Carole's turn!

With Carole having just completed her own dare, she was now in charge of choosing her victim for the next round. She quickly decided on Casey, already having a playful idea in mind. Eagerly anticipating the game’s continuation and hoping that she would take dare, Carole smiled as she asked Casey if she wants to choose truth or dare. True to her adventurous spirit, Casey confidently chose dare.

Carole didn’t waste a moment. "I've always been struck by how similar you and Alyssia look," she began, a mischievous glint in her eye. "But I think we should put that to the ultimate test. Casey, I dare you to crawl over to Alyssia and use your mouth to remove her bikini top. Then, I want you to remove your own top and kneel beside her, both of you facing us, so we can all compare."

An excited and satisfied murmur ran through the group. Casey, always game for a challenge, grinned widely. She did not hesitate and began crawling toward Alyssia with an air of confidence, her movements slow and deliberate. As she moved, her large breasts swayed enticingly within her bikini top, each motion accentuating their fullness. Her ample butt, framed perfectly by her bikini bottoms, swayed sensuously with every step, drawing the eyes of everyone present. Her gaze was locked on Alyssia, filled with playful determination and a hint of mischief, clearly enjoying the attention and adding a tantalizing allure to her approach.

As Casey reached Alyssia, she began the task with careful precision. She leaned in close, using her teeth to gently tug at the knots and strings of Alyssia's bikini top. Her lips brushed against Alyssia’s skin as she worked, her teeth expertly loosening the fabric. The atmosphere was thick with tension and lust as Casey skillfully untied the knots, letting the bikini top fall away, revealing Alyssia’s full, beautiful breasts.

Alyssia's boobs were truly a sight to behold; large and round with a slight tan line that highlighted their full, voluptuous shape even more. They were firm yet soft, with a perfect teardrop shape that defied gravity. Her nipples were erect, a rosy hue contrasting beautifully with her tanned skin. The entire group watched in awe, clearly appreciating the view.

Once Alyssia was topless, Casey moved to her own top. She removed it in one fluid motion, revealing her equally impressive chest. Nadine's breasts were slightly more conical, with a firmness that spoke of her youthfulness. Her skin was evenly tanned, her nipples a delicate shade of pink, standing out against her sun-kissed skin.

With both girls now topless, Casey knelt beside Alyssia, both facing the group. Carole, visibly excited, then suggested, "Since they both look so similar, maybe John could give us a detailed comparison. He should be the judge." The other girls nodded in agreement, their eyes gleaming with anticipation.

I agreed, feeling the eyes of all the girls on me as I prepared to describe what made each of these two beauties unique. "Well," I began, letting my gaze wander over the two beautiful women before me, "let's start with their similarities. Both have this beautiful, sun-kissed tan that really brings out their features." I then turned to the girls directly. "You both share those same glossy, chocolate-brown locks. Alyssia, your slight waves cascade gracefully over your shoulders, just reaching the tops of your breasts, while your hair, Casey, flows long and sleek, elegantly down to your sweet, round butt."

I continued speaking to the group, "Their faces have this sweet, inviting quality, with full, pouty lips that look soft and kissable. They both have those captivating eyes—Alyssia's deep brown and Casey's a lighter hazel, both equally enchanting."

I moved on to their bodies, "Their figures are strikingly similar—curvy and feminine, with soft, rounded hips and thick, luscious thighs. They both seem to have wonderfully soft skin that looks like it would be a pleasure to touch."

Taking a moment to appreciate the sight before me, I moved on to describe their most prominent features. "And now, their breasts," I said, feeling the group's eyes on me as I spoke. "Alyssia's are incredibly full and rounded, with a noticeable tan line that only enhances their allure. Her nipples are a lovely shade of pink, erect and inviting. Just looking at them, it's hard not to imagine how tempting it would be to spend hours kissing and licking them."

Turning my gaze to Casey, I continued, "Casey’s breasts are equally captivating, though with a slightly more conical shape that exudes a unique charm. They are incredibly firm, hinting at her strength and athleticism. Her nipples, a deeper shade, add a different, equally enticing appeal. The fullness and symmetry of her breasts perfectly complement her figure, giving her an irresistible allure. Honestly, their shape and firmness are just breathtaking; it's hard not to get lost in their perfection." I could see Casey blushing, a shy smile spreading across her face as she absorbed the praise.

As I spoke, I couldn’t help but notice the reactions of the other girls. Erica and Anna watched intently, their own arousal evident. Carole, who had proposed the dare, looked particularly pleased with herself. She grinned mischievously, noticing the bulge forming in my swim trunks. "Well, that was exactly the kind of detailed analysis I was hoping for," she said, clearly satisfied with how things were unfolding. "You have quite an eye for detail, John."

Erica nodded in agreement, her cheeks slightly flushed. "You really captured their beauty perfectly," she said, casting a warm smile at Alyssia and Casey.

Even Sarah, who had been a bit overwhelmed by the boldness of the game, spoke up, her voice soft but sincere. "I... I never saw the beauty of their bodies so clearly before. Your description was... insightful," she said, her eyes flickering between the two topless girls with a mix of awe and curiosity.

Alyssia and Casey, now both continuing the game topless, smiled at each other before turning to me. "Thank you for the kind and detailed compliments," Alyssia said, her voice tinged with both shyness and pleasure. Casey nodded in agreement, adding, "We definitely enjoyed it, John. It’s nice to be appreciated in such a detailed way."

With that, they moved back to their original places, still basking in the glow of the attention and admiration they had received.