Game stopper

As soon as Emma said truth it seemed like Grace paused for a moment and readied herself to ask a question she already had prepared, not looking like Emma earlier as she struggled to think of something.

“Have you and Max had sex yet?” Grace asked, bringing her glass of wine up to her lips to take a sip, hiding her expression in the process.

With a question like that, you knew this must have been on Grace’s mind for a while but you couldn’t get a read on her expression as you both waited to see how Emma would answer.

“Well, err…” Emma stumbled, looking at you as if she was asking for help.

“Max can’t answer for you” Grace warned, most likely knowing the answer based on Emma’s reaction but still wanting to hear it from her herself.

“We…have” Emma sheepishly responded, cradling her drink and essentially finishing it off as she didn’t want to meet Grace’s eyes.

That left you in the uncomfortable position of having to look up and see if she was already staring at you but she had her eyes locked on Emma, no anger in them but seemingly concern and something else you couldn’t quite figure out.

“I know I wouldn’t have wanted to have that conversation with my parents but…was there any reason you didn’t feel you could tell me?” Grace asked, the conversation turning more serious.

You didn’t need another reminder that Grace deeply cared for Emma but her reaction showed that she did perfectly, even if that felt a bit silly when you were sat there naked and the two of them were down to their underwear.

“Probably the same reason you didn’t tell me about your college stories. The timing never felt right and it wasn’t exactly something I could casually bring up” Emma replied, now looking up to meet her mother’s eye.

This felt like a moment you shouldn’t have been intruding on but in the same way Grace had stumbled upon her roommate, you felt that any movement to back away would only make your presence known, forcing you to stay where you were.

The moment finally seemed to pass when Grace put her glass to one side and crawled closer to Emma, giving you a great view of her ass as she moved over to her. It felt inappropriate for a moment to think like that but even with the serious mood, you still noticed that the way she crawled was definitely aimed at enticing you, even moving over to Emma’s other side so her ass facing you while she spoke to Emma.

They again exchanged whispers that you were unsure if you would have wanted to overhear even if you could and you just waited for them to speak, trying to give them some extra privacy if you could help it.

When they both shot a glance your way at the same time however, you then didn’t feel as bad about wanting to hear their conversation, now trying to strain your hearing to get even a slight sound of what they were talking about.

“…you’re on birth control right… ...Was he?... …not now but…” you heard, murmurs between the two of them that started as Grace’s concern but as Emma seemed to get more confident, the number of glances heading your way became more common.

“I feel like you’re just talking about me at this point” you commented, the looks making you speak up before you got too self-conscious again.

“We are but give us a minute. You’ll like the outcome, I promise” Grace replied with a grin, going back to speaking with Emma but the acknowledgement was enough to dissuade your fears.

It felt like they were talking for a lot longer than they probably were but eventually they both seemed to nod in agreement, the two of them turning towards you with Grace being the one to start speaking, pretending to clear her throat to get your attention even if you were already fully looking at her.

“Given that all of us had already had a conversation about you being open with what you get up to and letting me be involved even if it’s just to keep an eye on you, I have no issues with you having sex. I already knew Emma was on birth control so as long as you continue being safe then I don’t have an issue” Grace started to say, the parental speech coming first before you saw a smirk start to inch onto her lips.

“But, that doesn’t solve the change in mood that’s happened for our party games. At Emma’s suggestion, we want to give you the choice. Either we carry on with truth or dare, But, we only do dares that involve commanding someone to do something to you. For example if Emma was daring someone, they would have to do something to or for Emma” Grace explained, holding up one finger as she spoke before holding up the second.

“Or, we end the game and You are the only one that gets to give us both commands” Grace announced, letting the silence settle between the three of you to show that there was any other caveat to the second idea.

“So I just get to tell you what to do? No catch?” you asked, not quite Grace would go for something like that.

“Yep. Or you can give us the chance to take the reins. It depends how bossy you want to be” Grace replied, the smirk she had almost taunting you to take the more selfish option.

You still didn’t believe it but looking away from Grace and towards Emma, showed that she clearly had a preference on what you should pick. Emma tried not to be too obvious with Grace next to her but she frantically nodded her head, almost as if she was shaking with how little she was actually moving her head.

“And you will do ‘anything’ I tell you?” you questioned, feeling the need to taunt Grace back now that you knew Emma was excited for it and it wasn’t a complete trap.

“I…I’m not gonna tell you what they are but I have something in mind that I’m not willing to do tonight” Grace replied, the word tonight giving you some hope that whatever she wasn’t willing to do now, she would be in the future.

“I’ll let you do anything!” Emma interrupted, her eagerness still showing but the trust she had in you was still a good confidence booster.

“So, what’s the decision?” Grace said, wanting your answer.

Both options were clearly going to lead to some more fun but being fully in charge of the two for the evening seemed too tempting to pass up. You were a bit curious about what dares Emma or Grace would continue to come up with if the game continued but still, that curiosity wasn’t enough to make you change your mind on what you truly wanted.