Fair is the lily of the valley

“Carly, what are you doing?!” Marley demanded, struggling against her sister. She tried to push herself off, but in her pinned position she couldn’t get any leverage.

“I’m giving you what you want, little sister,” Carly calmly replied. She turned and looked up at Nick. “Nick, I know my sister is saying she doesn’t want this, but she’s really just shy. She’s too afraid of telling the truth.”

“No!” Marley protested, squirming in her sister’s grasp. “Shut up!”

“What are you talking about?” Nick asked. No matter how hot it was that Carly was holding her half-naked sister down for him to have sex with her, he couldn’t go through with something like this! It was sick and wrong!

“Marley, be honest,” Carly said, looking down into Marley’s eyes. “Do you have feelings for Nick? Yes or no?”

Marley turned red and broke her sister’s gaze. She bit her lip, refusing to say.

Carly sighed and looked up at Nick, giving him a “well, what are you gonna do?” kind of expression. “She’s being really stubborn,” she explained sadly.

“I think you should just let her go,” Nick said. He had no idea what Marley really wanted, but he doubted she wanted something like this.

But Carly was adamant.

“She’s in denial!” She insisted. “I know my sister! She wants to be with you, she just doesn’t think you want her, since she’s not in your harem anymore.”

“Of course he doesn’t want me!” Marley spat, her judgment lapsing momentarily so she could chew out her sister. She inadvertently said the quiet part out loud.

“There, you see?” Carly nodded down to Marley. “Sis, I know you! You had feelings for him all the way back in college! Not to mention, with Mimi…”

“N-no!” Marley stammered, flushing even deeper. Her blush spread all the way to her chest. “You can’t use Mimi against me!”

“Why not? You’re the same person, right? With the same feelings?” Carly pointed out. “Or are you going to tell me that you got all those points from platonic snuggles?”

Nick remembered the scintillating boobjob Mimi had given him, among other things. She’d certainly seemed into it. And judging by the embarrassed way Marley tried to wiggle her arms around her legs to cover her chest, she seemed to remember it too.

“That… that was…” Marley was on the brink of tears. She hated this! She hated that her sister would do something like this…

Give her hope like this.

I’m just a spare. Why would Nick want me, when he has someone like her? Even if he did want me… wouldn’t it just be because we’re twins? He just wants a matched set…

A tear fell down her cheek. It didn’t go unnoticed by Carly or Nick.

“She’s crying,” he hissed to Marley’s captor, but Carly shook her head.

“Marley, it’s fine,” she urged her sister. “I’m doing this because I want you to go first. You need this. You need to know that Nick, he doesn’t see you as just another me. He’s not like those shitty guys who put the moves on you in school. He genuinely cares about you. Not because you’re my sister. And I want you to go first, so you can see that for yourself.”

Marley sniffled, and her eyes watered even more. She shook, not sure if she was prepared to confront these feelings.

“But… he doesn’t even know me,” she whispered. She felt like she knew him completely, but there was no way he’d ever paid enough attention to her to know anything about her.

“Marley…” Nick walked over to the bed and looked into her eyes, just to make sure she wasn’t really afraid. What he saw when he looked at her was complex. He didn’t see fear, but he saw a lot of other things. Anxiety, worry, and doubt, but also excitement, passion, and hope.

Carly was right. Marley wanted to be with him; she just wasn’t ready to accept it yet.

“Don’t **** her,” Carly begged. “She…”

“I wouldn’t do something like that,” Nick assured her. He reached down, surprised that she didn’t flinch as his hand drew near. She almost seemed to be arching her body up towards him, like she was **** for his touch. A response from Marley herself? A physical reaction from her body she had no control over? Or even a vestige of Mimi’s desire for contact, perhaps?

Whatever it was, he didn’t oblige it. Rather than grabbing a handful of her creamy breasts, he reached down and stroked her cheek.

“Haaah…” A sigh escaped her lips and her eyes turned glassy. She looked expectantly up at him, and it seemed like part of her haze of doubt had faded away. Her desire was stronger now, and she seemed to no longer be fighting Carly as much.

“I still remember when we were talking about flowers that night in Carly’s dorm room,” Nick reminisced, earning a wide-eyed from the pale girl beneath him. “Remember rosa x alba?”

Her lips curled up into a smile. “A rose by any other name…” She sighed nostalgically.

Nick smiled back. “…Would smell as sweet, yeah.”

“What are you two talking about? Roses? Huh?” Carly asked, a little miffed. She was glad there was bonding going on in front of her, but she also felt left out of the conversation.

…Or maybe she should be happy about that. It was what she wanted, after all, for Marley to step out of her shadow and be with Nick on her own, right?

“It’s a line from Shakespeare, you dolt,” Marley groaned, rolling her eyes. “Romeo and Juliet. ‘That which we call a rose / By any other name would smell as sweet.’ That’s what it means.”

“You guys saw a play? Instead of going to a party?”

“It’s a type of flower,” Nick said, not taking his eyes off Marley’s flushed face. “A white rose. Marley told me all about the different kinds of roses, and… well…”

Marley nodded and bit her lip. “Red roses… symbolize love… passion… romance… but white roses, they represent purity and innocence.”

She gazed longingly up into Nick’s eyes. “I told him that I always felt like the white rose in comparison to you. Everyone was passionate about you, in love with you, they all desired you, but me… I was just pure and innocent and unwanted.”

“That’s when I told her that line from Shakespeare,” Nick murmured. “Just because she’s a rose by another name, that doesn’t mean she’s not desirable herself.”

“Kind of butchered that quote there, Mr. Author,” Marley pointed out with a grin.

Carly rolled her eyes and groaned. “Ugh. Nerds!” They were flirting with each other in nerd speak. And yet she couldn’t help but smile at the most adorable thing she’d ever seen.

Marley gazed up at Nick, stunned he’d remembered such a tender moment between them. That conversation, when he’d told her that she could be loved for herself, had been what made her fall for him. But she had no idea it was so meaningful for Nick as well.

Maybe… maybe she wasn’t wrong. Maybe there was something real here. Maybe she could want this.

Then she realized she was having this touching moment while her legs were being held up in the air by her sister and her pussy was on full display, only hid by a couple thin layers of cloth. She burst into awkward laughter and squirmed, embarrassed.

“I-I think… I’m ready now,” she murmured, moving her hands from her face. “If you… if you want to, I mean. Be with me. You don’t have to… it’s not like having sex with me will get Carly any points, and I’m sure you’d probably prefer doing it with her, and-”

She was growing more determined to talk them both out of it by the second so Nick did the only thing he could think of and leaned down, planting his lips on hers. That shut her up good and she stared up at him in wide-eyed shock.

Then when the shock wore off she began kissing back, filling her mouth with his tongue. She squirmed and strained against Carly’s grip, but for an entirely different reason this time. Now, she wanted as much of Nick as she could get.

“Hah… hah…!” She gasped as he pulled away from her. She raised her head to try and follow him, but Carly held her down. “More… please! Please, more, I can’t take it!” She begged. “I want it so badly!”

“I think she’s finally ready,” Carly purred with a wicked chuckle. Nick glanced down at Marley for confirmation and she swallowed, nodding her head.

“Yes,” she whispered softly. “Please…”

He didn’t need anything more than that as an invitation. He eagerly reached down, stripping off his clothes, and moved to take off Marley’s. An action rendered difficult by the fact that she was being held in place by her sister.

Nick guessed this was one of Carly’s outfits (since Marley hardly had anything to her name) and checked with her just to be safe. “Carly, these pantyhose-”

“Rip right through ‘em,” Carly said impatiently.

“What?! Are you sure? But-”

“Just do it!” She growled. Carly didn’t have time for Nick to work off a set of pantyhose! She was getting hot for this herself! It honestly surprised her; normally she only got this turned on when the sex involved her, but seeing Nick play with her sister like this was really scratching an itch she didn’t know she had.

Speaking of scratching, Nick used his fingernails to begin scraping away at Marley’s pantyhose as she squirmed beneath him. Soon he was able to get a good run and pulled it open, revealing the black panties beneath. A quick tugged and he exposed her sopping lips to the air.

She let out a gasp and sucked in air, feeling his eyes on her most sensitive spot. It was a pussy, a human pussy. Marley had memories of her vagina going back for as long as she could remember, but in the back of her head, she knew that it was brand-new; a gift, just for her, as a reward for becoming human.

And now Nick was staring at it. He was touching it! He was-

“Hyaahn!” Marley arched her back and squirted slightly, feeling Nick’s tongue dip inside her cunny. She had no idea she was so soaked! She must have been producing more juices than when she was a slime! She squirmed underneath his touch and arched her back, pushing herself against his mouth and trying to get him even deeper inside. Moan after moan escaped her lips as she imagined him doing so much more with her.

“Please…” She begged, thrusting her hips as best she could. It was hard to do while her sister held her, but it was a sign of how **** she was.

“I think she’s done with foreplay,” Carly giggled, spreading her sister’s legs even wider. “Let’s move onto the main event, shall we?”

Marley could only nod and squeak as she squirmed with excitement. Her eyes were frozen on Nick’s throbbing shaft. She’d experienced it a couple times before, but those had been as a slime girl. She hadn’t properly felt his heat as a human yet, but she could feel it now. And it was making her hot in turn.

“Please.” That seemed like all she could say at this point, and Nick was happy to oblige her. He moved up so he was looking her right in the eyes, seeing how helpless she was to resist. And she loved it! Being held at Carly’s mercy, offered up on a silver platter for Nick’s delight…

She felt like a flower about to be plucked. An analogy not that far from the truth, now that she thought about it.

“Just… be gentle,” she requested, bracing herself for when Nick inserted his throbbing hot rod into her moist insides.

Nick nodded, and went as gently as he could. He leaned forward, pushing the head of his cock against her petals, surprised by how readily she opened up for him. She must have wanted this badly. He could still taste her sticky juices on his tongue; it reminded him of honey, or maybe sap. How fitting for a girl who had once been a plant.

And the warmth was something else. He pushed deeper inside, feeling her squeeze in response, and then saw her wince. A moment later he arrived at a thin membrane and knew what that signified.

“Are you sure?” He asked one last time.

“Yes! She’s sure!” Carly cried, having half a mind to shove the rest of him in herself.

“Yes! I’m sure!” Marley echoed, thrusting up into him as he pushed down into her. She let out a yip as her hymen tore, and Nick pushed himself another inch deeper inside her. He hadn’t bottomed out yet, but it was coming.

And so was Marley.

“Hyaan!” She moaned, feeling a wave of pleasure rush over her. She’d never felt this way before. Oh, she’d masturbated in the past, but those had just been memories implanted into her head. And when she was Mimi, physical sensations had never felt quite as… visceral as they did now. Oh certainly, she’d had them (she wasn’t completely a slime, after all) but this was her first real burst of pleasure as a human, and it was glorious.

Carly could tell how much her sister was enjoying herself, and that made her feel even hotter. Damn, this is really something, she thought, her eyes glued to the copulation of the two people closest to her. She couldn’t look away. I had no idea that watching two people have sex could be this… wow!

She felt a throb in her loins, and wished desperately that she could be in Marley’s place right now, getting her world rocked the way her sister surely was.

…

Maybe there was a way she could.

“Hey now, sis.” She leaned down to whisper into her sister’s ear, just loud enough for Nick to hear as well over the sound of his grunts and Marley’s moans. When Marley felt Carly’s breath on her cheek she froze up, while her walls tightened even more around Nick’s shaft. His cock throbbed in response, sending another wave of pleasure rolling over her.

She could only squeak out a reply to Carly.

“Feels good, doesn’t it?” Carly continued. “Having a man inside you for the first time…” She let out a breathy moan. “Having… Nick inside you for the first time…”

Marley bit her lip to suppress her moans and nodded frantically.

“He’s quite good, isn’t he?” Carly chuckled. “Knows all the right places to touch a girl in there, to maximize her pleasure… I bet you’ve never felt anything better, isn’t that right?”

Carly was pretty much bullshitting right now. Sure Nick was good, but that was back when he just had a normal penis. Carly hadn’t had sex with him yet since his Skeleton Key transformation, and she bet that would make him feel even better.

She clenched her thighs together and squirmed as she watched Marley’s face distort with pleasure. She was glad her sister was savoring the moment, but when would it be her turn, damn it?!

“Uhg, Marley, you’re so tight…” Nick groaned, trying to push deeper into her. It was like trying to push through molasses. Her walls squeezed down so hard it was like she was trying to push him out while sucking him in at the same time. He hadn’t even managed to get all the way inside yet.

“I bet she is,” Carly moaned, working herself up even more. “You’re the one who plucked her precious flower, after all… she’s tight as a virgin… nothing like mine, isn’t that right?”

What the hell was she doing? She wasn’t into that cuck shit. She loved being the center of attention, sex was supposed to be all about her! And yet, for the first time, she had someone she wanted him to focus on more.

I guess being a sister changes you, huh?

“Yeah, fuck… there’s no… no comparison…” Nick groaned, pushing another inch inside her as she moaned and thrashed.

The burst of pleasure that came with his acknowledgment of that fact had Carly seeing stars. Damn, she wanted more of that spicy flavor!

“Keep going,” she panted. “Tell me… who’s better? Her or me? After all… she’s so tight… a virgin… she’s gotta be amazing, yeah? Fuck, I wonder how good it would have felt if you were my first time?” Carly was picturing that now, and the image nearly brought her to orgasm. “Fuck… Marley… you’re so fucking lucky…”

“Please!” Marley moaned, so far out of it she couldn’t even register her sister’s words at that point. “More! Please, I-ughn! Oh! YES! Right there!” She bucked her hips and clutched the sheets, not able to do much more than that with her arms pinned beneath her legs. For as helpless as she was, she was making quite a good try for Nick’s pleasure.

“Nick!” Carly was moaning too. “Come on… she’s better than me, right? Isn’t she amazing?! Or am I…?”

Honestly she had no idea what answer would turn her on more. Is this what being Holly is like 24/7?

“Ungh… I… oh, fuck, Marley! God, you’re so fucking good!” Nick moaned, answering Carly’s question inadvertently and causing her to moan. But that wasn’t what he meant.

The truth was, he had no idea which of them was “better”. Being inside Carly felt like slipping his penis inside a warm, wet hole designed to milk him of his body fluids in seconds. She had practice and experience and her pussy sucked on his cock like a succubus dying of thirst. Marley was different. Her insides were sticky and tight, clinging to him like a second skin and causing every movement forward to feel like a hard-won victory of pleasure.

There was no comparing them. They were each their own unique flavor of perfect.

He bottomed out inside of her finally and the chorus of their moans blended together. He practically crushed her into the bed, bearing down on her so hard he thought he’d pound her into slime again. Her breasts pushed out through the gap between her legs, two soft cushions to brake his momentum as their chests mashed against each other and their tongues danced together in a sloppy, moan-filled kiss.

Carly winced. Kissing had always been a no-go for her. A form of intimacy she wasn’t comfortable sharing with her sex friends. She’d kissed Nick to get a point and as a thank-you for how he helped her, but… she’d never been so hungry about it. And Marley did it so casually…

“Ugh, fuck… this is so fucking hot…” Carly leaned back and decided enough was enough. She was the only person in this three-way not getting any actual pleasure and she wouldn’t stand for it! She finally let Marley go, bringing one hand down to her pussy while the other began kneading the fleshy mounds she called her breasts. Her pleasured moans joined Nick and Marley’s and the three of them raced towards their climaxes together.

“More…” Marley gasped, hungry for as much physical sensation as she could get. “MORE!”

Her legs were free now, and she snapped them up around Nick’s waist to pull him even deeper inside of her. At the same time her arms clung to his back as she desperately crammed her breasts into his chest, pushing against him until the sweat between their bodies practically turned into glue.

“Fuck, sis…” Carly groaned, flicking her clit as she dug deeper into herself with one hand, twisting the nipple of her left breast with the other. “I knew you wanted him so fucking bad, fuck… you’ve been so fucking repressed it’s like you’re dying for it!”

Carly had seen her ravenous sister devour more food than should be humanly possible, but apparently all that binge eating was just practice for this moment right now. Nick was Marley’s meal, and she was savoring every succulent morsel she could gorge herself on.

“CUMMING!” Marley screamed at the top of her lungs as his thrusts drove her to what felt like her fiftieth orgasm of the night. Her tight walls squeezed even tighter until it felt like she was going to snap his penis in half.

“Fuck, yeah… I-I’m cumming too, I… OH FUCK!” Carly arched her back, spraying her sister’s face with her juices. Completely drained, she slumped back against the headboard to try and catch her breath. She’d never had an orgasm this intense that didn’t involve getting some dick. Meanwhile, Nick and Marley were still going as strong as ever. Her sister kept coming her brains out, enjoying her first taste of a man with more passion and drive than Carly had during her first time.

It actually kind of pissed her off she was getting it so good.

“You shouldn’t sleep around so much, sis! You should save yourself for the person you love!” How many times had her sister chastised her like that? Well, maybe she’d been onto something after all.

Carly felt a little hazy, and took a short breather. She nearly fell asleep to the rhythmic sounds of flesh slapping against flesh and the moan of two lovers locked in tight embrace when Nick said something that caused her blood to freeze.

“Marley, fuck… I’m… I’m gonna fucking cum-!” He gasped, his thrusts intensifying. Carly’s eyes snapped open.

Oh, hell no! Having sex with Nick was one thing. But Carly would be damned if he was going to cum inside her. If Marley got pregnant… no, she didn’t even want to think that way.

“Pull out!” She cried. Nick looked up at her, and worry flashed in his eyes. She could see they were on the same page here.

“Marley!” Nick shouted a little louder, and Carly could see now that his intense thrusts were actually him trying to pull himself out of her. “Come on! Let me go, I need to pull out! I can’t cum inside!”

“Fuck! Aangh, yeah! Fuck! You’re making me cum so hard!” Marley wouldn’t be negotiated with. Carly was only half-sure her sister was conscious; it seemed like the girl was so focused on the pleasure from her fucking that she didn’t even think of asking him to cum outside.

Been there. Done that. And she wasn’t about to let it happen to her sister.

“Marley… fuck!” Nick was nearing his limit. He was trying to hold on as long as possible, but if Marley kept him sealed up tight in one of her cuddles for much longer it wouldn’t matter what he wanted. He was going to cum inside her.

As he felt himself go over the edge, Marley shrieked in his ear as she came, and he lamented the desperation for physical contact she’d inherited from Mimi.

Then all he saw was white. He felt the warm, sticky sensation of semen flood over his dick as he came more than he ever had before. The whole blanket was stained with a giant white puddle, and-

…Wait.

Where did Marley go!? The girl he’d just been fucking was nowhere to be seen. A big pile of slime soaked into the bed, and his dick spat semen out into it, mixing with the warm, sweet-smelling fluid. A stained red wig and lay in the middle of the puddle.

“Fuck… that was… too fucking close.”

Nick looked up to see that Carly had disappeared as well. He glanced over his shoulder and saw her on the other side of the room, panting to catch her breath.

“Carly, you…?”

“I had to,” she said weakly, approaching the bed. “If I didn’t turn her back into slime, then you might have cum inside her, and then…”

It was a gamble that she wasn’t even sure would have worked. Hell, what would happen if Marley DID get pregnant and turned into slime somehow? Carly didn’t even want to think about that.

When she got within ten feet of the bed Marley reformed, looking a little dazed and confused.

“Wuzzat?” She looked around, blinking. “What happened?”

“Carly, uh… she gave you quite a unique climax,” Nick said, not quite sure how to describe what else could have happened.

“Wait, so… you bitch!” Marley exclaimed. “I was so close, and you just turned me into slime?!”

“Don’t you take that tone with me!” Carly snapped. “If I hadn’t done something he would have cum inside you, and where would you be then? You could be pregnant, is that what you want?”

Marley winced, not having a response to that. “Well… then I get another turn! It’s only fair, since you spoiled mine!”

Carly smirked. “Oh, no you don’t!” She pounced on Nick, pushing him over and mounting him with a wicked grin on her face. “It’s my turn to get some of that now!”

She hesitated and glanced at her sister, who was watching eagerly. Then Carly leaned down and planted a kiss on Nick’s lips.

Fuck. Kissing felt even better when sex was imminent.