hands encountered a flat, smooth stomach with a very narrow waist. Her skin was incredibly soft, almost like silk, and as I moved my hands upwards, I felt her small, delicate breasts under a bikini. The texture of her skin and the petite size of her frame were unmistakable. I declared, "Sarah," and she shyly whispered, "Yes."

Next was Carole, and this one was unmistakable. My hands were greeted by her large, bare breasts, which I kneaded for the entire five seconds, enjoying their fullness. Even though Alyssia and Casey were also topless, I knew these had to be Carole's—they felt even bigger than Casey's, which I was intimately familiar with. "Carole, I don’t even need to feel the rest of your gorgeous body," I said, feeling certain, and was met with an affirmative response.

Alyssia followed, and here I made my first mistake. Her and Casey’s breasts felt almost identical, with a similar size and firmness. Despite trying to feel her face to distinguish her, the time ran out too quickly. I guessed, "Casey," but was met with laughter and a cheerful, "Wrong!" from the girls, as Alyssia revealed herself with a smile.

The game ended, and I removed my blindfold, facing the group with a smile. Since I didn't get all the guesses correct, the girls now had the right to have me remove my swim trunks later, once the other people around the lake had left. Casey, very pleased with the outcome of her dare, giggled happily, "We can't wait to see you completely naked."