Catalina's Secret

As Will suspected the real pimp showed up a few minutes later, a young woman in tow. When Will told him their services were no longer required he was a bit upset, but after Will handed over the money they left without incident.

Now free to join the girls he proceeded to bound up the stairs and to the door of the Master bedroom. He slowly opened the door and was shocked by what he saw.

Melody wasn't naked any longer. She was wearing a plain black dress with a white apron overtop, almost like a maid outfit. Actually that was definitely it, Will noticed a feather duster in her hand. Melody was sitting on the bed with Catalina kneeling in front of her. They had been looking at each other but Catalina turned to look at Will as he entered.

*SLAP* The noise echoed across the room as Melody suddenly slapped Catalina across the face. Catalina gasped and clutched her cheek, glaring at Melody.

"You slut!" Melody growled, "Did I say you could stop? Don't look at him. Look at me." Melody sounded furious. What exactly was happening here?

"You...you slapped me. Nobody has ever... nobody would..." Catalina said softly.

"It's about time someone did. Going around acting high and mighty, but we both know who you really are. Now unless you want your father to stumble upon your dairy you'd better get back to work."

Catalina looked terrified, "No... please you can't. I'll do it!"

Catalina grabbed Melody's outstretched foot and started to kiss it. Will cringed, he was a little grossed out, feet were not his thing, but he had to admit it was hot seeing Catalina on her knees. This was obviously a **** roleplay...but with a wish it need not be roleplay at all.

Will strode forward, Catalina kept trying to glance at him without stopping the foot worship. He had almost reached when suddenly she lost her submissive demeanor entirely, "Do not come any closer! I said you could watch, nothing more."

Will pulled back, right. She was turned on by him watching but of course she didn't actually want him here. He thought about using a wish right then, but he decided he wanted to see where she was going with this roleplay. He saw a chair in the corner and went to sit down.

Melody continued to verbally **** Catalina as she licked her feet. Will was impressed by how easily she adopted that role. She mocked Catalina mercilessly and continually hit her with the feather duster.

Eventually Melody pushed Catalina away with her foot, "Now then I'm rather horny. It's time for you to earn my silence."

"What...I thought...the feet..." Catalina said quietly.

"Nonsense. That was just to show you your place," she leaned back and hiked her skirt up revealing her bare pussy, "Now lick."

Catalina looked away, "No. I can't. That's wrong. I'm not like that."

Melody chuckled, "Did you forget I read your diary? I thought you would be excited for your first taste of pussy. Now get over here...or else."

Catalina slowly crawled over to Melody and tentatively brought her face closer and closer. Melody didn't wait, she grabbed the back of Catalina's head and shoved her forward. She immediately started grinding her crotch against Catalina's mouth and moaning.

This roleplay was too specific, Will thought. So Catalina likes women...and she likes to be humiliated. Both things might be hard to admit to someone in her position. Will grinned, they might both get something out of their impending relationship.

After Melody came she ordered Catalina onto the bed for her turn. Catalina crawled into the bed but didn't want to undress, "No...I won't. I can't. The pleasure of the flesh...it isn't right that a woman makes me feel that way."

Melody laughed, "I'll show you just how right it is." Catalina was larger and stronger the Melody but allowed herself to be overpowered. Melody ripped her panties and threw them aside and then dove forward and licked her to multiple orgasms. When she was finally done she sat back and dropped out of her dominant persona.

Catalina took a moment to recover then sat up and smiled, "Thank you Melody. I'll have to hire you again. That slap? Wonderful. Really caught me off guard..." She looked over at Will, "...and I've never been watched before...it was...well I didn't mind it."

Will smiled and stood up, "I think we could make this relationship more long term."

Catalina held up a hand, "No. Our business is done. Please leave."

"I wish you would let us stay and have a discussion with you." Will said quickly.

Melody immediately followed up, "I wish you couldn't lie to us."

Catalina looked confused, "That was weird...well fine. You can stay but I'm not agreeing to anything so you are just wasting your time."

Will decided on the honesty path. Unlike say, Maria, he had no I'll will towards Catalina. Sure he wanted her, and her house, but his urge to build a harem wasn't as overpowering now that he had a small group already. He could survive letting her go if she really had no interest in joining, but he thought he could convince her.

"Alright first...we aren't the ones you hired. We just rang the bell and went along with what you wanted," Catalina looked shocked, but somehow when she saw Melody nodding along she just accepted it and let Will continue, "this will sound unbelievable but I have the power to make wishes come true. Not unlimited power, but there is a lot I could do for you. We came here because we wanted to see if we could make a deal for your house."

"Ok...so saying I believe you...you want to offer to grant my wishes in exchange for this property?" Catalina was hard to read. She sounded a little skeptical, a little angry, and just a little bit curious.

"More or less... although considering how we met...We would be open to continuing that sort of relationship too. The reason we want this house is for space for the whole Harem." Will explained.

Now she laughed, "Harem? You? You aren't ugly but you are just pulling my leg aren't you?"

Melody pouted, "It's true. Master has many women serving him. You should join us."

"Master?" Catalina said, looking back and forth between them. "Hmm..." She starting tapping her knee and seemed deep in thought. "Let's start with proof. Show me wishes are real."

Will looked over at Melody, "Do you have any wants for yourself? Something that will be noticable to her?"

Melody nodded, "Yes Master. I think I have one we'll both enjoy."

"Then let's show her on you. I wish Melody's clothes would disappear."

Immediately Melody was naked, eliciting a gasp from Catalina. Melody followed up with her own wish, "I wish my breasts were larger than Catalina's but would always be extremely perky and never cause any strain on my back."

Again the change was instantaneous. Melody went from her nearly flat chest to watermelon sized breasts hanging off her chest. She squeezed them and squealed, "Wow. They are so big! Do you like them Master?"

Will was speechless, he had no idea she wanted bigger breasts, "Ya...wow. That's really what you wanted?"

She nodded, "I've always wished they were bigger. All the women in your harem are so hot...I've just been feeling really boyish beside them. Now I've got the biggest tits in the Harem!"

Will turned to Catalina, "So is that proof enough?"

Catalina was still speechless. She slowly reached out and grabbed one of Melody's tits and hefted it up, "It's...it's real..."

Melody shook her chest back and forth, "Yep! 100% natural." She said with a wink.

Catalina looked over at Will, "I think...we may be able to come to an arrangement after all..."