The truth or dare app.

We finished eating breakfast, and after a brief, comfortable silence, I asked, “So… What do you want to do now?”

“I know what I want to do,” Mila said. She smiled seductively at me and ran her finger from my neck to my chest. “Sorry to be so blunt about it, but it’s been a little too long for me.”

“We already had a family-friendly Christmas,” Grace said. “Don’t worry about anything. We can do what we want for as long as we want.”

Beside me, Noelle swallowed with red cheeks. “Is it really okay?”

Grace smirked. “So long as you help me clean up afterwards, of course.”

“We’ll take you up on the offer, then.” Then, as Alice casually began to unbutton her shit…

“Stop!” Mila told her, making Alice freeze with a puzzled look on her face. It was Mila’s turn to smirk. “Sure, we could just jump into it like wild rabbits, but… Why don’t we make a game out of it?”

Sarah smiled, leaned back on her seat and crossed her arms. “Go on, I’m listening.”

Mila brought out her phone, tapped on the screen and showed us what she had in mind. On her phone screen was an app called ‘Spice the Night: The Truth or Dare Game!’

“Remember when we started hanging out with Oliver and we played truth or dare?” Mila asked. Grace and Sarah nodded. “We kept it super tame that time, but now… I checked plenty of apps and this one seems the most fun. It has questions and dares by levels: mild, spicy, hot and extra hot. You can set it for group play, too and…” As Mila grinned, her cheeks began to redden. “You can specify if a player wants to interact with men, women or both.”

“Okay, I’m sold,” Sarah said. “Let’s give it a try.”

“Yes, it sounds fun,” Noelle agreed.

“Better than jumping into it all of a sudden,” Alice said, buttoning up her shirt. “You came prepared, huh?”

Mila puffed her chest proudly. “I’ve been looking forward to this day!”

“What do you think, Oliver?” Grace asked me.

I swallowed. That time as a kid when I played truth or dare was still in my mind. This was entirely different, though. This time… I knew it would be fun.

“Let’s do it.”

“Yes!” Mila fistpumped and pecked my cheek. “So… I’ll write all our names here.”

“Set me to interact with girls,” Sarah said.

“Me too,” Grace said.

“H-Hey…” Noelle spoke up. She sounded hesitant. “If we… If we’re uncomfortable doing a dare, can we… refuse?”

“Hm? Of course,” Mila said. “We’re here to have fun, not make things awkward between us.”

“Well said,” Alice praised. “I said I was willing to try girl-on-girl stuff, but I don’t know how far I’m willing to go yet. So with that in mind, set me to interact with girls, too.”

Noelle nodded. “Me too.”

“Ah, me too,” I told Mila, which got a louder laugh out of everyone than I thought it would.

“Hmm, with these settings, we might not get to do a lot with Oliver,” Mila said.

“We’ll consider it the lucky rolls, then,” Sarah said.

And I’d get to watch them play around with each other. Fuck, my heart began to beat faster.

“Alright. I’ll press the button and the app will choose one of us at random. That person has to choose either truth or dare,” Mila explained. “Then the question or the dare will pick someone else for them to interact with or answer the question about.”

“Got it. Now shoot!” Sarah said.

“We’ll start with the ‘mild’ level, okay? Here we go!”

Mila pressed the button, and since I was behind her, I saw all our names start to spin and converge in the middle of the screen until one popped out.

“Noelle, you’re up!” Mila said. “Truth or dare?”

“T-Truth,” she said. I felt some of her nerves and knew she didn’t feel ready to start with a dare, nor be the first one to do it.

Mila then read the question. “If Oliver suddenly gained 20 kilos, would you stay with him? It actually says Grace’s name, but you’re not dating her, are you?” Mila and Noelle giggled at that.

Noelle looked at me and gave me a nervous smile. “I would, no question about it. But… I… I do like how he looks now, so…”

“Please don’t gain weight. Got it.” I nodded. Then I smirked and teasingly poked Noelle on the side. “But then I’ll hold you to the same standards.”

Noelle’s eyes widened. She looked down and placed her hands on her belly. Then, with a look of fierce determination, she nodded. “I promise!”

Okay, I suddenly felt bad about it. “D-Don’t take it so seriously,” I said, laughing.

“Hey, it’s fair, isn’t it? You’re handsome and sexy, so we’d like you to stay that was for as long as humanly possible. Of course, we should try to do the same.”

“Just… don’t go overboard, okay?” I told them.

“No surgery, then,” Sarah said, nodding her approval. “Okay, that one really was mild. I think I like this. Let’s do the next one.”

Mila pressed the button again, and our names spun. When mine came up, all the girls smirked. “Truth or dare, Mr. Boyfriend?” she asked me.

I swallowed. “D-Dare.”

“Remove two articles of clothing of your choice,” Mila read.

Sarah whistles loudly while Alice laughed and clapped.

Okay, this wasn’t so bad. I was wearing a black jacket over a long-sleeve gray shirt, so I took that one off first. Then… a shoe, which caused me to get unanimously booed, even by Noelle!

“Show more skin!” Mila shouted with her hands around her mouth.

“We want abs!” Alice shouted with her.

“Free the nipples!” Sarah added.

“Show feet!” Noelle said.

Fuck me… For a split second I almost believed I’d screwed up again, that I was being the same, lame and boring guy as always. But the girls all had grins on their faces, and those shouts… Dammit, it was funny. This was different. It wouldn’t be a repeat of that one time, or a repeat of what happened when we played Never Have I Ever with the guys.

Yes. This was going to be fun.

Author's Note: Please consider supporting me on Patreon, as it lets me continue writing stories.