Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 79 by syncmaster69 syncmaster69

Where did Heather go? Does Hannah have any plans?

And Heather Makes 3

And Heather Makes 3

*****

Note: Just a reminder there are some references here that go way back to the backstory in case anyone wants to refresh their memory.

*****

Peter and Taylor walked along the cold stream hand in hand looking for a private spot. Peter had noticed the forlorn look on both girls. He saw the troubled look on Hannah's face as her attempts to provoke a reaction in Taylor had failed. He also saw the longing in Taylor's eyes. His plan to make them realize how much they missed each other seemed to be working, maybe by tonight or tomorrow, they wouldn't be able to take it anymore and reconcile with each other. At least that is what Peter hoped. He really hated manipulating the two girls, thankfully Zack had made a great rebound thanks to Hannah and Chloe.

Peter knew the whole 'almost nothing bikini' Hannah wore was just to spark a reaction from Taylor, and maybe remind him that she was still waiting for him. When that had failed to get the attention she wanted from them Hannah had 'lost' it. He knew that what Hannah wanted most of all was attention. Attention and love from Taylor and from himself. Hannah knew what she wanted and wasn't afraid to lay it all out in the open. She had made that perfectly clear more than once. And perhaps that was the problem.

He also saw the way Taylor had desperately wanted to react to Hannah's antics. Taylor needed to have some predictability and stability around her. He guessed that she felt a little overwhelmed by Hannah's open sexuality and tried to put some control. He had long suspected that something had happened between the girls, something they had both kept quiet from him. He assumed they hadn't told him because Taylor wanted to keep a certain public image since she wanted to be a respectable doctor, something that was a bit hard to do living with Hannah. And last night, when Taylor had taken his cock in her ass he was surprised to find out that Taylor's preference in sex was far from being vanilla, quite the contrary. It really was an eye-opener for him. He really shouldn't have been surprised by it, knowing that the two girls were so close it was a given that Taylor would have her own kinks.

In a sense, Peter came to the realization of something that he always knew in the back of his mind. There was something of Taylor in Hannah, and there was something of Hannah in Taylor. Two sides of the same coin. That was the only way they could still be such close friends after all this time. It was clear they both very much enjoyed the back and forth. It was also something that almost always ended up drawing him in as well. 'Or is it something the girls do to draw me into their banter?' Peter wondered now about it. 'Do they fight more or less when I am around?'

It also brought forth another dilemma for Peter. He still felt something for Hannah, he always had, even after they broke up. He couldn't deny that. And he felt something special for Taylor as well. Which brought back the memories of why they had broken up and why he had hooked up with Taylor.

"If only Hannah hadn't fucked Zack," Peter muttered his thoughts out loud without realizing it.

"Why did she have to do it!" Taylor said between gritted teeth. Peter just squeezed her hand and let her get it out of her system on her own. "Why does she have to try and fix everything with sex! Doesn't she know it doesn't work that way!?"

"No it doesn't," Peter agreed with Taylor, "But for Hannah it is, or it does. You know that." He watched Taylor process it. She struggled, knowing that it was true but still angry that her best friend had fucked Zack against her wishes and their agreement.

"She didn't do it to get her kicks," Peter said as he hugged Taylor, "She did it because it hurt her to see Zack in pain. She loves Zack the same way you do and she couldn't bear to see him with a broken heart. She wasn't trying to take advantage of Zack, you know that? She just wanted to heal him." Peter felt Taylor tense up for another bitter reply when he added "Remember when you broke up with Grant? When Hannah and I were making out in the backyard and Hannah wanted you to join us?"

"Yeah, I remember," Taylor answered at the bitter memory.

"She wasn't trying to 'get you,' because you were a girl. She didn't want you to feel awkward with us, she wanted to make you feel better because she cares for you, I think... she loves you too." Peter said softly. "You know that... And I bet it wasn't the only time she tried it."

Taylor sighed as she relaxed in Peter's arms. 'Damm it, why does he always have to be right.' Taylor thought as she admitted that Hannah was like that. Hannah might not approve of some of her boyfriends but when she broke up with them she never came with the oh-so-high-and-mighty 'I told you so!' attitude. No, every time it had happened Hannah had always tried to seduce her to try and cheer her up and forget about her boyfriend, and sometimes it had worked.

"I know it's just that..." Taylor started before trailing off.

"Hannah was just doing the same with someone she loves like a little brother. And she'll probably try to do the same with Ashley if she ever breaks up with Brandon," Peter continued. "And you have to admit, Zack is more than fine. I bet he and Chloe already forgot all about Victoria, and Kurt, and everything else outside their own little world." He saw the resigned look on Taylor and knew he had won her over, "Much better than a year of therapy. and a lot cheaper."

Taylor chuckled and cupped his face in her hands. "Why do you always have to be right," she said before she kissed him, "I guess that 's one of the reasons we both love you, you know us both too well."

Peter wrapped his arms around her waist and pulled her in. Has their kiss deepened he felt the tension leave Taylor's slim body and he hoped she had finally let go of her bitterness and was ready to forgive Hannah. Now to get Hannah to give a sincere apology.

****

Heather quietly sneaked off from the group without being noticed except maybe by Hannah. But she trusted that Hannah would distract everyone and give her enough time. 'Well, with that bikini they'd have to be dead not to be distracted,' Heather giggled to herself.

She purposely walked along the banks of the stream, the mix of soft moss and rocks made it easy for her to not make a sound and approach the unsuspecting couple. She had been patient enough but now she really wanted to add another notch to her list of accomplishments.

Turning around the next bend she smiled as she came upon the happy couple making out on a large boulder. She watched Peter slowly peel off Taylor's monokini, gently revealing her supple breast, the light brown bud of her nipple pointing up, just begging to be kissed and licked. But for now, all it got was his thumb flicking over it.

Heather slipped her fingers under her bikini to rub her clit and felt her pussy start to get wetter as she watched Taylor's hand drift down from where it had been ruffling Peter's blond hair. Taylor's hand slid down Peter's chest and then slipped under his swimming trunks. Heather watched her pull his cock out and start to give it long slow strokes. Heather imagined she could almost hear Peter moaning like he did the last time they were together when she did that.

Heather felt her breaths come in shallow intakes, fearful to let her presence be known too soon. Her fingers rubbed her pussy lips, spreading them and moistening her fingers with her own juices as she watched the couple, looking for the opening, the right moment to join in. She watched Peter cup and squeeze Taylor's tits, rolling her nipple in his fingers. Heather found herself doing the same with her own hard nipple, copying Peter's hand, imagining what Taylor could also be feeling. She felt her mouth dry up when his mouth bent down to suck on Taylor's taunt nub, his tongue flickering out to taste Taylor's nipple just like he had with her that second morning at the cabin. Heather did the same pulling her tit up to lick her own teat.

She watched Peter's hand drift down to pull Taylor monokini off, leaving the brunette naked with her legs spread wide for Peter. She watched how Taylor cupped and fondled her own tits even as she fed them to Peter's eager mouth. Heather felt her own legs tremble as she watched Peter part Taylor's pussy lips and gently slip a finger inside the brunette's wet hole just like she was doing to herself now. Heather felt her body burn with unfulfilled need as she impatiently watched and waited for the right moment to join in.

Heather heard Taylor loudly moan his name and watched Peter silence her with his mouth as he kept pleasuring her pussy with his fingers. Heather noticed Taylor close her eyes and kept squeezing and fondling her own tits and knew it was time to make her move.

Heather practically tore off her bikini as she silently approached the unsuspecting couple. She reached out and started stroking Peter's unattended cock with one hand and ran her other hand to Taylor's thigh making the older brunette shiver. Her hand joined Peter's in pleasuring Taylor's pussy for a moment.

Peter was the first to be surprised by Heather but he decided to go with the flow. If she wanted in she'd have to earn it. His kisses drifted to Taylor's neck so he could watch Heather. He grabbed Heather's hair and guided her to Taylor's tits. He watched her smirk grip his cock tighter as her delicate pink tongue sensually circled the other brunette's nipple. Taylor was lost in a lust-fueled daze and fed her tits to her while she enjoyed Peter's kisses on her neck and his tongue dancing on her tit.

"Mmm, do it, suck my tits," Taylor moaned as she ran her fingers through Peter's hair and fed him her tit, She shifted to give his hand between her legs a better angle as she let his other hand grab her tit 'HAND!!!'

"Oh for fucks sake Hannah!" Taylor groaned with frustration, "Can't you at least let us have some alone time together?!"

"Thanks, I didn't know I was as as good as her," Heather piped in cheerfully as she lightly bit Taylor's nipple making her gasp and moan.

"Mpf! And just as slutty," Taylor moaned, her deep raspy voice thick with desire as she glanced down and watched Heather stroke Peter's cock while licking her tits, "Looks like she's got a good grip on you."

"Uf" Peter hissed a sharp intake when Heather ran her fingers over his balls. Still, he ignored Heather and kept kissing Taylor while he cupped the same tit Heather was busy sucking on, "You could say that."

Taylor watched Heather switch to kiss Peter and felt a pang of jealousy as they briefly kissed and then Peter kissed her again, their tongues dueling together while three pairs of hands roamed over each other body. Soon Heather's lips joined theirs and the three shared a kiss, their lips and tongues sliding around each other till they lost track of who they were kissing.

"I think she should earn it first," Peter mumbled as he reached down and smacked Heather's naked ass making her giggle delightfully.

"Alright," Taylor mumbled lustfully as she struggled between enjoying all the hands and mouths pleasuring her and rejecting having sex with another woman. Taylor grabbed a fistful of Heather's hair and pulled her down to Peter's cock, "Let's see if you're as good as Hannah."

Heather eagerly gobbled up Peter's cock but Taylor soon set the pace for her. Taylor guided Heather's head on his cock, setting the rhythm for the younger teen while the two lovers continued to kiss above her.

They settled into a rhythm together, Heather sucked Peter's cock to Taylor's rhythm while she and Peter both played with Taylor's pussy together, switching between fingering her dripping pussy and her clit. Peter switch between sucking on Taylor's delicious breast and kissing his girlfriend who squirmed under the constant attention of her two lovers.

The churning sound of the stream was soon joined by the moans of pleasure from Peter and Taylor and wet slurping and gagging sounds from Heather as Taylor pushed her deeper into Peter's cock.

"Mmm, She's got, a good head on her shoulders," Peter hummed as if judging her skills.

"She... She any good?" Taylor asked in a lustful daze. The many hands between her legs was a novelty as she also enjoyed using Heather's face to fuck Peter's cock.

"Check it out for yourself," he add and guided Heather's mouth off his cock and between Taylor's firm legs.

"OH!" Taylor gasped as Heather's eager tongue started licking and probing the folds of her pussy. She quickly grabbed her head and pulled her tight against her pussy, humping her girl's mouth, trying to her her tongue deeper inside her empty, aching pussy that was begging to get filled.

Heather quickly slipped two fingers into Taylor's hungry pussy, finger fucking the older brunette while her lips and tongues played with her clit and pussy lips. Heather was all too eager to please as she expected Peter to start fucking her now. She licked and drank Taylor's sweet honey dripping down and covering her chin and wondered why guys weren't more eager to go down on a girl.

Peter ran his fingers over Heather's full ass, sliding down the crack of her trembling ass and easily slipping a finger into her hot pussy. He knew she was more than ready to get a good hard pounding. But he also knew that Taylor needed a little more time to get used to another girl. Heather would have to wait a little while longer. He also knew that the wait would only make her hornier when he did fuck her, and he was going to fuck both of them.

Taylor mentally started to compare Heather's oral skills with Peter's and then with Hannah's. She closed her eyes to avoid seeing Heather eat her out, she didn't want to enjoy it, but she felt all of her resistance slowly crumble with each wave of pleasure Peter and Heather were giving her. Taylor finally started to lose herself and gave in to incessant tongue probing and exploring her sex. As she did so she felt Peter's cock brush against her lips, Taylor's lips glided over his crown as her tongue danced over his tip. licking and sucking his cock while she wrapped her hand around his buttocks and pulled him closer to get more of his cock into her hungry mouth.

Peter relaxed as he enjoyed Taylor's blowjob while he watched her reaction. The way her mouth moaned and hummed around his cock, the way her hands kept straying down to Heather's head while the heiress knelt before her, Heather's lips and tongues eagerly playing with her clit while she finger fucked Taylor's soaked pussy. He saw Taylor's hips start to buckle towards Heather's fingers and her legs start to tremble and wrap around Heather and he knew she was cumming on Heather's mouth.

Peter waited till Taylor started to come down from her high and gently pulled out of her mouth. "Let's fuck her," he whispered into Taylor's ear and watched her nod in a lust dazed way. He pulled Heather up and told her to lie down on the rock.

Heather stretched out on the rock and hoped that Peter would finally fuck her. When Peter lifted and spread her legs Heather looked at him with a shit-eating grin as he lined up his cock with her hungry pussy. Heather cried out in surprise when he buried his cock inside her in one swift, powerful thrust. He lifted her legs high in the air, bending them forward as he adjusted himself deeper and gave Heather another powerful thrust that made her gasp again.

Taylor watched Heather, mesmerized by the look of pure bliss on her face as Peter filled her pussy, the way her tits bounced with each thrust was a beauty to behold and she briefly wondered if that was the way she looked.

"You should sit on her face," Peter encouraged Taylor as he started to fuck Heather with long slow strokes.

Peter's voice brought her back to the real world. Taylor hesitantly settled down on Heather's face, smothering the younger teen even as she balanced herself by squeezing Heather's tits. Heather's tongue delved into her pussy while she pulled her butt cheeks apart to get better access and Taylor felt a shiver up her spine when that probing tongue briefly danced around her puckered asshole.

Peter's kiss melted away her final hesitation as she let herself enjoy the overwhelming sensation she was feeling. It was like making out with her boyfriend at the same time she was having sex. It was like the best of both worlds and she gave herself completely over to Peter's guidance as she melted into his embrace.

Heather was vaguely aware of the surface of the boulder, grateful that it was really smooth. She quickly forgot all about the boulder the moment Peter started to fuck her. She felt her orgasm quickly boil inside her, she hadn't realized just how hot and **** she had been to be fucked till she felt his cock inside her.

Heather kept licking Taylor's pussy as she felt someone play with her tits, rolling and pinching her nipples while Peter fucked her. She barely felt Taylor's hand drift down her abdomen till she felt her fingers circle her clit in a bolt of pleasure in tune with Peter's thrust. She cried out into Taylor's pussy and felt the older girl's legs tremble next to her.

It was now like a feedback loop, each thrust from Peter pushed Heather closer to a powerful orgasm, and each lick and muffled cry from Heather did the same to Taylor as she made out with Peter. Something in Heather made her take the next step, some curious corner of her mind gave her an idea to push Taylor further over the edge. She brought her finger to Taylor's crinkled butthole and pushed.

"OH MY GOD!" Taylor cried out as she felt her own orgasm explode when Heather fingered her ass. Her pussy spasmed around Heather's tongue as she flooded the girl's mouth with her juices. Her frantic grip on Heather's breast and clit did the same and Heather felt her body shudder with an exquisite release as she also came beneath the couple.

Hearing the two girls cum at the same time was too much for Peter. He pulled out of Heather's spasming pussy and started to shoot his load all over both girls. He fired off a couple of powerful jets of cum that landed on both girls' tits and stomachs.

The three panting lovers slowly untangled themselves and happily collapsed on the floor completely satisfied beyond what they had hoped for this afternoon. They lay there catching their breaths as they smiled and admired each other and basked in the collective bliss they felt.

Heather got a naughty idea and she scooped up some of Peter's cum dripping on Taylor's tits with her finger and feed it to Taylor. Taylor gently sucked on that cum covered finger till it was clean and then did the same with a second finger Heather feed her. Taylor started returning the favor and soon the two brunettes caress each others breast will they seached for more cum to feed each other.

'What a delicious slut,' Peter thought as he watched the two girls and saw Heather's smirk and Taylor's expectant smile.

A soft rumble of thunder brought them out of their revelry and they noticed that the sky was getting darker. A far-off flash followed by another soft rumble announced the approach of another storm.

"C'mon, we better hurry back and get everyone to the cabin before the storm breaks," Peter said as he stood up and helped the girls stand. He helped Taylor and then Heather put their swimsuits back on with some playful naughty groping along the way.

As they walked back Heather grinned like a Cheshire cat, another notch to add to her accomplishments something to keep her in the lead. Not to mention that it had really been a lot more fun than she thought it would be outside of a bed.

Peter was a bit worried that Taylor might have some regrets about getting carried away with Heather but for the moment the satisfied and sated look on her face made him think things were ok.

Taylor walked lightly, almost like in a dream. She started to wonder about what had just happened and seemingly out of the blue she remembered something that her mother had told her a few years ago when she had her first experience with Hannah. Maybe it was Peter's mentioning her old boyfriend Grant that brought it back. She remembered her mother's advice about Hannah's antics. '_Has long has it's just some fun among friends it's okay_. But it's better with someone you love and care about,' She also remembered a few other things her mother had said, warning and encouragement that she hadn't realized at that time.

Do they make it back in time? What about the other?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)