Plans are hatched

“I’m not crazy, you guys saw that, right?” Heather asked of her girlfriends, all now back in their bedroom changing out of their clothes and into pajamas.

“Are they all that big?” Ashley asked nervously.

“None that I’ve seen,” Heather answered quickly

“I… I’ve watched a lot of porn,” Chloe hesitantly said, looking around the room. “The ones that size are marketed as being enormous.”

“Ladies, we need to see that thing again. From the front, in good lighting,” Heather stated as fact, not suggestion.

“I think I want to touch it. Is that weird?” Chloe asked.

“I think not wanting to touch it would be weird,” Heather replied.

“Heather! I told you to stop shaming me for being a virgin!” Ashley whined.

“Girl, you can be a virgin, but that thing of Gavin’s is a scientific marvel. You’re usually a curious cat, are you telling me you don’t want to know how it feels?” Heather shot back.

“I… I do. But I did come here to give my virginity to Zack. I don’t know, I’m confused!” She slammed her fists on the bed.

“That’s right, you saw him naked earlier too! Did you see anything like Gavin? Has Chloe been hiding these enormous nerd cocks from us?” Heather turned and winked at her new friend.

“Ha ha, very funny Heather. I didn’t see Zack’s dick. I don’t think he’s in Gavin’s league though; I think I would have seen it if he was.”

“I don’t think Kurt is either,” Chloe added. “When I was grinding on him, I’m pretty sure he was hard, but it didn’t seem as big as Gavin.”

“I felt the same way when I sat on his lap,” Ashley chimed in.

“Ladies, this is probably the point at which I say there’s nothing wrong with being smaller than Gavin—” Heather started.

“But there’s a lot right with what Gavin’s got,” Chloe finished.

“…Yeah, pretty much. Jesus, he wasn’t even hard!” Heather said.

Everyone ruminated on that for a moment before Ashley broke the ice.

“So, what are you going to do?”

“What are we going to do, is the question, dear,” Heather said, continuing on, “I said we were bonding this week and I meant it. This is going to be a coordinated effort and we are all going to reap the rewards.”

“Heather, I don’t know if I can. I’m serious, I’m not sure how this makes me feel about Zack.”

“That’s okay. You still want to see it again, right?”

“…yeah.”

“Then you’re in. The first part isn’t dirty anyways; we need to boost his confidence. It shouldn’t be hard, once he realizes how special what’s between his legs is, but we’re going to have to help him feel a little more self-assured if we want him to be any good when we seduce him. Once it starts getting frisky, we two will take over. It’s only going to be one of us with him at first anyways; he might have a great cock, but if we come at him with more than one of us, it’ll be too much and he’ll fuck it up. Besides, more for the rest of us. Chloe, you go way back, are you scared to touch it too?”

“No way. It’s just like one of my toys; I’m not passing up the chance to see how the real thing compares,” Chloe answered quickly. “And I think you’re right about it being one at a time. I don’t think Gavin has kissed anyone; he’s pretty hopeless with women.”

“There we go. Ashley, you’re on look, don’t touch. Chloe, whoever gets to him first, promise that we do it so the rest can watch? And no getting in each other’s way, girls stick together.”

“Agreed.” Both other girls nodded.

“Wait! No walking up to him and just asking to see his dick, okay?” Chloe added. “Not that it wouldn’t work at first, but he’s my friend, I know he’s going to freak out eventually if we go about this wrong and it’ll be super weird. That’s just the rest of the week for you guys, but it’s the rest of my life.”

“Yeah, sure thing Chloe,” Heather replied, and Ashley nodded along.

*************

The next day, Ashley woke up to find Kurt had left a note that he was going for a run. She started rifling through the cupboards and quickly grabbed bread, eggs, and milk for French toast.

She had the pan crackling with the first batch when Gavin came downstairs. Ashley couldn’t help herself; she immediately looked down at the boxer briefs he was wearing and Jesus! She could see the pink head of his cock pointing out from the bottom! Any chance last night was a fever dream went right out the window on that one.

“Hi Gavin!” Ashley chirped, “there’s some strawberries in the fridge, would you chop them up to go along with the French toast?”

Gavin grabbed a knife and cutting board from the block and the strawberries from the fridge before he sat down and started going to work, whistling as he went.

“That was super weird last night, right?” he asked.

Ashley definitely agreed, but she was curious what Gavin considered ‘weird’.

“What do you mean, Gavin?” she asked.

“Well, I mean,” he whispered, looking around before finishing, “wow Chloe! I can’t believe she danced on Kurt like that! And I knew she played a lot of soccer, but I didn’t know she looked like that! She’s always in those oversized sweaters; even her social media doesn’t have her in anything else after like, twelve.”

Yep, thought Ashley, he has no idea. She let him carry on, careful not to say anything that would ruin the girls’ plans.

“And Zack, he never told me about all that with Lisa! I feel bad that he didn’t talk to me about it. I remember when they broke up he came over more and we gamed a lot, but we didn’t talk about much.”

“Do you guys usually talk about your problems?”

“I… guess? He suggested I do something for my mom this year on Father’s Day.”

“Oh?”

“My dad died when I was young, so my mom is all I’ve got. Normally I get kinda grouchy on Father’s Day, but Zack saw it coming this year and said I should get her something, since she has to be both parents. He actually helped me pick out some flowers and it meant a lot to her.”

“That’s… pretty great of him. What’s he going through?”

“I dunno, we never talk about his shit. He usually seems to have it all figured out.”

*************

Zack hadn’t slept well last night. He was hoping this weekend would be a chance to spend some time with Ashley, get to know her a little more and maybe see if she wanted to go on a date some time. All that had been thrown into the wind by the way everyone responded to Gavin’s dare last night. Christ, the size of that thing! Women always say that size doesn’t matter, but last night they’d all seemed practically feral!

He had been expecting Kurt to be a problem, but a manageable one, given what he’d heard from Ashley about Kurt. A guy being a moderate jerk, maybe a little shady or some other macho bullshit, that’s fine. But Gavin wasn’t supposed to be a threat! Hell, Gavin was the guy who couldn’t get a prom date.

With how little confidence Gavin and Chloe usually had, Zack had defaulted into the leader of their little group, as well as the social ambassador who connected them with other groups. He was used to being the big fish in their small pond and even though that meant he was always the one who had to try new things or stand up for the three of them, it gave him a sense of security that the other two looked up to him. He hadn’t thought he felt superior to them, but right now he was certainly feeling inferior.

And not just Gavin, what was happening with Chloe?! Admittedly it was impossible to be someone’s running partner without being somewhat aware of their body, but first she wore make-up to the beach, then that truth or dare game? Zack knew that Heather was a big influence on Ashley, but he hadn’t expected her to have this kind of effect on Chloe in less than 24 hours!

Yet, Zack had to admit, it’s not like he didn’t like this side of Chloe. About six months ago, Zack had gone over to Chloe’s to game on a Friday night while Gavin was out of town. At the time, a racing game had been all the rage, so he thought nothing of it when he heard a buzzing motor going behind the closed door to her room.

When he entered the room, however, it was anything but a racing game. Chloe was lying on the bed, face flushed, as she pushed a huge buzzing dildo in and out of herself with one hand and covered her mouth with the other. Once he was inside the room, Zack could hear the whimpers that managed to escape her mouth. On the TV in her room was not a video game, but instead some very impressive pornography of two women getting gangbanged, lying down beside each other on a bed. One of the women had a cock in her pussy and another in each hand, while she used her mouth to lick the other woman’s breast; the other woman was taking a cock in her pussy, ass, and mouth, using her hands to push her legs wide open.

After a moment’s pause for the shock to hit both of them, Zack quickly turned tail and left, yelling, “Sorry!” over his shoulder while Chloe whipped off her headphones and covered herself up, shrieking, “Oh my god Zack!”

The next time the two saw each other was at school on Monday. Gavin had chattered on about his trip and the two of them nodded along, half-present, the other half remembering what they had seen. After that, they’d only spent time together in a group setting for at least a month, before eventually Zack suggested a run. They spent that 10k in silence, but at least the two were able to spend time together again. The two didn’t avoid each other following the run, but had never discussed the state Zack had found her in.

It seemed like Chloe was ready to take her porn habits into the real world, or at least dip a foot in.

*************

The busty ginger got up and noticed Ashley was already absent from the big bed, though Heather still had her sleep mask on and was gently snoring. She rolled out of bed and decided to give it a shot at putting on her own make-up. After all, Ashley and Heather did it every day, how hard could it be?

Very, it turned out. Chloe had no idea why concealer, foundation, and bronzer all looked the same, but apparently did different things? And why did something look like her skin tone in the bottle, but then completely change her face when it came out? After a half hour of trying and becoming increasingly frustrated, she figured a lipstick was impossible to screw up, so she tried to pick one that matched her hair (though any expert would have told her she’d picked terribly).

Okay, if that wasn’t going to be her move for the day, it was going to have to be the body. She grabbed a tiny pair of terrycloth shorts and pulled them up much higher than she normally would, enough that her ass cheeks were peeking out the bottom. She turned to look in the mirror, going on tiptoes to see properly and her bum jiggled as she did so. Yeah, she smiled to herself, that’ll do.

Perhaps just as bold for her, if not overall, was grabbing a spaghetti strap white tank top. It was low-cut and tight, although admittedly Chloe had that effect on most tops intended as a first layer. Of course, she decided, today was a no bra day; I’m on vacation, dangit!

She flounced downstairs and saw Gavin and Ashley chatting as they prepared breakfast.

“—maybe you’re right Ashley, I’ll ask Chloe when she wakes up.”

“Surprise, here I am! What can I do for you Gavin?”

Gavin turned and looked at Chloe, his eyes widening at her outfit. He blinked twice to steady himself and replied, “Working out with you has clearly been working for Zack. Ashley was just suggesting that you might do the same for me.”

The redhead, who caught Gavin’s reaction, suppressed a smile.

“Sure Gavin, I’d be happy to. Heather actually wanted to go hiking this morning, I’ll go see if she wants to get on that now, before it gets too hot out.”

“Oh, that’d be cool! I’ll go wake Zack up while you get Heather.” Gavin took off up the stairs towards Zack’s room.

“That didn’t go the way we were hoping, did it?” Chloe asked her blonde friend.

“No, not quite, but I don’t mind seeing Zack get hot and sweaty. You better go get Heather, especially if we want to leave before Kurt gets back,” Ashley responded, adding, “this French toast isn’t going to pack well, but I’ll do my best.”

“Where is he?”

*************

After forty-five minutes of running to hip-hop club remixes, Kurt was ready to turn around and head back. The morning sun was beating down on his open chest and his curly brown hair had gotten quite sweaty. He wasn’t terribly familiar with the area, but he’d left a geotag at the cottage, so he figured it wouldn’t be hard to get back.

Kurt hadn’t done cardio since he started at university but the unforgivable lack of free weights at the cabin and the admittedly beautiful forest meant it really was the best option. As he reached the end of his playlist, Kurt took a minute to listen to nature and in doing so, his thoughts inevitably turned to the night before.

He knew before the trip that Heather being so close to Ashley was going to make seducing her that much more complicated, but he liked a challenge. Her being so into Zack was unfortunate, but manageable, especially since her attraction to him was tied up in feelings. Emotions are so malleable, since an allegation can so easily turn them in one direction or the other. He was not above implying Zack had done something mildly disagreeable or that would otherwise give Ashley an ick about her supposed crush. With her heart gone astray, she’d be putty that he could easily mold with the right compliment and suggestion. And hell, failing all that, the ginger virgin would be a quick lay.

This Gavin, however, had taken the wind right out of all of Kurt’s usual gamesmanship. Rumours of a big dick can be dissuaded, but the bastard had really just let it all hang out and everyone had gotten a good look at it. Okay, maybe not a great look, but clearly the kid was packing! And then it got put away before anything could be done about it, what a clever tease! Kurt honestly hadn’t figured Gavin would be a factor at all, what with how quiet and skinny he was, but Kurt could tell from the way the ladies responded the night before that ol’ Big Dick was suddenly the top dog in the cabin.

This was a troublesome development. On one hand, whichever girl Gavin picked, the rest might be so upset that they didn’t want any dick the rest of the week. In another version, Gavin might pick the other new hot thing, Chloe, leaving Ashley with her original choice, Zack, and Kurt out of luck given that Heather was his cousin. Kurt didn’t even want to consider whether Gavin might be smooth enough to get all three; that might break him.

Oddly enough, his best hope was that his cousin came through and took Gavin off the market. What was his cousin up to, he wondered?

*************

Heather started to stir when she heard Chloe fumbling away at the make-up counter they’d set up in the corner. Since she was half-asleep still anyway, Heather decided to let Chloe continue to try her luck on her own. The redhead probably wasn’t going to nail it on the first go around, but at least she would have a greater appreciation for what Heather and Ashley were helping her with. And hey, maybe she’d be a natural! She turned over as quietly as possible and gave a small smile as she heard Chloe say, “Ugh, this was stupid anyway,” and start rubbing her face with make-up remover.

The perfectly toned brunette figured she would have a bit of time to herself in bed this morning, enough to plot a course to get Gavin naked and put his cock in her hands. Chloe was right, the blunt approach of walking up and asking was the simplest, but it was too high-risk when another path could remove that doubt. He would need to be seduced. As much as the actual act would need to happen in relative privacy, this shy boy was likely very unused to being complimented in public. Puffing up his ego, especially in front of other men, would hit him just where he needed it and give him the push to not just undress in front of her, but have some confidence while he does. God, he didn’t even seem to know how gigantic his dick was last night! This was a rare opportunity indeed.

Heather had been hoping to get a little more time to lay around in the big bed, but Chloe disrupted that when she burst into the room

“Hey, I convinced Gavin to go hiking with us! He’s going to bring Zack, but Kurt is off on a run, so if you move your butt, we can probably get on the trail without him.”

“Ugh okay, that’s worth getting up for. Good work, Chloe. And smart move with the tank top, your tits look great babe.”

We’re going to need them to do some extra work now that we don’t have time for make-up, Heather thought, but decided not to verbalize. Chloe was a rookie and she’d managed to cut Kurt out of the picture, which wasn’t nothing. In the future, she’d a) be better at make-up and b) think about these kinds of things before she acted. Heather hopped out of bed and tossed her oversized t-shirt to the floor, her braless breasts bouncing about freely before she grabbed a cute workout set of tight aqua and orange shorts to go with a matching sports bra doing its best to contain her 36Fs; they aren't contained, Heather smiled to herself, but the support would be good for this much movement.