Noises in the dark

John grinned wide. Five horny girls, on all fours, crawling around the room blindly. This should give rise to some very interesting possibilities, right?

While all of them were still searching for something he did not even bother to hide, John silently walked over to a slightly chubby girl with full lips. He bent down and wished to her "Don't alert the others, and we will have some fun!"

A very short surprised gasp was all she let out. None of the others seemed to give it any second thought. A moment later, John guided her lips against his hard tip. He pushed against them softly, and her mouth opened. With his cock halfway inside of her mouth, John grabbed her by her hair and led her, on all fours, to the side of the room.

Sure, he was the one who had asked her not to make noise. But still, after half a minute of gentle movements, he started to thrust in her face for real. Of course, she gave off more and more slobbering gagging noises.

When one of her friends called out "Hey, what was that?" John quickly pulled out of her mouth. "Not a word." He whispered and stepped away from her.

For the next time, John decided not to even warn them first. He walked silently among the crawling naked party guests and randomly decided to reach down and stroke his finger over an exposed pair of pussy lips. When the surprised moan came, he was already gone.

Then, he started to just put his finger inside, by now they were all at least a bit wet. Confusion and suspicion spread quickly as one after the other girl gave short gasps and moans.

"Nobody found it yet? You want to give up, or do you want to keep looking?" John asked the room at large. "Keep searching, please!" One of them said, and the others agreed with a mumble. Of course they had. Hoping for more than a finger, John thought with a cheeky grin.

"Well in that case, let us see what your will be able to find." He noticed, that they all tried to crawl in the direction where they last heard his voice. After being groped and fingered more than one, they could all see where this was going. Or at least they hoped for something more. And who was John to disappoint them, right?

John got a little out of the way, so they all missed him. One of them missed him completely and moved in the opposite direction. This way, John has a great view of her perky ass cheeks as she crawled away though. She was his first victim.

The mumbling and stumbling sounds got suddenly interrupted by a sharp outcry as John buried himself right inside of her tight hole. He gave her more more than 5, maybe 10 seconds.

Right away, the others tried to reach the source of the sound they so much wished was coming from themselves. After the first one, John wildly jumped around between the rest of them. Pining them to the ground, fucking them against the side of the couch, sometimes taking their astonished open mouths as well. All but one. He never took Luna.

After a lot of drilling in tight 18 year old slits, moaning and groaning in various octaves and probably several orgasms on their side, Luna finally lost it.

"Come on! Please won't you take me too? All the others are getting it, I think, and it is my birthday!" She sounded very pouty. John slowly walked over to her, lifted her blindfold and reached down for her chin, to make her look up at him with her quivering lower lip and big eyes.

"Oh don't you worry about that, birthday girl. For you, I have a special plan" John's hard cock, wet from her friends insides, cast a shadow over Lunas face. She gulped audibly.